The Greek Church No. 3: Schism With Rome
By W. A. C.
The fatal schism between the Greek and Latin churches did not occur until the ninth century. A jealous and contentious spirit had long prevailed between the bishops of Rome and Constantinople, and had sometimes kindled into acts of violence and rage. During the seventh century about the time of Leo the Isaurian, to whom we have already called attention, the bishops of Constantinople, supported by the power and authority of the emperors, withdrew from the Roman pontiffs a number of provinces over which they had previously exercised spiritual dominion. In the ninth century the contest became more violent, and broke forth with greater animosity and determination than ever. In the year 858 the emperor, Michael III., for some cause drove Ignatius, who was patriarch of Constantinople, from his see into exile, and placed Photius in his stead. A council which assembled at Constantinople in 861, vindicated and applauded the proceeding. Ignatius appealed to Pope Nicholas I., who espoused his cause, and in a council assembled at Rome in 862, excommunicated Photius and all his abettors. The newly elected patriarch, so far from being terrified by this excommunication, returned the compliment to the pope, and in a council convened at Constantinople in 866, declared Nicholas unworthy of the position he held in the Church, or of being admitted to the communion of Christians. In this same year Photius added to his jurisdiction the province of Bulgaria which Nicholas had also hoped to annex to his spiritual domain. While the pope was bitterly provoked at missing his aim, Photius went still farther and drew up a most violent charge of heresy against the Roman bishops and the Church of Rome in general, condemning their practice of fasting on the Sabbath, or seventh day of the week, their prohibiting priests from marrying, and various other matters of practice and doctrine. This bold and open charge laid a sure foundation for a lasting and total separation between the Greek and Latin churches. A similar charge was again made in the eleventh century. Leo IX., then in the papal chair, answered the charge by solemnly excommunicating all the Greek churches. The Grecian patriarch followed with a general excommunication of the Roman legates with all their adherents and followers. Thus the breach was made doubly sure. Several attempts have been made toward a reconciliation, but the demands of the Roman pontiffs, on the one hand, have been so arrogant and unreasonable; while the Greeks, on the other hand, have been so tenacious of their views, and so unwilling to submit to papal authority, that that reconciliation has seemed impossible. The creed formulated by the second council of Constantinople was nominally adopted by both the Eastern and the Western Church. But the Latins holding to the double procession of the Holy Ghost, that is, that it proceeded from both the Father and the Son, afterward interpolated to that part of the creed which stated that the Holy Ghost proceeded simply from the Father, the words filio-que, i. e., and from the Son. This has always proved an unsurmountable barrier to reconciliation between the two churches. In the negotiations toward reunion in the thirteenth century, Pope Gregory IX. agreed that the Greeks might omit filio-que from their creed providing they would conform to the Western Church in other matters, recognize papal jurisdiction, and burn all books written against Western doctrine. This the Eastern Church refused to do, regarding it as an attempt to foist upon it new creeds. Similar proposals were afterward made by succeeding popes, but were likewise rejected, the Greeks recognizing in each the intention of the popes of bringing them into submission and gaining universal supremacy. The Vatican decree of 1870, declaring the pope to be infallible, has served to intensify the separation. In all this is manifested the unconquerable tenacity with which the Eastern Church clings to doctrines and practices once established, and in a measure explains why missionary efforts are less numerous, and attended with greater embarrassments in those countries where this is the established church, than in many others. W. A. C.