AdventAI

WHAT WOULD IT BE?

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 9., February 26, 1889

The bone and muscle of the National Reform movement are very sensitive over the charge that a union of church and state would be the result of the success of their movement. But their attempts to explain away the charge, and dodge the issue, do not seem to affect the ideas of the generality of the people; for scarcely one in a hundred who discusses the subject from a Constitutional stand-point, fails to devote a part of his effort to the discussion of the question of church and state in this country, as if that were so evidently involved in the project as not to admit of any question at all. The Press, of Cleveland, O., in its issue of Feb. 12, 1889, replies to an article in the Cleveland Leader, which advocates the teaching of the Christian religion by law in the public schools. The Press charges the Leader with advocating, in this movement, a union of church and state, which the framers of the Constitution had the good sense to avoid. It says:—

“Some religious instruction should find a place in them.” Thus the Leader concludes a long article upon the public schools. Let us see where this would lead. The public schools are the creation of law. Whatever is taught in them is provided by law. Law is the result of the public will as expressed at the ballot-box. Therefore, it follows that if religion is to be taught in the common schools, it must be the religion of those who hold the greatest number of votes. This would mean that in some localities one kind of religion would be taught, while in others, other kinds would be taught. When majorities changed, the sort of religion given out in the schools would change. Does the Leader want a religion of majorities propagated at the expense of all? Would not this result in a denial of the right of conscience in a matter the most serious of all matters with most people? Suppose the Leader could have its way, and have religion taught in the public schools; and suppose the writer of the Leader article had a child which attended school, and in that school a style of religion was taught which was obnoxious to the said Leader writer. How would he like it? The hostility of the Leader to some forms of the Christian religion is too well known to make it necessary to consider further how it would like to take its own medicine in such a case. Nor is the Leader alone in the matter of religious prejudice. Probably seven out of ten of all people of adult age have ardent likes and dislikes on this subject. The framers of the National Constitution well understood what State-made religion meant, and they, therefore, concluded to have no union of church and state in this country. What the Leader advocates is what the framers of the Constitution intended to avoid, and what 100 years of experience have shown to have been wisdom. Politics are bad enough now, with their elements of office-seeking and business greed as factors to sway men's actions at the polls. To interject the rivalries and intense prejudices of religious opinion into elections, would be a thing so serious that one cannot forbear concluding that the article from which the above quotation is taken was written with more reference to local popularity than as a serious general proposition of good policy.