BY HAROLD STEARNS, M. D.
(Idaho Springs, Colo.)
SCIENCE has declared that there is no Devil. All that we are accustomed to ascribe to the agency of evil spirits can be explained more simply, we are told, as the result of inherited tendencies. Every method of inquiry known to science has failed to demonstrate the existence of evil spirits, and therefore it is assumed that there are none, and Satan must take his place as a mythological character, the production of an ignorant age. Says the Popular Science Monthly:—
If any human soul has gradually and voluntarily subjected itself to evil passions, what need is there to call in the hypothesis of diabolic agency to account for even the worst acts of which the man may be guilty? What says an apostle?—“Every man is tempted, when he is drawn away of his own lust, and enticed.” The logical law of parsimony forbids us to suppose anything beyond this. What lusts are, we know. What devils are, we know not, nor have we any means even of certifying ourselves in regard to their existence. Why, then, frame hypotheses beyond all need for them?
Much might be said in answer to this, even from the purely scientific stand-point. There are many things of whose existence we are certain, and which we have never “certified to ourselves” by actual demonstration. We speak of “life,” yet we are familiar only with its manifestations; of “electricity,” yet we know not what it is; of the “laws of gravitation,” yet of “gravity” we are in absolute ignorance. So may we not be certain at least of the existence of evil spirits because we see the evidence of their unseen influence upon human actions, in promptings so sudden and so imperative as to make it very difficult to account for them as simply results of inherited or acquired tendencies; promptings so repugnant often to the afflicted themselves, and yet so overpowering that almost without exception they ascribe them to the “influence of an evil spirit?”
But however interesting this phase of the question may be, we are more concerned with another question: What does the Bible teach on this subject? Science having pronounced its dictum that “Satan must go,” there is at once great consternation among those theological writers and speakers whose ambition it is to be considered progressive and liberal. It would seem to be an impossible task to so distort the teachings of the Bible, and especially those of the New Testament record, as to make it appear that the writers did not believe in evil spirits; yet theological acumen does not shrink from the task, and it is becoming more and more fashionable to consider Satan a personification of the evil tendencies of our natures, and belief in a personal Devil as decidedly old-fashioned.
The foregoing remarks, quoted from the Popular Science Monthly, were called forth by a recent article by Dr. Lyman Abbott, in which he expresses his belief in the agency of evil spirits. Yet he is careful to state that he “does not maintain the doctrine of demoniacal possession on theological grounds. Orthodoxy does not require belief in a Devil, but only in a God. It is not impossible to interpret the New Testament rationally, and disbelieve in the influence of evil spirits.” In answer to a correspondent who asks, “Will you be kind enough to say how you interpret these words of Christ: ‘I saw Satan as lightning fall from heaven’?” the Christian Union replies,—
It appears to us that Jesus Christ’s teaching implies a belief on his part in evil spirits and in demoniacal possession; but some scholars who are believers in, and followers of, Christ hold a different view, and we are not prepared to say that their interpretations are impossible.
It will be profitable to examine the testimony of the Gospels, and see if indeed there is any foundation for this attempted compromise with science. Remembering that the Gospels were written at a time when medical knowledge was in its infancy, and little if anything was known of insanity and allied disorders, we are at once struck with the fact that the authors of the Gospels invariably draw a distinction between insanity, disease, and demoniacal possession; and that, too, not only in a general way, but in particular cases where well-known diseases were simulated by those possessed by devils.
In Matt. 4:24, we read of those who were sick “with divers diseases and torments, . . . possessed with devils, and those which were lunatic, and those that had the palsy.” In Matt. 8:16 is the record: “They brought unto him many that were possessed with devils: and he cast out the spirits with his word, and healed all that were sick.” In both the above records a clear distinction is made between demoniacal possession and insanity, paralysis, and ordinary diseases; and an equally clear distinction in Christ’s methods of cure,—in the one case “healing,” in the other “casting out.”
In Matt. 9:32, we have the still more significant record of the dumb man possessed of a devil. Here the record plainly shows that this was not an ordinary case of dumbness due to physical defect; for as soon as the devil was cast out, the “dumb spake.” Matt. 12:22 records a similar case; but the most remarkable instance of this sort is recorded in Mark 9:17–30 and Luke 9:37–43. Here a child possessed of a devil is afflicted with symptoms so closely resembling epilepsy that we are almost surprised to find the father attributing his trouble to its proper cause. It has been claimed by many that this was indeed a case of epilepsy, and that the evangelist simply records the belief of his time in demoniacal possession; and this brings us to the questions, Is not this the case with all similar records? and did not Christ himself know better? If he did, then we must conclude that he not only allowed a great error to go uncorrected, but actually established it by his words and acts. Can we believe this of Him who came as the great Revealer of truth?
Let us notice the language used by Christ on this occasion. In Mark 9:25, we read: “When Jesus saw that the people came running together, he rebuked the foul spirit, saying unto him: Thou dumb and deaf spirit, I charge thee, come out of him and enter no more into him.” Is this the language of one who knew that there was no such thing as demoniacal possession?
If any further proof is needed, what shall we say of the temptations of Christ in the wilderness? These temptations were of such a character, and the language used in describing them is so clear, that it would be simply absurd to attribute them to “inherited tendencies.” Equally ridiculous is it to suppose that “inherited tendencies” are of such a character that, when driven out of a man by divine power, they may take possession of a herd of swine, and cause them to rush violently down a steep place into the sea, and be drowned! It is true, as James says, that a man “is temptedp. 436 when he is drawn away of his own lust, and enticed;” but it by no means follows that he may not be tempted in some other way. To deny the force of the evidence for the personality of evil spirits, to which we have partially called attention, and then build up a doctrine on one verse, as James 1:14, which is itself but a half truth, is an evidence of the lengths to which men are driven when they attempt to make the Bible conform to the constantly changing hypotheses of science.
We hear much in these days of agnosticism, and it is the latest fashion to talk of “Christian agnosticism;” and to look upon positive belief in the Bible as evidence of inferior knowledge. But surely God has not left us a chart so confused that we cannot know its meaning, nor be sure of the directions on which alone we must depend to reach the desired haven. To those who study it with a humble mind, God’s word is indeed a lamp to the feet and a light to the pathway.