[The accompanying article is the official report of an argument made before the Senate Committee in Washington, D. C., Feb. 22, on the proposed Educational Amendment to the United States Constitution. Six speakers from various sections of the country spoke in favor of the amendment, and urged its passage on the grounds that the Catholic element in our country is now wielding an influence so powerful in politics as to threaten the destruction of our public school system. The argument following was designed to answer the points made by these speakers, but as the reader will see, the questions plied by Mr. Blair, the chairman, were designed to lead away from the point at issue. This explanation will account for the seemingly abrupt beginning of the argument. [J. O. C.]
The Chairman: Please state in what capacity and for what purpose you appear before the Committee.
Mr. Corliss: I appear before the Committee, sir, to offer objections to the proposed amendment now pending before the Senate, and I represent nearly every State and Territory of the Union. Yesterday there were 230,000 names presented before the Senate in opposition to the same amendment.
Granting, sir, that there are some menaces to the present school system of the United States, as has been detailed this morning, and as was detailed by the delegation who appeared here a week ago, the simple question resolves itself into this:—
Will the proposed amendment to the Constitution avert the impending calamities that seem to overhang the common schools of this country?
If it were an amendment looking to the establishment of schools throughout the United States to teach simply the common branches of education, there could be no one who has any knowledge of the advantages to be gained from such education, who would oppose it for one moment. But it is the religious phase of the amendment that, in the minds of many good citizens of the United States, will deepen the difficulty that now faces the country.
The clause of the proposed amendment to which I refer, is that on the second page—in the 16th and 17th lines. In order to make it intelligible and connected, I will commence reading at the beginning of Section 2, which says:—
Each State in this Union shall establish and maintain a system of free public schools adequate for the education of all the children therein, between the ages of six and sixteen years inclusive, in the common branches of knowledge, and in virtue, morality and the principles of the Christian religion.
It is the religious phase of this amendment to which I object, in the name of the people whom I represent.
The Chairman: Suppose you read the section in connection with the remainder, or what follows the part that you have read.
Mr. Corliss: Very well. I will continue the reading:—
But no money raised by taxation imposed by law or any money or other property or credit belonging to any municipal corporation, or to any State or to the United States, shall ever be appropriated, applied, or given to the use or purposes of any school institutions, corporations or persons, whereby instruction or training shall be given in the doctrines, tenets, beliefs, ceremonials, or observances peculiar to any sect, denomination, organization, or society, being, or claiming to be, religious in its character, nor shall such peculiar doctrine, tenets, beliefs, ceremonials, or observances be taught or inculcated in the free public schools.
Senator Payne: You speak of the persons whom you represent. Are they known as the Seventh-day Adventists? Is that the class of people that you particularly represent?
Mr. Corliss: Not particularly. I do represent them, but I represent also a large class of American citizens. I speak not from the stand-point of any one sect.
Senator Payne: I merely asked for information.
Mr. Corliss: I speak from the stand-point of an American citizen and simply that.
We heard last week, and also heard to-day, of the encroachment of the Papal power upon the public-school system; and we have had brought before us facts maintaining that the numbers and influence of these people have become so great that they now claim a portion of the public money; that their influence is so great in New York that they even influence the legislature in their behalf; that in Boston their influence is so great that they control legislation in the city council. If this all be true, then it is easy to see that the religious phase of this amendment will only deepen the difficulties in which the nation already finds itself. Because, if the principles of the Christian religion are taught in the public schools, irrespective of denomination or sect, then the question arises, How will it be known what are the principles of the Christian religion? And who will determine what those principles are that should be taught in the public schools? There would certainly be but one way to learn what those principles are, and that would be by having a national council, perhaps appointed by the Congress of the United States, to convene and settle the question as to what are the principles of the Christian religion. This could not be confined to any one sect alone, but must of necessity include every sect. At least, it should include every sect that is of any importance in the land.
Now, taking for granted that the statements made before the Committee are as represented, and that the Catholics are acquiring very important influence in the country, then should such a council meet, the Catholic influence would be just as great, in proportion, in such a council, as it is in the several parts of the country, at the present time, where Catholics abound; it must of necessity be so. And if the Catholics shall have a voice in the decision of the question as to what are the principles of the Christian religion to be taught in the public schools, then their influence would largely mold that decision, and, instead of having the principles of that sect taught merely in parochial schools, they would be incorporated into the public school curriculum and taught in every public school in the United States. That must of necessity be so. Because if the Catholics should be excluded, were such a council to meet, the seven millions or more of them in the country would not tamely submit to being ignored in the consideration and decision of the question.
Should any religious persuasion having so numerous a following and so much influence in this country as have the Catholics be left out from any such council, I would not say that anarchy would ensue, but we know from the events of past history that there must of necessity be a religious war, which would scatter desolation throughout our land. We know that religious strife is the most terrible influence that could operate upon the people of a country. It is much worse than civil war could possibly be.
The Chairman: I understand you to be apprehensive that under that amendment it might come to pass that the peculiar doctrines, the sectarian doctrines of the Catholic Church, could be taught in the public schools; is that your fear?
Mr. Corliss: To a large extent—to the same extent that Catholics have a voice in the establishment of the “principles of the Christian religion.”
The Chairman: Well, do you think that there is anything in the principles of the Catholic Church so far as they are principles of the Christian religion, which, if dangerous at all, are dangerous because they are sectarian and only because they are sectarian?
Mr. Corliss: They are dangerous in so far as they are directed by the Pope of Rome. We have heard this morning that no doctrine of that Church is established without some edict from headquarters.
The Chairman: I think there has been a general misapprehension in the country about the amendment, from not reading the clause as a whole, treating it as they do, as confined to the phrase “the principles of the Christian religion.” The amendment is framed on the theory that moral or religious instruction is essential to the character of a good citizen of the State; that a very large number of the children of the State fail utterly to receive any instruction of that kind at home or in the churches. We know practically that a very large number of children get no education, of either a scholastic or spiritual kind, save what they get outside of the family or outside of any church; that it must necessarily therefore be given to them in the common schools or they will go without it, for there is no other institution which the State has which will furnish it.
Now, under that amendment, only those principles of the Christian religion can be taught which are not sectarian, because no sect can undertake to enforce or inculcate in the schools those doctrines peculiar to itself which must (and which alone, it seems to me, can) be assumed to be dangerous at all, because all the general principles of the Christian religion which all sects and all good society approve, cannot be dangerous to any sect or to good society. So that I think if the amendment is all read together, it can hardly be claimed that it has any clause calculated to establish the teaching of sectarianism, but rather to preclude and prohibit it. It is to that point that I wish to direct your attention now. I am simply stating the point as a whole, and I would be glad to hear you at length on that part of it.
Mr. Corliss: Would it be out of place for me to ask a question of the Chairman at this point?
The Chairman: Not at all.
Mr. Corliss: Then, sir, permit me to ask you this: When the statement is made that the “principles of the Christian religion” should be taught, to what length shall we go in defining the principles of the Christian religion? In other words, what do they cover?
The Chairman: You will observe that the amendment uses the phrase “for the education of all the children living therein, between the ages of six and sixteen years, inclusive, in the common branches of knowledge, and in virtue, morality, and the ‘principles of the Christian religion.’”
It has been thought by those who support the amendment that it is important for a child, or for a citizen of the United States, to have knowledge of the principles of the Christian religion. Those are the principles which permeate our system of laws, and all our habits and customs as a people. Even if a person did not believe in them, it might be essential that he should know what those principles are, and whether they are principles that he should conform to, in order to keep out of jail under our system of laws. This may be true, whether he be an infidel, a Jew, a Protestant, a Catholic, or what not, in order that he may navigate through the tortuous circles of society and of life. It is well that he should know what they are, as they are a part of his environment. They are a very important part of the environment of every man who lives in a country like this of ours.
When you come to the question whether doctrines taught in any specific school are principles of the Christian religion, if there should be a controversy on the subject, that would go through the courts of the whole country, and they of course, would decide the question. A second question would also arise, and that is, whether, being principles of the Christian religion, they could be called sectarian or peculiar tenets or doctrines of any particular sect or society. The courts would have to settle that question. It must necessarily go to some tribunal for decision, just as the question would have to go to some tribunal whether geography was being taught, or arithmetic, or any other common branch of knowledge. We go, of course, ultimately to the courts or other tribunal that the whole community has established, to settle such questions. And, getting there, it would be held, under this amendment, by the courts, that no principles of the Christian religion which were merely sectarian could be taught, and in fact it might probably be held that those cases which are peculiarly sectarian are not “principles”—that is, not fundamental, general, principles—of the Christian religion. I would not suppose that it would be held that any special regulation or ceremonial or tenet of any church was a principle of the Christian religion if it was a regulation, ceremonial or tenet peculiar to that sect, but the “principles of the Christian religion” must appertain to all churches whatever, so far as they are not sectarian.
Senator Payne: Let me make one suggestion. I would like to get an illustration on this point that you have now been discussing. This question is brought here, I understand, from Massachusetts. Let me inquire whether Unitarianism is within the principles of the Christian religion?
Mr. Corliss: I am not here, as I understand it, to define or speak in favor of any church or any sect. I would not want to commit myself on that point.
Senator Payne: The amendment states that instruction is to be given in “the principles of the Christian religion.” Is not Unitarianism a direct denial of the divinity of Christ and the Christian Church, and is that to be prohibited or is it to be allowed? I merely suggest the point now, so that you may be heard upon it if you desire to be.
The Chairman: The court would have to settle that, wherever the question was raised. The probability is there would be no peculiar doctrine of the Unitarian Church taught.
Mr. Corliss: That is the point I suggested. The courts would be called on to settle that question. Then the question arises on what basis would they settle it? The statute books of the country do not define what are the principles of the Christian religion. The Bible only does that. Then if a judge on the bench decides such a question, would he not of necessity decide it in accordance with his peculiar views of the Bible? Or perhaps he would do as did one Judge in this District some years ago when a religious question came up in his court for adjudication. The point was as to whether a man had violated the Sabbath day by working on Sunday. The Judge said that as the theologians had decided Sunday to be the Sabbath, he should act upon their knowledge of the matter, and pronounce the man guilty. Religion is a matter of conscience with which the courts have nothing to do. Their jurisdiction extends only to things civil. Just as soon as the courts are called on to decide as to what constitutes the principles of the Christian religion, then the Bible will be dragged into the courts to become a bone of contention. If we say that the courts shall decide that the Bible must decide what are the principles of the Christian religion, their interference is not needed at all; for that is just what is now being done.
The Chairman: But nothing that is sectarian, whether from the Bible, or otherwise, can be taught in the schools, under the provisions of this amendment. If I read a text of Scripture from the Bible, without any comments on it, would that be sectarian?
Mr. Corliss: No. It would not be sectarian, because it is the Bible, which is the gift of God to all men. The principles of the Christian religion are not taught anywhere else, primarily, but in the Bible. That is the primary source of the Christian religion, and if we establish the principles of the Christian religion, we must go to the Bible to find them. But to enforce the Bible upon any one by legislation would be mixing the Bible and politics. We would have the Bible in legislation and the Bible in the courts, and that would be objectionable.
The Chairman: Do you consider the use of the Bible in schools as the union of Church and State?
Mr. Corliss: I consider that religion which is upheld by the legislation of the State is a union of Church and State. Religion should be purely for the people in their individual capacities and not a matter of State legislation. As was said by General Grant in the memorable document that was referred to this morning, I believe that religion should be a matter of the family altar and the Church and the private school which is supported entirely by private parties, but that the State and Church should be kept entirely apart.
The Chairman: Do you object, from your stand-point, to the use of the Bible in the schools simply as a reading-book?p. 187
Mr. Corliss: Personally, I have no objection to it whatever as a reading-book, or even as a book of religious doctrines, because I am a believer in the Bible. But I cannot see how I, or any one else would be justified in trying to oblige others to use it in the same way; and for this reason, I should rather my children would read the authorized version of the Bible rather than the Douay version because there are some very objectionable texts in the latter. For instance, in Heb. 11:21, that version says that “Jacob when he was a dying, blessed each of the sons of Joseph and worshiped the top of his staff.” Then again in Gen. 3:15 the Catholic Bible says: “I will put enmity between thee and the woman, and between thy seed and her seed; she shall bruise thy head, and thou shalt bruise her heel.”
But the Catholic has just as good right to object to his children reading the Protestant Bible. Would it be right to tax the Catholic to educate his children in a book that he does not believe in?—Certainly not. Neither would it be justice to the Jews of the country to oblige them to assist in the maintenance of public schools, at which their children must be taught principles which they do not believe, and could not be hired to have taught to their children.
I am well persuaded that He whom the New Testament exalts as the Son of God deserves the exaltation he receives therein. But for all that, I do not believe it would be right to compel the children of Jewish parents to read the New Testament in school against the wishes of those parents; for that would be against the principles taught in the Bible itself. That says: “All things whatsoever ye would that men should do to you, do ye even so to them; for this is the law and the prophets.”
But there is another class of citizens whose rights and convictions are just as sacred as those of any other class. I mean those who do not indorse any version of the Bible. These are taxed equally with all others in support of the public schools. These should not be compelled, any more than others, to be taught that which they have no faith in. Whatever class is involved, the statement of the General Assembly of Virginia in 1785 is still true, that “to compel a man to furnish contributions of money for the propagation of opinions which he disbelieves, is sinful and tyrannical.” The decision also of the Supreme Court of Ohio on this matter is equally to the point, that “to tax a man to put down his own religion is the very essence of tyranny.” And that is just what the State does, when it taxes men to pay for forcing upon their children the religious ideas which the parents themselves do not believe.
The Chairman: Do you object to the teaching of virtue and morality which are embraced in “the principles of the Christian religion”?
Mr. Corliss: Morality is something very desirable, but I do not consider it essential to specially teach the Bible in the schools in order to inculcate social morality. The family and the church are the places where religion should be taught. If the church has lost its power to do its legitimate work, let it get more of the evangelistic fire, so that it will not need the secular power to accomplish that which, by its clamor for legislation it confesses it is not able to do.
The Chairman: Would you object to a phrase like this: “Instruction shall be given in the common branches of knowledge, Christian virtue, and morality”?
Mr. Corliss: I object to the term “Christian” in connection with legislation in behalf of the public schools, because that in the estimation of many good citizens is an obnoxious discrimination in favor of one party and against another.
The Chairman: Do you mean to be understood that you think there is, outside of the Christian religion, a virtue or morality which is sufficient to be taught to the American child in order that he may become what he should become as an American citizen?
Mr. Corliss: I will give you as an example, sir, the Jewish community of this country, which is 600,000 strong. They have not any faith whatever in Christianity. They ignore Christ entirely and they also ignore entirely the New Testament. Yet, we seldom find a Jew brought up before the court for any immorality. The Jews are a virtuous people as a class, although having a penchant for money. It will be found that as soon as we try to enforce upon Jewish children in the public schools anything in the way of Christian tendencies, it will cause great friction with that class of the community.
The Chairman: Do you think that the practical results, so far as citizenship is concerned, of any other religion than the Christian religion, are just as good as the practical results of the Christian religion?
Mr. Corliss: I would not want to commit myself on such a question as that without some explanation.
The Chairman: You may give your answer accompanied by any explanation you desire.
Mr. Corliss: I am a full and firm believer in the Christian religion, and I accept Christ as the only Saviour of mankind, but I seriously object to the mixing of religion and politics.
The Chairman: Do you consider common school instruction to be political instruction?
Mr. Corliss: I will read from Sections 3 and 4 of the proposed amendment by way of answer to your question.
Section 3. To the end that each State, the United States and all the people thereof, may have and preserve governments, Republican in form and in substance, the United States shall guarantee to every State, and to the people of every State and of the United States the support and maintenance of such a system of free public schools as is herein provided.
Section 4. That Congress shall enforce this article by legislation when necessary.
Thus we find that the religion that is to be taught in the public schools is to be enforced by legislation of Congress when necessary.
The Chairman: But my question is whether the instruction in the common schools is considered by you to be of a political character—not whether political methods may be resorted to by our Government to enforce the existence of the institution known as the common school, but whether that which is taught in the instruction of the common school is political.
Mr. Corliss: Not necessarily so; but if we, by politics, undertake to teach religion in the schools, that is mixing politics with religion. It is a virtual union of Church and State.
I can see, as I have said, how this amendment if it should become a law would plunge the country into a much deeper gulf than it is in at the present time; because here are all the various followings that I have spoken of—a large number of people who are American citizens and have the rights of citizenship, but who are in a minority. Now the simple fact that they are in a minority does not give the right to a majority to enact such legislation as would force the consciences of these men, or attempt to do so. I should seriously object to any legislation that would bring persecution to those people for conscience’s sake. The fact that a certain class of the people are a majority should not as I think warrant them in passing laws which would oppress the consciences of a minority; it matters not how humble a minority that may be, it matters not how humble a citizen may be, his rights of conscience are between himself and his God, and are private, so long as they do not interfere with the liberties of his neighbor. There is no legislation that should attempt to disturb or regulate the dealings of his mind or conscience in those matters. It would not be just to do such a thing as that. It would not be justice to the Jew; it would not be justice to the infidel; it would not be justice to the atheist or to the spiritualist or to the large number of other persons who differ from the majority in their religious feelings and thoughts. As Gen. Washington said, every man who conducts himself as a good citizen is accountable to God alone for his faith, and should be protected in worshiping God according to the dictates of his own conscience. If that principle, written by the father of his country, whose birthday we celebrate to-day, be the true principle, then I repeat that it would be injustice to those people who are good citizens to have their children instructed in religious articles and doctrines that they themselves have no faith in whatever. It would be a system of persecution, it would be like the edicts issued of old by the Roman Emperors, which obliged people to receive their religious opinions from the Emperor without question. There is no person in the world who has not some preference as to what religious training his children shall have. Just as soon as we overstep the bounds of what is purely secular, we step on the people’s consciences. That is why I am opposed to anything of the kind. The people I represent are opposed to the resolution as it stands at present. If all the phrases referring to the teaching of the principles of the Christian religion were removed from the proposed amendment, there would not be a single voice raised in objection to it, because I believe that secular education in all the arts and sciences will fit men to become good citizens of the United States. It will bring children up in the proper direction.
The Chairman: If the clause reading, “And the principles of the Christian religion” were stricken out. I understand that you, and the people whom you represent so far as you know would favor the amendment?
Mr. Corliss: I have no reason to believe otherwise.
Senator Payne: Why is not that virtually established now? What occasion is there now for a Constitutional amendment requiring the public schools to promote general intelligence and morality?
Mr. Corliss: I do not see any occasion for it. I am perfectly in accord with the sentiments expressed by some very prominent men in our nation. Not long since, the New York Independent, in view of the pending amendment, wrote to some of the most prominent men of the nation for their views upon the necessity of this amendment, as to whether the Constitution of the United States should be amended or changed in any way. In its issue of January 10, 1889, the Independent published replies from some of the most prominent gentlemen of the nation on that question, as follows:—
Hon. George Bancroft said:—
“I have your letter asking what changes had better be made ‘in the Constitution. I know of none; if any change is ‘needed, it is in ourselves, that we may more and more respect ‘that body of primal law.”
Justice Grey of the U. S. Supreme Court said:—
“I am so old-fashioned as to think that the Constitution, ‘administered according to its letter and spirit, is well enough ‘as it is. And I am of the opinion of the late Governor An- ‘drew, that it is not desirable to Mexicanize our Government ‘by proposing Constitutional amendments as often as there is ‘supposed to be a disturbance in its practical working.”
Justice Blatchford of the U. S. Supreme Court said:—
“I am satisfied with the Constitution as it is. It cannot be ‘bettered. Constitution tinkers are in a poor business. If
“there are ills, it is better to bear them than fly to others that ‘we know not of.”
Just as soon as religious legislation is entered into in any degree by this nation, a precedent will have been established, and there is no knowing where it will end, and just as soon as the Government is committed to this sort of legislation, then a religious complexion is given to the work of the Government, which will constantly call for new legislation, and it will be insisted on until there will be no end to it.
Senator Payne: You are now giving your own opinion.
Mr. Corliss: Yes, sir, but such a result would be inevitable.
Senator Payne: Have any of the prominent men that you have spoken of advocated the proposed change in the Constitution?
Mr. Corliss: None.
A question quite similar to this was up before the United States Senate in 1829, when a committee of the Senate reported as follows:—
“It is not the legitimate province of the legislature to determine what religion is true or what false. Our Government is a civil and not a religious institution. Our Constitution recognizes in every person the right to choose his own religion, and to enjoy it freely, without molestation. The proper object of government is to protect all persons in the enjoyment of their civil as well as their religious rights, and not to determine for any whether they shall esteem one day above another, or esteem all days alike holy. What other nations call religious toleration, we call religious rights. They are not exercised in virtue of governmental indulgence, but as rights of which government cannot deprive any portion of citizens, however small. Despotic power may invade those rights, but justice still confirms them.”
In order that it may be known what are the principles of the Christian religion, there would, as I have said, be a necessity for having a national council called somewhere, say at Washington, from all the bodies of religious people in the United States, that is to say, from the bodies of any prominence.
The Chairman: Why should that be so? You have stated that point before, and I have seen it stated in the newspaper.
Mr. Corliss: I think it must be so.
The Chairman: That would be an ecclesiastical council. Is not the judiciary of the country an organization created by the State for the precise purpose of adjudging and construing every such question as might arise, and not the ecclesiastical bodies, which by their disagreements, constitute sects?
Mr. Corliss: I will answer that question, sir, by reading a portion of a letter purporting to be written by yourself (Senator Blair) to the Secretary of the National Reform Association, and published in the Christian Statesman. In that letter I find this sentence:—
“I believe that a text-book of instruction in the principles of ‘virtue, morality, and of the Christian religion, can be pre- ‘pared for use in the public schools by the joint effort of those ‘who represent every branch of the Christian church, both ‘Protestant and Catholic.”
I have only based my opinion upon the avowed statement or judgment of one who stands as a legislator in our national Congress.
The Chairman: I will simply say that that is a genuine extract from a letter which I wrote. I should be glad to have the full letter. I do not know where the letter is, but if the reporter can find it, I wish he may insert it, in the record of this hearing.
The question I asked you was whether such an ecclesiastical convocation would be necessary in order to carry out this amendment, and whether the judiciary was not a body that would decide as to whether the amendment was being interfered with, or as to whether anything was being taught in the public schools that, if embodying the principles of the Christian religion, lapped over into sectarianism. As to the latter point, undoubtedly in the preparation of text-books, religious men, although believing in the principles of the Christian religion in different sects, would confer, and it would not be permitted that either should incorporate into any book anything peculiar to his own sect; or, if the book they agreed upon was objectionable, it would be complained of, and the question would be carried to the courts and the courts would decide—not any ecclesiastical body.
Mr. Corliss: What court would have the decision of such a question as that?
The Chairman: It would, first, no doubt, be decided by the national body created for such a purpose, but would undoubtedly be finally carried to the Supreme Court of the United States.
Mr. Corliss: Then, sir, as the judges of the bench have preferences for some special religious views, would not they be partial to the religious views which they themselves entertain, and would they not give their opinion with reference to what they themselves understand to be the teaching of the Bible, so that it would fall back after all upon sectarian teaching?
The Chairman: That is not necessary at all. Judges to be sure are human beings and have undoubtedly their secret likings or convictions as to anything that comes before them, but there must be some tribunal that must decide and they in deciding what were the principles of the Christian religion, without sectarianism, would not be guided by their own sectarian views. They would decide as matter of fact as to the leading principles of the Christian religion, which were not sectarian.p. 188
(Continued from p. 11.)
Mr. Corliss: How could they do so when the statutes of the country do not define what the Christian religion is?
Senator Payne: As the Committee have but a few minutes more before the session of the Senate begins, I would suggest that the gentleman be permitted to give his views as expeditiously as possible.
Mr. Corliss: If my time is nearly up I will not attempt to say any more. I have some points which I wish to present and some facts, but in view of the possibility of legislation in the direction of religion I may perhaps be permitted to give you the following from Alexander Pope:—
“Let not this weak unknowing hand, Presume thy bolts to throw; And deal damnation round the land, On each I judge thy foe.”
No man has any right to deal out to another condemnation for any religious principles he may entertain so long as they are not subversive of civil liberty and the civil rights of others.
The Chairman: What you claim is the right to believe, but of course you admit that you must conform your conduct to that of the majority for the good of the State.
Mr. Corliss: In all civil matters I believe it is perfectly right to do so, but in questions of conscience you will find that intolerance, from the days of Christ down to this time, has been brought to bear against those who would carry out their convictions of right and wrong according to the dictates of their own conscience. That has been the record of history from the time of the apostles to the present day. All religious persecutions have started in that way.
The Chairman: Still, in our country, we give everybody the right to believe what he thinks best. Even the Mormon is not interfered with in his religious faith; it is only where his conduct is incompatible with the good of the State, that he is disturbed.
Mr. Corliss: It is not because of matters of conscience but because of the practices of the Mormons that they are interfered with—because their practices are subversive of civil liberty.
The Chairman: That is a point to which I wish to call your attention—that while the law protects a man in his belief, whatever that belief may be, yet in practice he must obey the law that is for the time being on the statute books of the country.
Mr. Corliss: Do you not think it would be a dangerous precedent to commence legislation upon matters that are purely religious, and would it not be subversive of religious liberty as held by the consciences of mankind—would it not by and by draw them into the vortex that almost destroyed the Christian religion of the old countries, when they had the church and state united? It seems to me that it would be surely fatal, and but a natural consequence of the introduction of religion into the public schools of this country.