AdventAI

SOMETHING MUST BE DONE.

By W. A. Colcord

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 8., February 19, 1889

BY W. A. COLCORD.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

SUCH appears to be the sentiment taking possession of the minds of many religious teachers of the day not in sympathy with the doctrines of present truth. The presentation of these doctrines has not been altogether without effect. Notwithstanding the crosses which an acceptance of them involves, they have carried with them a measure of conviction that has been irresistible. Thousands upon thousands have admitted their truthfulness; while not a few have accepted them, and decided to live in accordance with their convictions.

Those who for some reason are not willing that these views should become general, or be accepted by any considerable numbers, are beginning to appreciate the fact that something must be done, or such is liable to be the case. A minister signing himself “Rev. F. L. Tuttle,” writing from Healdsburg, Cal., in the California Christian Advocate (Methodist), of Jan. 16, 1889, quite clearly sets forth this idea. His article is headed, “Seventh-day Adventism.” In speaking of the “Pastors’ Union” of that place, of which, it appears, he is a member, he says, “They have long felt the need of doing something to stay the progress of this system of error.”

So these gentlemen have come to realize that this “system,” whether of error or otherwise, is making “progress;” and that if its progress is to be stayed, something must be done. They have learned that it will not stop of its own accord, neither will it die out because these Reverend gentlemen may have studiously ignored it, and sought its demise by withholding from it the honor of even their disapproving smiles, as Mr. Tuttle so plainly admits. He says, “Ignore it as much as we please, the reading of this literature scattered abroad does unsettle many, and they do make proselytes.”

It thus appears that the plan of ignoring has been tried. But this has failed to accomplish what they desired it should. The reading-matter scattered abroad has had an effect upon “many,” in spite of all this. And the efforts put forth by this people are not entirely without visible results, for “they do make proselytes.” But as this will never do, something must be done. And what is it?

First, let us inquire what we should naturally expect ministers of the gospel would do, after they had decided that a certain system of religion is erroneous and demands attention. Would we not expect them to say something about it, and show up its errors themselves? That is the way Paul did with heathenism, and Luther with Catholicism. They entered the field themselves, and fearlessly battled against the wrong, and earnestly contended for the right. But what have these valiant shepherds of the flock over in California done?—Sent across the continent and hired a man whose teachings are as destructive to cardinal points of faith held by Methodists, Baptists, Presbyterians, etc., as are those of Seventh-day Adventists, to do their work for them. Says Mr. Tuttle, “The Pastors’ Union of Healdsburg, Cal., has secured the services of this gentleman for a series of lectures in their town.” The object is stated farther on. It is “to refute the errors of this sect.”

But the question naturally arises, Why have not these pastors undertaken to refute it themselves? We will let Mr. Tuttle answer: “It is not a pleasant task, and most pastors, rather than get into a debate, allow the work of proselyting, unsettling, and undermining to go on.” Heartless pastors! Allow souls to go to ruin just to avoid a little unpleasant task! Think of it! A pastor permitting men and women to go to destruction, when he could have saved them by “getting into a debate”! Is this the true solution of the question? If so, it surely is a sad comment on the pastors. The words of Christ in John 10:12, 13, would seem to be the only fitting description of them. “But he that is an hireling, and not the shepherd, whose own the sheep are not, seeth the wolf coming, and leaveth the sheep, and fleeth; and the wolf catcheth them, and scattereth the sheep. The hireling fleeth, because he is an hireling, and careth not for the sheep.”

But the motive that induced these men to engage some one else to undertake this “unpleasant task,” Mr. Tuttle has quite plainly intimated. Speaking for the Union, he says, “We feel safe in calling such a man to do a work for us that we hesitate to undertake for ourselves.” The work to be done is for them. But they feel safe in letting somebody else do it; for, if it should succeed, it would be a success for them; and if it should fail to accomplish all they desire it to accomplish, as it surely will, it will be some one’s else failure, and not their’s! So they are “safe” in either case. But the most striking feature in the passage is the frank admission that this work of refuting the doctrines of Seventh-day Adventists is a task which even the whole fraternity of ministers in the city of Healdsburg “hesitate to undertake for themselves.” After admitting that it needs to be done, there can be but one valid reason for their not doing it, and that is a conscious sense of their inability. It is a little too great an undertaking.

We think we understand the situation these gentlemen are in. They are evidently laboring under peculiar circumstances. They are anxious that something should be done, to stay the progress of a particular sect, but hardly know how to go about doing it. A few similar cases have presented themselves in the past, a brief notice of which may, perhaps, aid us in solving this one, and in determining what doubtless will be done in this.

The Saviour came preaching a doctrine which attracted the attention of the people wherever he went. It appealed to the better judgment of all, and was accepted by many as truth. This greatly disturbed the religious teachers of his time, and so we find them first attempting to entangle him by argument. But he put them all to silence. So ably did he answer their sophistry that they finally dared not to ask him a question. Still they were determined that his preaching should cease, and, like the Healdsburg Pastors’ Union, “felt the need of doing something to stay the progress of this system of error.” So what did they do?—“Then gathered the chief priests and the Pharisees a council” (John 11:47)—just what the pastors of Healdsburg did. “And said, What do we?” They were in a quandary what to do, just as these pastors have been. Why they were thus solicitousp. 116 over the matter is plainly stated, “If we thus let them alone, all men will believe on him,”—the anxiety of the ministers exactly. “Ignore them as much as we please,” says Mr. Tuttle, yet “they do make proselytes.” The result of that council of the chief priests and Pharisees was that “from that day forth they took counsel together for to put him to death.” And in order to get him into their hands, and thence under the power of the law as a criminal, they hired a traitor to betray him, and sought false witnesses against him. Matt. 26:59. If these modern pastors are not in a similar situation, and are not playing a rôle corresponding to that of those ancient priests, then there is nothing alike in a likeness.

The same procedure is repeated with reference to the apostles, as recorded in the fourth chapter of Acts. The apostles had been preaching with convincing power. Verse 3 states that “many of them which heard the word believed.” This aroused the indignation of the priests and others, “being grieved that they taught the people.” Then followed a council of the rulers, elders, scribes, priests, and high priest. “When they had commanded them to go aside out of the council, they conferred among themselves, saying, What shall we do with these men?” Their chief anxiety was, not to know whether the teaching of the apostles was true or not, but “that it spread no further.” It was gaining adherents, the apostles were making proselytes; and that they could not endure, so they said, “Let us straitly threaten them, that they speak henceforth to no man in this name.” This failing to accomplish their purpose, they resorted to imprisonment, beating, false accusation, and murder.

That a similar course will be pursued by the enemies of truth now, is evident, not only because like causes produce like effects, but from the fact that the actual working out of that cause has already begun. The incentive to such opposition we apprehend is not so much from the conviction that certain doctrines are wrong and injurious, as it is that they chance to run across some cherished rite or settled creed, and only too plainly prove it wrong. Was it because those chief priests and Pharisees believed that Christ’s teachings were making people worse instead of better, that they wished to hush the voice of truth? Was it because those priests and rulers thought that the apostles were destroying faith in the word of God, that they threatened, imprisoned, beat, and killed them? And is it because these modern pastors are convinced that the teachings of Seventh-day Adventists really make men and women worse, destroy faith in Christ, or lead to the violation of God’s law, that they feel that something must be done to stay their further progress? We think not. If they were, they would do that something themselves. But a different motive prompts to a different course. Like the priests of old, they are ready to condemn it, but prefer that some one else should do the more unpleasant task. True zeal for the maintenance of truth never leads to such timid expedients.