(On this subject The Living Church gives utterance to the following:—
There are some good and gentle souls to whom everything in the way of controversy in religion is shocking. Theirs is a kind of placid piety which is not to be despised, and for which even in the church militant there is a place. It should not, however, be exalted above the more sturdy type which has the courage of its convictions, and seeks to propagate them by all means that are lawful. There are other good people, not so gentle, who deprecate controversy because they fear its effects upon some of their own views and practices. The least agitation disturbs their peace, hence agitation must be wrong. As the church was in their childhood, or as they conceived it to be, so must it always be. Fifteen years in a vestry are counted by them as a better precedent than fifteen centuries of the thought, the life, and the work of the church. Controversy we must have, while human nature remains what it is; only when it degenerates into contention and persecution does it endanger the unity of the spirit and the bond of peace. Yet those who are loudest in declaiming against controversy are often most forward in advocating repressive legislation against those who value peace and principle as much as themselves. They charge their fellow-churchmen with agitations that disturb their peace, and straightway set about to agitate the disturbers into subjection. The church may be disrupted, but their peace must not be disturbed! The peace party is the attacking party every time. Open discussion, appeal to facts and reason and history, are unendurable. “Agitation” must be stopped at any cost.
These are true words, and it would be well if their truthfulness were more generally recognized in the world of religious thought. So long as religious error exists—of which all must admit there is no lack at the present time—so long will there be religious controversy, for truth and error cannot exist in harmony with one another. The absence of religious controversy is not itself an evidence that there is nothing wrong in the religious status of a community. It may be often only an indication that error is holding the fort with undisturbed supremacy. In such a case the sooner its supremacy is disputed the better; and such a step of course involves religious controversy. Controversy is in such cases always preferable to peace.
That the “peace” party in such disputes is always the aggressive party is a statement capable of abundant demonstration. It has been so in all religious controversies of the past, and is so at the present time. The controversy which arose from the preaching of the doctrines of the Reformation disturbed the peace of Rome, and to quell the agitation of which she had such a horror she promptly undertook to agitate the Reformers into subjection. Just so does the preaching of the truths of the third angel’s message, especially the Sabbath truth, agitate and disturb the peace of many who are to-day complacently anchored in the calm waters of popular theology, and it is coming to be understood among them that it is imperatively necessary for them to do something. It will never do to allow this agitation to go on and disrupt communities. They are very anxious for peace,—so anxious that they are willing to take the most aggressive measures to secure it. Religious controversy is for them a more dreadful thing even than religious war. In short, the “peace” party, the aggressive party, and the party which feels itself wanting in argument to sustain its views, are almost always one and the same.
L. A. S.