AdventAI

ANOTHER ATTACK.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 12., March 19, 1889

Third and Concluding Paper.

We were obliged to close last week’s remarks with a bare allusion to the charge that our position on the subject of the sanctuary obliges us to take the view that there can have been no forgiveness of sin since 1844, when, as we hold, Christ entered into the most holy of the heavenly sanctuary, and commenced the work of the atonement. The reason upon which they base this charge, is that on the day of atonement in the type, no offering was made for the people, and hence only those who had previously presented their offerings could share in the atonement; and therefore in the antitype, no forgiveness of sin can be secured after the work of the atonement begins.

This view is one which our opponents manufacture for us, upon premises of their own, not upon ours. Their premises we deny, and their conclusion we consequently repudiate. Did they ever stop to think what conclusions would inevitably follow from their premises? If, as they say, all that was done on the day of atonement had respect only to what was done previous to that day, then it follows that if a sin was committed on that day, for that sin there was no forgiveness. For if there could be no offering for present sin on that day, which was the tenth day of the seventh month, all opportunities ceased at the close of the ninth day; and when the work of the next year opened, on the eleventh day of the month, the offerings had respect to the sins of that day and onward, and did not lap back onto the tenth day, the day of atonement. Hence we say again, according to this view, Whatever sins were committed on the day of atonement could find no forgiveness—the door was shut. Thus our opponents, by the view they hold, will have it that there was, for one day in every year, a “shut door” to Israel, for nearly fifteen hundred years, while the typical dispensation lasted. This is the worst “shut door” view we ever heard of. Let not such theologians taunt S. D. Adventists with any shut-door doctrine.

We claim that there was an offering for sin on the day of atonement; that is, that the offering ministered by the high priest on that day was a general one for all the people; and that if a man, though he had brought no offering before, would come up and comply with the directions for that day, he could avail himself of the benefits of that offering. Just so in the antitype. And we repeat that the subject of the sanctuary was the very subject which was calculated to correct the ideas of Adventists on the question of the shut door immediately after the passing of the time in 1844, and which did correct it with all who would receive it. Let the argument above stated, with respect to sin on the day of atonement, be carefully noted.

The much-mooted passage, “The time of their salvation is passed,” as appears in “Early Writings,” is again brought up. What is the subject of the vision?—This: “The reformations that were shown me were not reformations from error to truth.” This would imply that there might be reformations from error to truth; but these were not the ones brought to view in the vision. We wonder how much confidence Mr. M. would have in a “reformation,” so-called, which was “not from error to truth, but from bad to worse.” Whether or not this has yet been fulfilled is an open question. But whether past, present, or future, the subject of the vision is false so-called reformations of the last days, and the ones whose salvation is spoken of as past, are those who are engaged in those false reformations. The whole scope, intent, and context of the passage demand this construction. But men become so delirious with prejudice that they will hang and quibble upon mere words, rather than be governed by the sense of the narrative. Of this construction the objector says: “He goes back five paragraphs to find the antecedent of the pronoun ‘their.’” Very well, look at 2 Sam. 24:1: “And again the anger of the Lord was kindled against Israel, and he moved David against them to say, Go number Israel and Judah.” Now in this passage, what is the antecedent of the pronoun “he”? The skeptic says the word “Lord” just before. But Mr. M., with every accepted commentator, and every Bible believer, will say, “Satan;” and to find this antecedent we must go back, not merely five paragraphs, but more than five chapters, even into an entirely independent and different book—1 Chron. 21:1. In view of this principle, why quibble over five paragraphs? Why not be consistent, and take as the antecedent of “their” the plainly-expressed subject of the vision; namely, those who are carrying on false so-called reformations?

Mr. M. then tries to make out that we apply the language to all ministers, whereas we do nothing of the kind, but apply it only to a particular class.

As another specimen of the way in which Mr. M. treats the writings of Mrs. White, take the following: He quotes from her these words (p. 11): “I do not write one article in the paper expressing merely my own ideas.” The reader will notice that she says “ideas;” but Mr. M., commenting upon this a few lines further on, says: “And yet Mrs. White claims, and her followers profess to believe, that every line and every word is inspired of God.” Can any one tell what right he had to slyly change the language, and say “word,” when she had only said “idea”? Does not any one know that an idea may be expressed in a hundred different ways, and that words need not be inspired to set forth a heaven-sent idea? By such foul and deceptive means they try to make the writings of Mrs. White odious.

On this point Mr. M. rests principally upon verbal instead of printed evidence. He says:—

Again, Seventh-day Adventists claim that the writings of Mrs. E. G. White are “equal to the word of God in all respects.” Yea; more than this, that when a preference is to be made, the former must take the precedence, “since they are more recent and pertinent to the present time.” The italics are our own. I here quote the verbatim language of two of their leading ministers, proclaimed from the sacred desk in the Tabernacle, in Battle Creek, Mich., in 1882.—p. 10.

Did Mr. M. ever find anything like this in any of our printed and standard works?—Not a syllable. Whether he ever heard it or not, we will leave the reader to decide for himself. We can only say that we never did. We say that people sometimes look through colored glasses; we might also say that they hear through a telephone, the other end of which is manipulated by the father of lies. But suppose he did hear this; suppose two persons could be found so ultra and unbalanced as to give utterance to such extreme views; is he to judge the whole body by them? Again we say that we never heard any such statements, and certainly nothing of the kind can be found in any of our printed works.

Again he says: “In a meeting held in their Tabernacle in Battle Creek, I heard the testimonies of sixty-two persons. Out of that number only two made mention of the name of Christ.” As these were testimonies that he “heard,” he of course was not one of the two who mentioned Christ. He then himself failed to do what he now reproaches the others for not doing. This is thrown out to carry the impression that we make nothing of Christ. But what has such an incident, supposing it is true, to do with determining the position and practice of a whole denomination of Christians?—Nothing whatever.

He continues: “The testimony of the sixty was substantially as follows: ‘I thank the Lord for the visions; I believe every word of them; I believe that they are equal to the word of God in all respects; and I hope you will pray for me that I may be able to square my life by them.’” It is astonishing what a faculty this man seems to have had for getting into peculiar meetings, and hearing peculiar testimonies. In all our connection with this people, we do not remember to have heard any such testimony, and we boldly aver that he never heard half a dozen, much less sixty, of the kind.

He further affirms that Mrs. White claims for her writings that they are “equal to and in some respects above the word of God.”—p. 12. Such a charge is infamous. In all her writings he cannot find a syllable asserting that they are in any respect above the word of God, or even drawing any comparison between them.

His charge that the visions are made a test of fellowship; that credentials are taken away, and members cut off from the church for not accepting them, is one of the old stale falsehoods referred to in the first of these articles. Turbulent and unruly spirits are to be set aside for the divisions they cause. Rom. 16:17; 2 Thess. 3:6; etc. S. D. Adventists could fellowship a person even if he believed that the dead were conscious, and the soul immortal, if he held those views quietly, and on all matters of conduct kept the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus. But if he made this subject an occasion of strife and wrangling, they would withdraw from him as a disturber of the peace and a cause of division. And so they would do on the subject of the visions, or any other subject. It is a very convenient way, when a person has taken a course to cause a separation from a church, to charge that separation upon some, to him, obnoxious doctrine, especially if he imagines he can thereby raise some prejudice, or inflict some injury upon the people of his dislike. This will explain the position of every one who claims to have been disfellowshipped for not believing the visions.

But we will not pursue this subject any farther. Enough has been presented to show the dishonorable nature of this attack, and the spirit by which it has been prompted. We find in it no evidence that the writer was seeking to heed the injunction of the apostle: “Whatsoever things are true, whatsoever things are honest, whatsoever things are just . . . think on these things;” and we discover in it nothing to lead to a higher and better life. It may for a time influence some, but will stand exposed in its true light to all who will take the pains to investigate the matter fully.