PRINCIPLES BY WHICH TO INTERPRET PROPHECY.—NO. 12.
BY ELD. D. T. BOURDEAU.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
A FALSE THEORY EXPOSED.
In order further to illustrate the last two principles laid down, and to give a fuller idea of the growing tendency with some so to interpret prophecy as to put off the coming of Christ, while claiming that it is near, we will notice the main features of a theory met by the writer in Europe, and which is now being adopted, to a certain extent, in America. This theory agrees with that held by the Reformers of the sixteenth century and by the generality of Christians since the Reformation, in teaching that the monarchies of Babylon, Media and Persia, Greece, and Rome are represented by the four parts of the metallic image of Daniel 2, and by the four beasts of Daniel 7, and in maintaining that the empires of Media and Persia and Greece are symbolized by the two beasts of Daniel 8. It also agrees with that theory on a few other points. But as just ten kingdoms were to arise out of the fourth kingdom, as appears from the toes of the image of Daniel 2, the fourth beast of Daniel 7, etc., and were to exist when Christ should appear; and as there are not now just that number of kingdoms occupying the territory of the old Roman empire, the theory in question claims that in the war to precede the coming of Christ, the kingdoms now embracing the territory of the original Roman empire are to be broken up and remodeled, so that there will be precisely ten kingdoms when Christ appears. Some holding to that theory even deny that there have been just ten kingdoms in the old Roman territory, answering to the ten toes of the image of Daniel 2, and to the ten horns on the fourth beast of Daniel 7, etc.
This foundation laid down, of course the little horn of Daniel 7, that of Daniel 8, and the leopard beast of Revelation 13, do not at all represent the papacy of the past, according to the firm conviction of Christians in the Dark Ages, who suffered so much from the cruel persecutions of that power that they should certainly be the best judges in this matter, and according to the faith and teachings of the Reformers and of the mass of Protestants since the Reformation. And according to this theory, the little horn has not yet appeared, but will arise after the manifestation of the ten horns, and after three of those horns have been plucked up or overturned. And to hasten the time of the glorious reign of Christ on earth, in which the Jews, it is claimed, are to rank first in honor and in the enjoyment of blessings and privileges, they have the threep. 180 times and a half, or 1260 days, or forty-two months assigned to the little horn as a period of prosperity and triumph over the saints, to mean just three and a half years. Dan. 7:25; Rev. 12:6, 14; 13:5. And of course “the man of sin,” or “mystery of iniquity,” and “antichrist” (2 Thessalonians 2), being synonymous with the little horn, represent a literal man, no more, no less,—the personification of all evil,—who is to sit as God in the temple of God in Jerusalem three and a half years. Then a literal image of the beast is to be erected by the two-horned beast, and whosoever does not worship the image of the abominable man called Antichrist, shall be killed. Rev. 13:11, etc.
That will be the “time of great tribulation” to the church (Matt. 24:21–29); and the literal sanctuary at Jerusalem, which will have been recently constructed, will be trodden under foot 2,300 literal days (Dan. 8:13, 14), answering to the last of the seventy weeks, which, it is claimed, is disconnected from the sixty-nine weeks that were to reach unto the Messiah, and thrown ahead and applied more than 1800 years after the first advent of the Messiah and the termination of the sixty-nine weeks. Dan. 9:24, etc. About that time the Jewish system of sacrifices is to be restored; but in the midst of the seventieth week the sacrifice and oblation shall cease, and the sanctuary shall be cleansed. Dan. 8:13, 14; 9:24–27. And after the awful tribulation of the elect, to occur in those days, the signs of Christ’s coming will appear in the sun, moon, and stars. And pray tell us when Christ will come, if all these things must transpire before he appears!
Our limits will allow us to present only a fraction of what might be said in reply to this theory. And the first thought that strikes the reflecting and critical mind familiar with the Scriptures in the true light of prophecy, in surveying this theory, is that it violates and mars God’s plan of unity and uniformity which characterizes each of the great chains of prophetic symbols. It does this with regard to the ten horns, the little horn, the prophetic times, and the image to be formed by the two-horned beast, throwing them out of joint with the symbols with which they are connected.
Observe the connection that exists between the first four parts of the metallic image of Daniel 2, between the four beasts of Daniel 7, and between the two beasts of Daniel 8. The same is true of the governments that those symbols represent. There is not a break in the symbols, nor is there a break in the history of the governments that the symbols represent. And this is for the simple reason that each government came up by overcoming and replacing its predecessor. And why should not this be true of the parts of the last symbol in each of these great lines of prophecy? Why should there not be a connection between imperial Rome and the ten kings, as indicated by the legs and toes of the image and the fourth beast and ten horns?
If the ten kingdoms have not yet appeared, then there is a blank of at least fourteen hundred years in the prophetic history of Rome as set forth by the legs and toes of the image, and by the fourth beast of Daniel 7. There is or there is not, in those symbols, a connection between the history of imperial Rome and that of the ten kingdoms. If that connection exists, then most assuredly the ten horns have appeared, or, so far as the symbols are concerned, we are still under imperial Rome. But imperial Rome has passed away; therefore the ten horns have arisen, or else God has failed to fulfill his word. If, on the other hand, the connection that we claim exists does not exist, then is God’s wisdom as a teacher impeached; for in that case God would plainly represent through symbols a most striking feature that no event in history would ever meet. God forbid that we should impute such weakness to him who is too wise to err, or that we should say, God has failed to fulfill his word. We therefore conclude that the ten horns have appeared.
But why linger here when history shows conclusively that in the fourth and fifth centuries ten kingdoms arose in the territory of the Roman empire, and broke up that empire? See Gibbon’s “Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire,” etc., etc.
The idea that in the end of time the beast is represented as having ten horns (Revelation 17), is not against our position. The prophetic eye of John looked at the nations now occupying the old territory of the Roman empire through the original ten kingdoms which they replace. Whether they number ten, or more or less than ten, the beast bearing them retains its original, distinctive brand, and is still called the ten-horned beast.
Among the places at which I stopped when in France, was one called Les Quatre Chênes (The Four Oaks). I looked for the oaks, but they were not there; yet they had been there, and had given their name to the place, which still retained it. Last winter, while in New Orleans, I occasionally spoke at a point on a street called Twin Cottage Street and Five Cottage Street. That street was thus named because originally it had five cottages built on it that looked just alike. Now if one half of those cottages were destroyed, the street would still be known by the same name. There are now many more houses on that street, yet its name has not changed. The same is true of ten thousand different things that have undergone marked changes, yet bear their original names. So of the beast which originally had ten horns. But the same beast had also “seven heads,” yet those heads are successive, for they denote seven different forms of the Roman government, the seventh of which is the papal form. Of these John says, “Five are fallen, and one is, and the other is not yet come.” Rev. 17:10. But John uses one emblem to represent the power in question throughout its history; namely, a beast with seven heads and ten horns.
It is not therefore necessary to say that just ten kingdoms must yet arise on old Roman territory before the coming of Christ. These kingdoms have already appeared, and the power symbolized by the little horn, the papacy, has arisen, also, and has had its prosperous reign of 1260 years over the kingdoms that succeeded imperial Rome. This power is also indicated by the woman that sat on the scarlet colored beast having seven heads and ten horns (Rev. 17), and by the beast which took the seat and power of the dragon, pagan Rome. See Rev. 13:1, 2; 12. It was this dragon who through Herod, its representative in Judea, aimed to destroy the child Jesus as soon as he should be born. Rev. 12:1–5. The seat of this power was the place in which its legislators sat in legal capacity to make laws. All know that this was Rome, and that Rome became the seat of government of papal Rome.
But as the little horn is synonymous with the man of sin, or mystery of iniquity, and antichrist, and as Paul declares that the mystery of iniquity had already begun to work in his day (2 Thess. 2:7), and John speaks of antichrist as of something known in his time (1 John 4:3), it is evident that the little horn was to appear before the end of this dispensation. This power did, through its head, the pope, sit in the temple of God, the church, calling himself God, even “the Lord God the pope.” Compare 2 Thess. 2:3, 4 with 1 Cor. 3:9–17; 2 Cor. 6:16.
It is contrary to God’s plan of unity and uniformity as seen in each series of prophetic symbols, to confine the little horn, etc., to one particular man; namely the pope of Rome, as does the theory under examination. That horn was to arise among the ten horns. Were the ten horns simply ten kings in the sense that we now attach to the term “king”? They certainly were, if the little horn means only the pope of Rome. It will never do to take that position. It may be objected that the prophet says, “The ten horns are ten kings.” Dan. 7:24. We would not deny this. But the four beasts are, by the same prophet, declared to be “four kings which shall arise out of the earth” (verse 17); and in explaining the head of gold of the metallic image, he says to Nebuchadnezzar, “Thou art this head of gold.” Dan. 2:38. Did, therefore, the four beasts simply mean four men? And was king Nebuchadnezzar all that the head of gold signified? No one would be so unwise as to claim this. You say, In each of these cases the head of the government is made to represent both himself and his subjects. Apply the same rule to the little horn, the man of sin, antichrist, etc., and the Scriptures will not be thrown out of their glorious harmony.