BY J. G. HARDIE, JR.
(Canton, N. Y.)
RECENTLY I began to solicit signatures to the petitions which remonstrate against the passage of the Blair bills, in a town in Northern New York, where resides a judge of the Supreme Court. As he is acknowledged to be one of the clearest thinkers and ablest reasoners in the State, I was particularly anxious that his attention should be called to the petitions, and, if possible, his signature be obtained. So, accordingly, I called upon the judge at his office, and stated, as clearly as I could, the object of the petitions, asking him to sign them; but that he would not do, as he said he saw no objections to the passage of the bills.
I continued my work, and found that the majority fully indorsed our views on the subject and gave us their signatures. But the thought came to me that if we are correct on this question, and our arguments all as clear as they seem to be, why cannot such a one as Judge Tappin, who has been upon the bench of the Supreme Court for fifteen years, see it also? I concluded that either I had not clearly stated the matter, or that the Judge was biased or else that we are mistaken. Being in the town a few weeks later, I again called upon the Judge, to ascertain, if possible, which of the above conclusions should be adopted. Accordingly, I asked the Judge if I might see him further regarding the anti-Blair petitions.
“Well,” said he, “when you were here before, I had given the matter no previous thought, but since then I have looked up both of the bills and the resolutions, and am only too glad of an opportunity to sign a remonstrance against them.”