A NEW METHOD OF COMBATING INTEMPERANCE

50%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 4, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 23.

Read the full edition

A NEW METHOD OF COMBATING INTEMPERANCE.

Of all the efforts lately made to diminish the evils of intemperance, none is so interesting as the novel, though not original, experiment which Minnesota is about to try. While one school of reformers is constantly developing new zeal in the attempt to prove that drunkenness is a disease, Minnesota formally declares that it is a crime, and imposes a fine or imprisonment for the first two offenses, and for every subsequent offense imprisonment for not less than sixty or more than ninety days. This experiment is likely to produce some curious results, and is worth a more fearless and efficient trial than it will probably have. It ought to be watched closely by all, and not least so by those who attribute little or no moral responsibility to the drunkard, for it may be expected to throw some valuable light upon their contention. Moreover, it ought not to provoke their immediate resentment; for, supposing that drunkenness is a disease, it does not follow that it may not be best treated by heroic measures. Hysteria is unquestionably a disease, but it is sometimes cured by a shower bath, and aboard ship a cat-o'-nine-tails has been known to produce highly satisfactory results. We are not commending the Minnesota law, but since it is on the statute-books, we hope to see it rigidly applied so long as it remains there. Even more than most legislation, it will depend, whether for its practical results or its indirect lessons, upon the impartiality with which it is enforced. If it is simply made a convenient means of putting bibulous and disreputable nobodies out of sight, it will not amount to much in the way either of reform or of instruction. But if it is carried out with all possible firmness against offenders in every condition of life, it can scarcely fail to produce some results which will have to be taken into account in subsequent treatment of the problem.—N. Y. Tribune.