Out of the developments of the recent past in the domain of current political reforms, have come two opposite results the significance of which it is impossible to overlook. One is the utter and signal failure of the movement for prohibition, under the crushing weight of nine consecutive reverses. Michigan and Massachusetts, Texas and Tennessee; Oregon, West Virginia, New Hampshire, and Pennsylvania have decided against it, with ever-increasing majorities; and Rhode Island has torn from her constitution the prohibitory statute, after allowing it a brief existence of three years. The other is the almost equally signal success of the movement for Sunday prohibition, which has brought about the absolute closing of the saloons on that day in some of the largest and most rum-ruled cities of the Union. Cincinnati may be mentioned as an example.
The situation presents some features which arep. 425 rather anomalous. It shows us the same parties opposing prohibition on the one hand, and on the other hand maintaining it, the difference being not in the kind of prohibition, but only in the amount. A small quantity of a good thing appears to be better than a large amount of it. That which is good and very desirable on one day of the week, is very undesirable on other days. Public sentiment seems capable of facing both ways on the same question.
Sunday prohibition, too, evidently prohibits, while we are told that week-day prohibition does not prohibit, notwithstanding the statement of a prominent city official of Philadelphia, that “it would be just as easy to enforce prohibition in Philadelphia on all the week-days as on Sunday, and easier, as the vast multitude of the working class who frequent open saloons on Sunday are, on the week-days, in their places of employment during the day, and many of them at their homes in the evening.”
The facts point very definitely to one conclusion—Prohibition is being sacrificed in the interests of Sunday. The forces which should have been employed to do battle for the former, have been largely perverted in the interests of the latter. Prominent and talented speakers have been called off from the great theme of prohibition to give a part, if not all, of their time to the championing of Sunday; and the powerful organization of the W. C. T. U. has formed a political alliance, and is devoting a part of its much-needed energies, and a very large part, it seems, to the maintenance of a “Sabbath Observance Department.” Small wonder that, with such divided support, the cause of prohibition fails to make that advancement which had been hoped.
The action of the nine States we have mentioned, represents the true state of public sentiment on the question of simple prohibition; the action of our large cities and towns in the closing of their saloons, represents an apparent public sentiment in favor of prohibition, but a real sentiment in favor of the enforced observance of Sunday. Public sentiment cannot be educated in both directions at once; and when there is any gain made in the latter, there is a loss experienced in the former for which it in no degree compensates. L. A. S.