BY W. A. COLCORD.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
For taking contradictory positions the advocates of a national compulsory Sunday law are entitled to the first rank. To harmonize their efforts to cajole the people into the belief that such a law would be so highly beneficial and effective in this country, with their answers to those opposed to it—that it is only for the District of Columbia and the Territories, and would not materially effect us in the States—is about as difficult a matter as it is to turn a grindstone two ways at once. The fact is, they can turn it best one way at a time, and it depends simply upon whose ax they are grinding which way they turn it. If they are talking to those whom they expect to win over to their cause, then, according to the last words in the Blair Sunday bill, the law is, “so far as possible, to secure to the whole people rest from toil during the first day of the week, their mental and moral culture, and the religious observance of the Sabbath day.” It is to be an inestimable blessing to every man, woman, and child in the land. But if, on the other hand, they are seeking to allay the fears of those who see oppression to follow the enactment of such a law, then it is so circumscribed and of such a nature, that if it should be enacted and strictly enforced, we in the States would not know, so far as effects are concerned, that there was such a law in existence.
In proof of the foregoing statements, we call attention to the following quotations from the Christian Statesman of April 11, 1889. Under heading “The Seventh-day Adventists and the Sabbath,” Mrs. J. C. Bateham, who is superintendent of the Sabbath observance department of the W. C. T. U., says:—
The Seventh-day Adventists are circulating in many of the States petitions to Congress against any legislation in favor of a day of rest. They say the ultimate intent of Blair’s Sunday-rest bill is to compel people to attend church, that it is to help the Catholics, that a union of church and state will be the result, and various other things, all of which are of course false.
The petitions are “Against Needless Sunday Work in Government Service and Inter-State Commerce,” and Senator Blair’s “Sunday-rest Bill” covers this and no more, except that it creates a Sabbath law for the District of Columbia and the Territories, similar to that of most States. If made into a law, it will no more compel church going than do our State laws, and will have no more tendency to bring about a union of church and state than those State laws, under which we have lived since States were formed.
From this we would understand that this contemplated Sunday law was to be a very harmless and meager affair; that it was to be no more effective than the State Sunday law; and that S. D. Adventists had been greatly mistaken in supposing that it had the remotest intention of getting people to attend church. But let us see. In the same paper, and on the same page, there is another article by Mrs. Bateham, entitled, “Sabbath Rest and How to Maintain It.” In this she asks how the rights of the people to a day of quiet “can best be secured by law.” Then she goes on to state why we need this weekly rest. First to rest “our bodies,” then “as a matter of economy,” for “variety,” for “our higher natures,” and last but not least, she gives this reason:—
But most of all the soul—for our souls we need the Sabbath. . . . We want it for the purposes for which God designed it when he bade us keep it holy, not for frivolity and amusement, not for sleep and idleness, not for the Sunday newspaper, with its demoralizing literature, but for reading which is elevating and improving, including the word of God, and for attendance upon church services; a practice which I believe does more than almost anything else to insure prosperity in this world and happiness in the next. [Italics ours.]
And who shall say now that even Mrs. Bateham does not want the Sunday law in order to get people to go to church? She says we need the Sabbath (Sunday of course, she means) “most of all” for that very purpose, and we want that “secured by law.” Is the law to stop short of securing the most needful thing of all? But it may be urged that there is no intention of “compelling” people to attend church, but that their right to do so shall be “secured.” Let us reason on that a moment. How is it about taking the weekly rest? Is it simply the right to the rest that is to be secured? By no means. The people are to be compelled to refrain from labor on the Sunday. They are to be compelled to have the “variety” of rest and labor, whenever they wish it or not. If there is “economy” in the keeping of Sunday, they are bound to reap the benefits, whether they are economical or not. However much they may esteem it a right or a pleasure to engage in some play, game, or amusement on Sunday, they are compelled to refrain, if it in any way disturbs others. Read the Blair bill. No compulsion to such a law? We should say there is. But for the last step. We have not got the people into church yet. But let us see. They are not to work—they must rest—they are not to engage in games and amusements, and Mrs. Bateham says the day is not “for sleep and idleness.” What then is it for? and what is left for them to do but the “attendance upon church services,” reading “the word of God” and the like? Shall that “practice” which more than almost anything else insures “prosperity in this world and happiness in the next” not be made obligatory? For the law to fail in this, would be the greatest mistake that could be made. Compel people to go to church? That is the inevitable logic of the situation when once it is admitted that it is proper to compel them to rest, whether Mrs. Bateham can see it or not. We have demonstrated it from her own writings.
A word in regard to the extent and effectiveness of the proposed Sunday law. Mrs. Bateham states that this national law will no more compel church going or bring about a union of church and state than our present State laws have done; that aside from controlling the Government Service and Inter-State Commerce, it is only to make a Sunday law for the District of Columbia and the Territories similar to those of our States. But we will let Mr. Crafts speak upon this point. On the previous page of the same issue of the Statesman, he says:—
The National law is needed to make the State laws complete and effective.
This tells the whole story. The State laws have not been doing what they have wanted them to do, and they are going to ask for a national law in order to make the State laws “complete and effective.” This shows that the States have already gone farther in this matter than they have been warranted in doing; and now what is wanted is a sanction from the Government for what has been done in the past! and who shall say how much farther they will go when this is granted? It is the merest quibble, then, to say that a national Sunday law is intended to do no more than our State Sunday laws have already done. The national law is desired simply for the privilege of operating through State laws. It needs but fair optics to see through the meshes of this National Reform scheme.