BY W. A. COLCORD.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
Advocates of the observance of the first day of the week often seem to think they have proved their point when they have stated that certain notable events occurred on that day. And as this is about their only stock in trade in the way of proof, the greater the number of these there can be found, the better the institution is supposed to be established. Hence, the number is made to appear as large as possible. Thus, in a little sixteen-page anti-Sabbath pamphlet, the writer, W. S. Moore, before closing, sums up his reasons for observing the first day of the week, as follows:—
1. On this day Jesus Christ, the Lord, rose from the dead.
2. On this day he first appeared to his disciples after his resurrection from the dead.
3. He continued to meet his disciples—probably on other days also, but on this day especially—regularly each first day during the remainder of his stay on earth.
4. On this day, the first day, he ascended on high, was received into heaven out of sight of his disciples, and sat down on the right hand of God.
5. On this day Jesus sent forth the Holy Spirit, the promise of the Father, upon his disciples.
6. On this day the apostles began their missions under their great commission, “Go teach all nations,” etc.
7. The first converts to Jesus after he had assumed “all authority,” were made on the first day of the week.
8. In the apostolic age the disciples uniformly met on the first day to break bread, to commune, teach, and exhort.
9. Civil society requires me to rest on the first day of the week; and the Holy Spirit requires the Christian to submit to the civil law. Rom. 13: 1–6. Hence, I rest this day. The nine reasons are sufficient.
Here the first seven of the “nine reasons” presented are adduced in behalf of first-day observance upon the hypothesis that because certain noteworthy events took place upon a certain day of the week, that day, therefore, became great. But the query arises as to why all these great events took place on this day. From the array presented, the answer would naturally suggest itself: “Because it was the first day of the week.” But why was this day selected in preference to all others for these events? “Because they were great events.” Such reasoning reminds one of certain definitions given in our dictionaries. If you wish to find out what sulphur is, you will learn that it is “brimstone.” Then turn to the definition of brimstone, and you will learn that it is “sulphur.” Great events occurred on Sunday because it was the first day of the week. And that day was chosen for these events because they were great. This appears to be about the logic of the case, if there was any providential choice or selection in the matter; and if there was not, then it was a mere matter of course, and, therefore, of no particular bearing upon the sanctity of the day.
But it seems that in the effort to swell the number, some occasions have been pressed into service that, according to the record, could hardly have occurred on that day; at least not without some serious derangement of affairs. For instance, the ascension. This took place forty days after Christ’s resurrection. Acts 1: 4–11. How that could occur on the first day of the week we are unable to say, unless the resurrection occurred on some other day than the first day of the week; and that would knock the very cornerstone out of the whole Sunday argument. Six weeks complete make forty-two days. It may be that those who can make “after eight days” come around in one day less than eight days, can elongate forty days into forty-two.
But perhaps the matter may be extricated from mathematical difficulties by allowing that the first day of the week may not have come around exactly accurately back there. Perhaps this is the correct way of looking at it. There were so many changes being made then, and things were in such a state of transition, what wonder if the first day of the week should come around a little irregularly! When any great event was to transpire, it was so highly fitting and proper that it should occur on the first day of the week, that that day could be slipped in most any time! The week could be extended to nine or ten days, or contracted to five or six days. Instead of the events accommodating themselves to the natural order of the days, the order was made to accommodate itself to the arbitrary and irregular events. They must occur on Sunday. The day must bend to suit the event. This reminds one of the man who said he had always admired the wisdom and beneficence of God in making all the big rivers run by all the big towns. In the case before us, we are really afraid that some of these events are inland towns; that, if we may depend upon our reason and the accuracy of simple mathematical calculations, the Sunday river missed some of these great occasions by several miles, and ran along by others, not because it was the Sunday river, but because it was a river. They had to occur on some day, if they occurred at all. Let us notice the nine reasons above given, in order.
1. True, Christ rose on the first day of the week; not, however, because it was the first day of the week, but because it was “the third day” after his betrayal and crucifixion when he said he would rise. Luke 24: 21, 45, 46.
2. He also met with his disciples on this day, not because it was the first day of the week, but that they might be witnesses that he rose when he said he would. Luke 24: 48; Acts 5: 30–32.
3. That he continued to meet with his disciples “regularly each first day during the remainder of his stay on earth,” is a flattering statement in behalf of the Sunday to beguile the ignorant, but it is easier made than proved. There were five first days of the week after the resurrection day during that period, but a record of only three meetings of his disciples within that time. John 20: 26; 21: 1–14; Acts 1: 1–11. If all of these were on the first day of the week, they would still fall two short of bearing out the above statement. But the fact is, the record fails to state that either of them was on that day. The first was “after eight days,”—a mile or two beyond the Sunday river. The second was on a fishing occasion, and if on the first day of the week, our Sunday friends are welcome to the fish. And the third was forty days after the resurrection, or Thursday. Several inland towns here!
4. On this day, the first day of the week, Christ ascended on high. This is rather strange. The resurrection takes place on Sunday, and forty days after that is Sunday! Queer weeks to come out that way! Then Pentecost (a Greek word meaning fiftieth) takes place about ten days after the ascension, and that is also on Sunday! Another odd week! An inland town here, somewhere, we should say.
5. On the day of Pentecost, the Holy Spirit was poured out upon the disciples. Acts 2: 1–5. If this was on the first day of the week, it was not because it was that day, but because on that year, a day fifty days from the Passover, chanced to fall on Sunday.
6. On this day the apostles began their mission under the great commission, not, however, because it chanced to be that day, but because they were “endued with power from on high,” and Jesus had told them to wait until then. Luke 24: 49; Acts 1: 4.
7. If the first Christian converts after the resurrection were made on this day, it was not because it was the first day of the week, but because the first efforts after the resurrection were made in that direction on that day.
8. There is a record of just one religious meeting’s being held on the first day of the week in the apostolic age. If it is proper to speak of a uniformity of one, then the claim that “the disciples uniformly met on the first day” in that age, may be true.
9. Civil society requires us to rest on the first day of the week, and the Holy Spirit requires Christians to submit to the civil law. That is, when we are in Turkey, we must do as the Turks do, and when in heathen lands, do as the heathen do! In other words, if the laws of the land require us to violate the law of God, we must do it. If they say that we shall bow down to an image, we must bow down.—Cases like that of Shadrach, Meshach, and Abed-nego for example! If they say that we shall not pray to the God of heaven, we must not pray.—Case of Daniel! Or, to make a practical application of the rule to fit the case of our first-day friends, if civil society required men and women to rest on the seventh day, Sunday-keepers should “submit.” Would they do it? If not, why not? and what does this “reason” amount to? and why does anybody use it?
We wait for reasons more reasonable.