AdventAI

NEITHER SPIRIT NOR LETTER.

By W. A. Colcord

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 25., June 18, 1889

How Sunday is Generally Kept.

BY W. A. COLCORD.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

The following story related by the Rev. George H. Hubbard, of Norton, Mass., in the Sunday School Times of May 11, together with the reverend gentleman’s comments and candid admissions, so correctly pictures the manner in which Sunday is generally observed at the present time by professors of religion, that we present it to the readers of the REVIEW.

SUNDAY CONVERSATION.

In the “good old days,” when Sunday was observed with Puritanic strictness in New England, there lived a couple of worthy deacons in a little Massachusetts town. Like most orthodox New England deacons, they were exceedingly scrupulous in the fulfillment of all religious duties. They were also great lovers of horse-flesh, and shrewd in matters of trade.

It chanced, on a fine Sunday morning, so the story goes, as those two deacons drove up to the church-door with their families, that Deacon Smith had a new horse, which he had purchased only a few days before. Deacon Jones observed the fact, and took a good look at the animal. Nothing was said at the time; but after the morning service, while the “women folks” were discussing the latest scandal in a neighboring village, and the children were strolling about the churchyard, nibbling their lunches, Deacon Jones cautiously approached his brother deacon with the remark:—

“So you’ve got a new horse, eh? Quite a fair-looking nag, too. If it wasn’t Sunday, how would you trade with me?”

“Brother Jones,” returned Deacon Smith, with just a shade of reproof in his tone, “you know I don’t trade horses on the Lord’s day. But seeing you’ve mentioned the subject, if it wasn’t Sunday, I’d like to talk with you. Your horse is a trifle old, you know, and can’t do as much work as this one. I should probably want about fifty dollars to boot.”

“If it wasn’t Sunday,” rejoined Deacon Jones, “I’d give you twenty-five.”

Thus the “dickering” went on. Each time the offer was made with a saving clause, “If it wasn’t Sunday,” until finally a point of agreement was reached, and it was mutually understood that they should meet on Monday morning and make the trade. Then they went into the church, and slept through the afternoon sermon with a peace only consistent with restful consciences and the assurance that they had strictly observed the sanctity of the Sabbath in all they had done.

This was in the days of “Puritanic strictness,” and in the State of Massachusetts where Puritanic laws were enacted compelling men and women to attend church services on Sunday or lay themselves liable to a fine. These laws evidently did not have the power nor effect, however, of sanctifying that day in the hearts of these “worthy deacons.” But let us pass down the stream of time a century or two, and see if such a manner of observing the day is confined to a few worldly-minded deacons. Mr. Hubbard’s comments are to the point:—

We cannot vouch for the truthfulness of this particular story, but we can find its parallel any Sunday in every community in the land. Inconsistency no less ridiculous is a weekly occurrence. Very many persons who observe the Lord’s day scrupulously, so far as their occupations are concerned, are utterly careless and indiscriminate in their choice of topics for Sunday conversation. Farmers who would not do five minutes’ work in the field on Sunday will discuss crops with their families and neighbors on the way to and from church, and will occupy all the leisure hours of the day in walking about their fields, laying plans for the work of the coming week, and talking about various parts of their work. Tradesmen, in the same way, discuss market reports, business prospects, recent developments of trade, or failures in which they have an interest. Railroad men on Sunday talk of the incidents and accidents of railroad life. Mechanics discuss the latest invention, and its bearing on their work. Lawyers recount the interesting, amusing, or important cases of the week. Doctors converse freely on professional or business topics. And even ministers of the gospel too often amuse their friends with wholly irrelevant conversation upon innumerable topics. Ladies talk about the fashions. Children talk of school, lessons, and play. Unfortunately, too, people of all classes may be heard speaking one to another of topics less worthy than these. Political and social questions, the latest concert, base-ball game, boat race, walking-match, prize-fight, etc., are discussed on every side. In short, the Sunday conversation of the majority of our Christian families is pretty accurately reproduced in its variety and unsanctity by the average Sunday newspaper.

And such is Sunday-keeping to-day by “the majority of our Christian families!” Is it any wonder that the Sunday newspaper has found an existence, and supplied so large a class of readers when the thoughts and conversation of the greater portion of those who profess to keep the day, run in the same channel that the paper does? or to state it a little differently, is it any wonder that the Sunday paper deals so largely in sensational literature and mundane topics when such is the case? Is it any wonder that Sunday trains have been run, Sunday base-ball games been played, and the religious observance of the day fallen into such general desuetude?

The evident trouble is, the day has largely lost its supposed sacredness. The majority of these people are coming to understand that it is not the Sabbath. And what can be done to bring back the spiritual regard for an observance of the day? There is no divine command for its sanctification to fall back upon. The day has neither letter nor spirit to sustain it. The only thing that can be done other than to abandon the day entirely, will be to create a letter for it by enacting a Puritanical Sunday law. And then those who regard it will have the question to solve whether in keeping it they are worshiping God or the government, the answer to which we think in the majority of cases will not be so inspiring as to make horse-trading on Sunday incompatible with the decision.