AdventAI

THE SAFETY OF RESERVOIRS.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 26., June 25, 1889

The extent of the disaster at Johnstown will direct public attention to other reservoirs that may give way, causing death and destruction. There are a great many of them in this country, and, as a rule, they are not properly inspected. There is reason to fear that some of these are not strong enough to sustain the weight of the water that may be precipitated by a storm against them. It is possible to construct a dam that will withstand the frosts and freshets of a century. But this involves such an expense that cheaper methods are generally adopted. This was the cause of the terrible Mill River disaster in Massachusetts in 1874, which resulted in the loss of over 200 lives. In that case the jury found that the engineering work was discreditable, and that the contractors had been delinquent, and that even the State legislature was to blame in authorizing the construction of the reservoir without taking proper means to secure its safety. There need be no surprise if something of the kind is found to be the case at Johnstown. The dam was constructed by the State over forty years ago as a feeder to the Pennsylvania Canal. It is not improbable that it was a defective structure from the beginning. It was subjected to an extraordinary strain on Friday, but proper engineering work would have provided for such an emergency. There is a dam 1,629 feet long built across the Merrimac River in Massachusetts which has stood the floods for nearly half a century without starting a stone, or opening a crack, or costing its owners a single dollar for repairs or protection. It was built of solid masonry, in the most painstaking manner, everything about it being carefully tested. If as much care had been taken at Johnstown, we venture to say that the dam would still be intact, although Johnstown might have suffered from the floods that prevailed generally. Great strides have been made in the engineering profession in recent years, but even now the best engineers differ as to what is absolutely necessary for the safety of dams. New York has been discussing a proposed dam for a reservoir at Quaker Bridge, on the Croton River, and some very marked differences of opinion have been developed. Some of the best engineers expressed directly opposite views on the subject. General Newton, formerly chief engineer of the United States Army, declared that if a curved dam were constructed it would be certain to give way; while Commissioner Barnes, who was chief engineer of the South Penn Railroad, and stands high in his profession, expressed the belief that any other than a curved dam would not withstand the pressure. Similar differences of opinion were developed among engineers who were called upon to testify on this matter. Hence, it may not be surprising, when engineers cannot agree as to what is necessary for safety, that disasters like that at Mill River and Johnstown occur even after engineers have pronounced the structures safe.—Philadelphia Press.