The following anecdote is not given simply as an interesting evidence of the understanding and reasoning faculties possessed by the brute creation, but also because it has an important bearing on a great question of theology. It is strenuously urged by multitudes that man in his natural constitution possesses an immaterial entity, capable of existing without the body, and destined to live forever, which they call “the immortal soul.” And in proof of this assertion they point to the mental phenomena exhibited by men, their power to think, will, reason, etc., claiming that matter cannot think, and it must be an immaterial and immortal part which performs these acts. In view of this claim, it is an interesting process to point them to such instances as the following, and try to secure from them an answer to the question whether they consider that brutes also have immortal souls; for they can understand speech, and reason upon it in a manner altogether beyond the sphere of what is called instinct. The following is a case in point:—
A good dog story comes from Manchester. A bright-witted girl telephoned to her father at his office, asking if her dog “Curly” was there. Reply came that he was. “Well, take him up in your arms, and hold the receiver to his ear; I want to tell him to come home,” said the girl. Her father did so. The dog’s countenance wore, momentarily, a look of astonishment at hearing: “Come home, Curly; come home!” in the familiar tones of his mistress, but it took him only an instant to understand what was wanted, and, the door of the office being opened, he made a wild break for home as fast as he could go.
A writer in Nature gives the following, which, though of a different nature, exhibits equal intelligence. He says:—
“In my family we had a tabby cat, who, when turned out, would let herself in at another door by climbing up some listing nailed round it, then pressing up the click-latch, push the door, with herself hanging on it, away from the post, so as to prevent the latch from falling back into its place, and then dropping down, walk back to the fire. I knew a Skye terrier who, being told to carry a fishing-rod, carefully experimented along its length, to find its center of gravity. In carrying it, he came to a narrow path through a wood. There, dropping the rod, he took it by the end, and dragged it by the end lengthwise till the open road was gained, when he took the rod by the center of gravity again, and went on. This could not be a copy of human actions, but the result of original reasoning.”
Another writer gives the following, on the authority of the late Mr. Dawes, the astronomer:—
“Being busy in his garden, and having a large bunch of keys in his hand, he gave it to a retriever to hold for him till he was at liberty. Going into the house soon after, he forgot to reclaim the keys. The remembrance of what he had done with them only returned to him when he required them in the evening. He then recalled that he had given them to the dog, and forgotten to take them again. Calling the animal, and looking impressively in his face, he said, “My keys! fetch me my keys.” The dog looked wistful and puzzled for a moment, and then bounded off to the garden, his master following. He went straight to the root of an apple tree, scratched up the keys and brought them. May we not fairly put into words the dog’s train of reasoning thus: “My master has given me these keys to hold; he has forgotten them; I cannot carry them all day; but I must put them in safety where I can find them again”?
This not only shows the wonderful power of reasoning suggested, but also the faculty of memory, and the power to receive ideas from language which we may suppose he had, at most, only casually heard. He manifested as much intelligence as many human beings, and a good deal more faithfulness than some.
We leave our friends who hold that the manifestation of reason and intelligence proves that man is immortal, to wrestle with the problem why the same faculties do not prove that cats and dogs are immortal, as well. For ourselves, we simply remark that we rest the evidence of immortality on no such grounds. The manifestation of mind is the result of organization only, in connection with the vital processes. Man has an organization so much superior to the brute creation that he becomes possessed of a moral nature also. But this does not give him immortality. That depends on how he uses this moral nature; for immortality comes alone through Christ; and he will confer it upon those only, who, on the condition of his promises, shall prove themselves entitled to the same.