HOW THE U. S. CONSTITUTION IS AMENDED

20%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 16, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 16.

Read the full edition

HOW THE U. S. CONSTITUTION IS AMENDED.

It may not be clear in the minds of many of our readers who are looking for the enactment of a religious amendment to the Constitution of the United States, by what steps a proposed amendment to our Constitution must pass from its introduction in Congress to a place of authority in the fundamental law of the land, if it is sufficiently favored by fortune to do so. To such we present the following information on this point, taken from an editorial in the April Century:—
As this is one of our eras of great striving and cry for reforms of various kinds, it is probable that we shall hear a great many proposals of amendments to the Constitution of the United States, as if the suggestion of even the best of amendments gave it any more real chance of life than as if it were meritless. It is therefore necessary to retain, as a very prominent element of our political consciousness, the knowledge that the adoption of any isolated amendment is now a matter of such enormous difficulty as to be practically impossible. The time may come when some amendment shall evidently have behind it, as in the case of the Civil War amendments, so general a popular and party interest as to “rush” it over all the inevitable obstacles; but that time is not now. The reform which is limited to the road of Constitutional amendment may besiege the entrance to it until it dies of inanition; it must abandon hope long before it even enters.
The very first difficulties are those of mere constitutional machinery, which Sir H. S. Maine has stated with so much Tory gusto that his statement has already become classical. They are obstacles which the people imposed upon their own action in the original Constitution in order to guard against what was supposed, a century ago, to be democracy’s characteristic turbulence and impatient desire for change. A change in the English Constitution, no matter how radical, needs only a majority vote in the two houses of Parliament; and in practice a determined majority in the House of Commons will insure a majority in both houses. A change in the American Constitution demands, at the very beginning, a two-thirds’ majority in both houses of Congress. Every one familiar with such matters knows that the difficulty of getting a two-thirds’ majority in either house is far more than a geometrical increase over that of getting a simple majority; and that a two-thirds’ majority in both houses is a difficulty almost geometrically greater still. Here the framers of the Constitution might have stopped, but they did not. They provided that the amendment, after passing the gauntlet of Congress, should not be valid until ratified by three-fourths of the State legislatures. As there are now thirty-eight States, three-fourths means twenty-nine; and, as each of these bodies have two absolutely independent houses, this means that the budding amendment must find friends to introduce it, champions to fight for it, and a majority to support it, in each of fifty-eight separate legislative bodies, each with its peculiar interest, prejudices, and characteristics.
It will be seen from this how thoroughly the Sunday question is bound to be agitated in every State and Territory before the proposed religious amendment to the United States Constitution can become an established fact; and this agitation means an agitation of the question of the Bible Sabbath and a diffusion of the light on this and other important points of the third angel’s message to a degree which would scarcely be possible under other circumstances. With the difficulties in the way of the establishment of an amendment to the Constitution, we need not concern ourselves. If the image of the beast is to be formed in that way, the amendment will pass, as surely as God’s word is true; nor can we judge of the length of time which will be required, so long as we do not know the strength of the forces which will be employed in pushing forward the church and state movement, when all is in readiness for the final conflict of the remnant church with the powers arrayed against her.