THE COMING CRISIS IN EUROPE.
By John Vuilleumier
And now, if it is at all necessary to destroy the illusive charm which the pope has brought to bear to win again from the world an almost unlimited prestige, it will be sufficient to mention two facts. The first is the unswerving fidelity with which Leo XIII. has followed, on doctrinal and ecclesiastical grounds, the course pursued by Pius IX.; it is the zeal with which he has prosecuted, in all Catholic countries, the establishment of the ultramontane principles. At present, this victory of ultramontanism is universal among the devotees of Rome. It is especially complete in France, where the opposition to papal absolutism was perhaps the strongest. “The history of religious thought in French Catholicism since the beginning of the century,” says Dr. E. de Pressensé in his Encyclopédie des Sciences Religieuses, “may be summed up in the growing and finally blazing and decisive doctrinal triumph of ultramontanism. This triumph has been obtained by the Romish court in all countries and by similar means.” The second fact speaks louder than words could speak. It is the pontifical brief, dated July 13, 1886, by which Leo XIII., this liberal pope, the modern airs of whom have blinded all the world, has solemnly restored to all its frightful privileges, the Society of the Jesuits—the organization extant the most subversive of modern liberties, yea, of morals; but also the most fanatically devoted to the triumph of papal theocracy, and which Pope Clement XIV. had abolished in 1773 upon the earnest entreaties of all European governments. This brief sketch would be incomplete if we did not say a few words of the progress of Catholicism in Protestant lands. After what we have seen of its political success in Germany, we cannot wonder at the following words, written in the Evangelical Ecclesiastical Journal, by Stoecker, the well-known court preacher in Berlin:— For years we have seen the Catholic Church in Germany undergoing a marked development, and steadily gaining preponderancy. At the very time when our church threatens giving out under the indifference of the enlightened classes and the hatred of the working classes, Rome has gained the sympathies of the nobility, the princes, the citizens, the peasants, and the laborers. . . . Again, the church has gained a large influence on social ground. . . . It is looked upon as the soul of great economical reforms and the initiator of the great social regenerations. . . . It is beyond dispute that the Catholic Church has considerably outgrown the Protestant Church. She seeks to maintain this advantage. Her activity grows visibly. She is petted by the courts, sought after by the parliaments, loved by the people. In Norway, the current of public opinion is also setting toward Catholicism; this fact is so conspicuous that not long ago a professor at the University of Christiana could say, without meeting contradiction, in a numerous society,—that after a century all Norway would have returned to Catholicism. This fact has been recorded without gainsaying by influential continental papers. In Switzerland, according to the Federal census of 1888, the Catholics are alarmingly on the increase in Protestant cantons. The Journal de Genève said not long ago (July 1887):— Who would have said ten years ago, that we should once see the two chambers of the Swiss Federal Assembly presided over by the deputies of two Catholic cantons, and that one of them, the State Council, would have its bureau made up with two Catholics? . . . What is still more singular, one of these two Catholic deputies is the representative of the city of Calvin. To conclude this part of our subject, we will give the grave testimony of the eminent Professor Zahn, from a significant book of his published not long ago, and of which Mr. Appia, Lutheran pastor of Paris, France, says:— The perusal of the book [Dr. Zahn’s] leaves an impression of anxiety; the author shows us, all along the line, Rome preparing for battle, improving all our awkwardness and all our defeats, often turning to advantage our very victories, mending her old armor, as she sees us laying ours down, and menacing to become the religion of an age which wants the forms of religion, without accepting its sacrifices. II. What is the present state of Protestantism in Europe? We will first hear on this subject a man who has been one of its most eminent representatives, Alexander Vinet:— Three centuries of external life should not deceive Protestantism. It is now living on the first and vigorous impulse received in the sixteenth century. It lives on its political antecedents. It lives on the elements of nationality. But this impulse is exhausted. The beams of the framework are disjoined. The edifice is creaking on all sides. The accessory and auxiliary forces are leaving it. Protestantism remains alone, and disorganized. No institution can exist in a disorganized state; no institution can long suffer an organization foreign to its principles. Protestants there are, but Protestantism is no more. These words were written in 1842. What would Vinet have written in 1889? And if he could thus speak, referring simply to the destructive principle of the union of Church and State, what would he have said if he had dealt with the doctrine itself, a thousand times more important than the ecclesiastical organization? Indeed, was it not this distinguished thinker who wrote this simple and profound sentence: “Protestantism as such can be strong only on the condition of being Protestant, and to the extent that it shall be. . . . For Protestantism, evidently, to exist, is to be Protestant.” The question before us would then resolve itself into this: “Does Protestantism remain Protestant, and to what extent?” (In this, only the state churches, the historical churches founded by the Reformers, are taken into account. They embrace by far the great majority of professed Christians in Europe.) We leave it to its most authorized representatives to answer this themselves. A pastor of Geneva, Mr. Chantre, wrote in the Alliance Libérale, at the occasion of the 350th anniversary of the Reformation, in 1882:— Swiftly carried off to-day by an irresistible current, are the doctrines which, in the sixteenth century, were proclaimed by our spiritual ancestors as the truth—truth absolute, truth divine. . . . The fact is general. All around, with more or less frankness, with more or less distinctness, the great doctrines of the Reformation are abandoned in the midst of Protestant churches. . . . Whilst a minority in the Protestant world, in England, in Germany and elsewhere, is, in many respects, drawing near to the Catholic principles, the great majority of Protestants modify, transform, abandon, and even oppose, the old doctrines of Protestant orthodoxy. In the review, already quoted, of Dr. Zahn’s book, we read:— If, after surveying, with the author, the realms of politics, of theology, of church life, among Protestants of our time, we again ask the question, “What is lacking in the Protestantism of to-day?” the answer, brief, and cutting like the book itself, will come back: Everything! It has, particularly, shaken the faith in the word of God, and abandoned the true doctrine of justification by faith, without being able to substitute anything for the solid basis which it has endeavored to shake. Says Felix Kuhn, a noted Lutheran minister in Paris, and historian of Luther:— We have now been at least a hundred years struggling with rationalism, the object of which is to mold the old gospel to the fashion of the day. What has been our success? Alas! we have failed in every direction. The old ideas harmonize no more with the requirements of our science; the new ones are dead as soon as born; and we to-day present the painful spectacle of a great spiritual body which has only contradictory answers to give a world seeking after salvation. Not long ago Edmond Stapfer, author of a new French version of the New Testament, said:— It has been said for a long time, and is perhaps still said, that the Reformation of the sixteenth century rested on two principles—justification by faith, and the authority of the Holy Scriptures. But now justification by faith alone remains. . . . For it must be confessed in all frankness that the belief in a direct inspiration of the Scriptures, making them of authority, has passed its time, and is henceforth no more held. . . . The decease of this doctrine has been already duly recorded, some years ago. To-day, the barriers are broken [wrote in 1885 the Swiss philosopher Charles Secrétan]. A great number of Protestant Christians, the greatest number, probably, still hold the infallibility of the holy books; but theologians do so no more. . . . The old foundation has been duly overthrown, but not the least substitute has as yet been found to put in its place. Rationalism would thus, in Europe, remain master of the situation. Protestantism as a whole, in the persons of its legitimate representatives and leaders, follows this baneful declivity. This transformation has gradually taken place during the last fifty years. Having thus bequeathed its principles to orthodoxy, rationalism as a separate issue may now safely and gloriously disappear. This significant fact was solemnly proclaimed to the religious world on the continent, in June, 1888, by a large and prominent Protestant Review. Thus, at the hour of the last triumphs of Rome, European Protestantism—“which can only be strong on the condition of being Protestant”—finds itself giving up the very principles on which it rests, and which are its condition of existence. This alarming fact calls forth from Dr. Zahn the following conclusion:— The great majority of the orthodox Christians of our time have consequently no authentic mission against Rome, the influence of which extends on every side. They are rather its allies in consequence of their secret pelagianism. Destructive Bible criticism has only to look at the darkness of Rome, invading and bewitching the nations, to realize its perfect weakness. But this situation is still more aggravated by the Romeward aspirations noticeable among many Protestants. The English Ritualistic church, under the influence of which from 500 to 600 clergymen were seen to pass over to Catholicism, in the course of thirty years, has to-day 3,000 representatives in the Church of England; and besides that, it is exerting a serious influence over the “High Church Party,” which includes three-fourths of the English clergy. In June, 1886, the chairman of the “English Church Union” publicly expressed the desire of seeing the Church of England blended with the Church of Rome. The same movement, although at a less degree, has been noticeable on the continent. The “Review of Theology and Philosophy” (French), published at Lausanne, Switzerland, said in 1882: “We see the ecclesiastical government of most of the Protestant churches of Germany, complacently following the Romish track. From what is going on in the most important of the national churches of that country, the old Protestant spirit seems to be absolutely fettered.” In both France and Switzerland, leading Protestants have been heard, of late years, lamenting publicly the feeling of separation which Protestants would fain retain with respect to Catholics, and advising deliberately, not only to cease debating, but to unite with them.468 III. To sum up: All along the line, Romanism is preparing for fight, threatening, encroaching. Protestantism, on the other hand, after having undermined its foundations, seems ready “to lay its armor down.” “From this new condition of the two camps,” Gaussen was able in 1843 to “conclude with certainty that a great contest was preparing,” “a contest of violence against the patience and the faith of the saints.” What part will Protestantism as a whole act in these ominous struggles? It can only be one of two things: either it will suddenly awake all along the line, and return to the principles without which it cannot exist, resuming a tremendous fight against its old adversary; or it will make a compromise with Rome. Nothing makes the former probable; everything tends toward the latter. But where will the adversaries of Rome be? “It will be,” says Gaussen, “the church, to all appearances, vanquished, scattered, reduced to a small number,” which “will have to resume the work of conquering by the preaching of the cross, by patience, and by faith.” It will be the humble company of “Protestants,” such as will have remained uncompromisingly attached to the principles of the Reformation and the apostolic church. There does exist such a remnant of Protestants, we are thankful to believe. They will protest by words and by actions, against both the encroachments and blasphemies of Rome, and the apostasy and compromises of Protestantism. Having Rome and the great masses of Protestants against them, their lot will, for some little time, be extremely trying. But a sure victory is promised them. They know it. The sudden bright and glorious interference of the Son of God will turn the battle to the confusion of the enemies of the truth, and to the everlasting triumph of the happy little flock.