AdventAI

COMMERCIAL RELIGION.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 14., April 2, 1889

HOW THE CHURCHES ARE BECOMING BUSINESS CONCERNS.

[The following on this subject is from Bishop Huntington, of Syracuse, N. Y., in answer to a request from a correspondent of the New York Sun.]

“My views,” said Bishop Huntington, “have never been concealed, and I am entirely willing to state them to the public at any time and in any form. That commercial forces are pushing their way into the church is very obvious. This is seen repeatedly in the election of vestrymen. Spirituality seems often no longer the test of a church official: business success, high social position, shrewdness in the conduct of affairs are coming to be considered the more important qualifications for a good vestryman or trustee. I do not refer to the Episcopal Church alone, but to churches in general. The man poor in spirit, but rich commercially, is preferred as a church officer to the man poor in worldly goods, though rich spiritually. There are numerous instances daily before our eyes of men holding high places as church officials who would not hold such high positions, were spirituality the test of office.

“This commercial tendency is also obvious in the pew renting. The rich occupy the choice places, while the poor must sit in the obscure, out-of-the-way corners. The church becomes a club house, and this amounts in cases to an exclusion of the poor. If the church was to be merely a means of providing comfortable incomes for Sunday orators, and cosy seats for wealthy listeners, the pew-renting system might be a success. But as the church is for the common salvation of rich and poor alike, no system that shuts out the poor or puts the rich into a fashionable house with a saint’s name, at one end of the town, and the poor into a bare chapel by themselves, at the other end, can ever be a system that God will prosper. There is all that class of persons who in this generation are servants and laborers, but whose children in the next generation will be the lords and ladies of the land, all of whom, under the pew system, are just as completely and effectually excluded from the house of God as though it were written upon the door, ‘No admittance for servants and laborers here.’ The system virtually cuts off from the sound of the gospel and from all heavenly helps of the church, a portion of every population. It is well-nigh impossible, with the commercial influence to the front, with property as the controlling element, that the spiritual interest should not suffer. The question of how costly a pew or how high a tax the parishioner can afford, will obscure very often those simple merits of a meek and lowly heart. If it could be known openly in how many parishes at this moment some influential and managing men are secretly discussing the question of how they shall contrive to get rid of the minister they have, because he is not paying well in pew rents, or how they shall find one that will do that, an appeal of alarm would arise to the ears of God.

“I have long been an advocate of the free church system. I don’t believe men should own the church at all. It should be as free as the winds of heaven. The church is not here on sale. It is a gift. It should be such that people of every nationality, every race, every color, every condition, would be welcome. The doors should be open wide. No one should be excluded by class or social distinctions.

“Cathedrals built as an investment in real estate, or to give distinction to the city, instead of being built for the worshipers, is another influence of the commercial influence. Another commercial intrusion is the elaborate and costly church music, arranged to attract people to hear that, instead of the gospel. The employment of high-priced singers is substituted for churchly or ecclesiastical singing.

“The intrusion of politics into the church is not seen perhaps in any rivalry of the opposite political parties to gain control of the church, but I know of cases where rich parishioners have endeavored to influence the politics of their clergymen, and, not only that, but when displeased, would even by withdrawing some of their customary support, render the situation most embarrassing. I fear it is true, too, that rich parishioners do not disdain to influence the political course of their employees, operatives, or clerks, and even the poorer members of the church.

“Contributions to high and sacred undertakings are not meant to be wrung out of people’s fingers by rhetoric and declamation, by agents, by fairs and lotteries, by a sense of respectability, or by amiable deferences to the pastor’s expostulations. The commercial influence shows its predominance in this direction also. In prosperous times like ours, and in affluent communities, antichrist goes himself to church, patronizes preaching, buys a pew, gets himself elected to the vestry, and takes a hand in shaping the policy of the establishment, and, by blandishment or bluster, in pitching the keys of the pulpit. All that you may hear said of the mischief of this secular corruption in disordering Christ’s family, vitiating doctrine, emasculating the manhood of the ministry, and lowering the standard of personal righteousness, rather understates than exaggerates the facts. It is not scientific doubt, not atheism, not pantheism, not agnosticism, that in our day and in this land is likely to quench the light of the gospel. It is a proud, sensuous, selfish, luxurious, church-going, hollow-hearted prosperity. The door by which this has gained official entrance is the pew-renting system. Coming in by that door, it would intrench itself about the very altar, and debase the clergy itself.”