We have all heard of the woman to whom a volume of “Pilgrim’s Progress” with Explanatory Notes, was once given. On being asked afterward how she liked it, she replied that she “liked the book itself exceedingly well; that the book was all plain; and she hoped to be able after a time to understand the notes!”
So we feel like saying frequently in regard to answers to the question why people now keep Sunday for the Sabbath. We understand the question and the issue involved therein; but can anybody explain the explanation?
For instance, at one of Mr. Moody’s meetings in Chicago week before last, the question was asked, “How is it that Christians keep the first day of the week, when the fourth commandment says it should be the seventh?” To this Dr. Driver, who goes with Mr. Moody to answer questions, and who has the reputation of being a “great gun” in this direction, replied; and from his reply we quote the following representative passages.
He is reported in the Chicago Inter Ocean as saying: “In the Mosaic dispensation, day did not mean a mere period of twenty-four hours, but day is the best defined period of time we have in the Bible.” If “day” does not mean twenty-four hours, what does it mean? Some say a thousand years; some, ten thousand; some, a hundred thousand; some, three hundred and sixty thousand; and some, an indefinite period of immense duration. How, then, is “day” the best defined period in the Bible? Who can explain?
Again we quote: “As far as the Scriptures go, it makes no difference what day we keep, but we must keep one day in seven.” We would respectfully ask how we know we must keep one day in seven. The fourth commandment of the decalogue is the only law which enjoins one day in seven. From this alone the obligation, “we must keep one day in seven,” comes. But the fourth commandment does not put it that way. It says “the seventh day,” not “one day in seven,” making it as definite as it is possible to make it. And what right has any one to change the wording from “the seventh day,” that is, a definite seventh part of time, to “a seventh day,” that is, an indefinite seventh part? “Oh,” the reply is, “it does not say the seventh day of the week.” Then, we ask again, how do you know that this rest day is to come once in every seven days? and that “we must keep one day in seven”? If it is not the seventh day of the week to which the commandment refers, what period is it the seventh day of? If it is replied, the seventh day after every six days of labor, we answer, The commandment does not say the seventh day “after every six days of labor” any more than it says, the seventh day “of the week.” But do not six days of labor and one of rest make a week? And is not this weekly cycle the only period with which the commandment has to do? And, moreover, does not the week owe its origin exclusively to the great facts which the commandment brings to view; namely, the six days’ work of God in the creation of the world, his rest upon the first seventh day of time, and his blessing and setting apart each succeeding seventh day from that time as the Sabbath for man? And when therefore the commandment says, “The seventh day is the Sabbath,” does it not mean the seventh day of the week? Can it mean anything else? Is it not just as plain as if it had been worded, “the seventh day of the week is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God”? Can any one deliberately, without outraging at once both his common sense and his moral nature, answer these questions in the negative?
Two lines further on the Doctor says: “The sabbatical Sabbath and the Jews’ seventh day came together at our Lord’s crucifixion.” How much of this sentence must be attributed to typographical error, we will not undertake to say. But there it stands as a part of the answer to the question why Christians keep the first day when the commandment says the seventh. But like the woman who wanted some one to explain the “notes,” we would like to have some one explain this answer.
Then he undertakes to draw a little comfort from Paul, and this is it: “Paul wrote fourteen epistles, and never used the word ‘Sabbath’ but once, and that was, ‘Let no man judge you regarding meats and drinks, and the keeping of the Sabbath.’”
And this is offered as a reason why Christians keep the first day, when the commandment says the seventh. Can we ever hope to understand such an answer as that? Then he refers to the scripture, “The Sabbath was made for man and not man for the Sabbath,” as proof that if we keep “a Sabbath of rest we fulfil the law.” At the same time, he would probably denounce the observance of the seventh day, as the rankest heresy, worthy of being restrained by law. It seems to make a great difference, after all, when that “a day of rest,” and “any seventh part of time,” comes in. “Any seventh day” is a very convenient catch-phrase when theory only is under consideration; but when it comes to practice, its own friends will strangle it as soon as we.