A RESPONSE

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 10, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 36.

Read the full edition

A RESPONSE.

In the Review of Aug. 13 was published an article entitled, “Questions for Sunday-keepers.” Rev. J. M. Foster, of Cincinnati, Ohio, a district secretary of the National Reform Association, sends us an article entitled, “The Christian Sabbath,” which he submits as a reply to the questions. Our readers will remember that the questions, for the most part, called for proof-texts in support of the first day of the week as a Sabbath or sacred day. As Mr. Foster does not attempt any direct answer to them, and his article is largely made up of old and thread-bare arguments, such as the seventh-part-of-time theory, we do not deem it necessary to publish it. We will take time to notice only a few of his statements. Following his introduction, he says:—
The Christian Sabbath has all the advantages of the Old Testament Sabbath, with the superadded advantages of the New. It comes every seventh day, reminding us that God created the world in six days and rested the seventh, and set that apart as a memorial of creation; and that seventh day recurs on the first day of the week, reminding us that Christ finished his greater work of redemption on the first day, and set that apart as a memorial of his greater work.
It would greatly add to the cogency of their reasoning if Sunday advocates would first show from the Scriptures that there is such a thing as the “Christian Sabbath,” before they proceed to talk about its advantages, superadded or otherwise. The only weekly Sabbath we have observed that the Bible makes mention of, is “the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.”
Mr. Foster says this “Christian Sabbath” “comes every seventh day,” “and that seventh day recurs on the first day of the week.” This is edifying information. Does he mean that it comes twice a week, or that the seventh day is the first day? He says it reminds us “that God created the world in six days, and rested the seventh,” and also reminds us “that Christ finished his great work of redemption on the first day, and set that apart as a memorial of his greater work.” These statements are all right except in three points: The Bible nowhere says the first day is a memorial or reminder of creation, or of redemption, or that Christ set it apart for anything. All that Mr. Foster’s statements lack is the evidence. Our twenty-five questions for Sunday-keepers called for texts and not assumptions.
Mr. Foster continues:—
Our New Testament Christian Sabbath is the original and permanent institution. . . . Christ is the mediator. The ten commandments are in his hands as our rule of life. We are under this law to Christ. And as the administrator of the fourth commandment, he changed the day from the seventh to the first day of the week on the morning of his resurrection.
How an institution can be the “original” and yet be different, or “permanent” and be “changed,” is a little beyond our comprehension. We are also informed in this last quotation just when and by whom the change of the Sabbath was made. This is something divines have been trying to find out this long time. Mr. Foster, it seems, has discovered the long-looked-for information, although he did not tell us just where he got it. His testimony would be complete, and right to the point—would doubtless be used by ministers, doctors, lawyers, and statesmen all over the land—had he only told us where in Inspiration it is found. This is the only missing link there has been in the evidence for Sunday observance from its earliest agitation,—the evidence.
Mr. F. does, however, attempt to give a shadow of proof, citing two texts, and only two, in support of his assertions. We will notice them. He says:—
The change was predicted. “And when these days are expired, it shall be that upon the eighth day, and so forward, the priest shall make your burnt-offerings upon the altar; . . . and I will accept you, saith the Lord God.” Eze. 43:27. This language is symbolical. . . . Their eighth day is our first day. The Christian Sabbath realizes the fulfillment of this prophecy.
This is altogether too gratuitous and “far-fetched.” When what days are expired? Let us get the connection. Verse 18 says: “These are the ordinances of the altar in the day when they shall make it, to offer burnt-offerings thereon,” etc. Verses 26, 27: “Seven days shall they purge the altar and purify it; and they shall consecrate themselves. And when these days are expired, it shall be, that upon the eighth day, and so forward, the priest shall make your burnt-offerings upon the altar,” etc. What days, then, we ask, does this “eighth day” follow? Not the seven days of the week, as Mr. F. would have us to understand, but the seven days “purging the altar,” and the priests “consecrating themselves.” Similar instructions are found in Leviticus 8 and 9: “And ye shall not go out of the door of the tabernacle of the congregation in seven days, until the days of your consecration be at an end: for seven days shall he consecrate you” (chap. 8:33); “And it came to pass on the eighth day, that Moses called Aaron and his sons, and the elders of Israel; and he said unto Aaron, Take thee a young calf for a sin-offering and a ram for a burnt-offering, without blemish, and offer them before the Lord.” Chap. 9:1, 2. Eze. 43:27 no more predicts a change of the Sabbath than Leviticus 8 and 9 prove that Sunday was kept in the days of Moses.
But we come now to what Mr. F. claims as his best argument. “The prime argument,” he says, “for the change of day, is found in Heb. 4:10.” Upon this he comments thus:—
In this chapter the author quotes the 95th psalm, where there is a promise of “entering into rest.” Then he proves that this rest could not be the seventh-day Sabbath, for they had that rest “from the foundation of the world.” It could not refer to Canaan, for “Joshua had given them” that rest, and yet David afterward spoke of “another day.” It could not refer to heaven, for multitudes of Israel, falling in the wilderness, went to heaven, and yet God had sworn in his wrath that they should not enter into this rest. There is only one other rest to which David could refer; viz., the Christian Sabbath.
Thus Mr. Foster takes the Christian Sabbath as the rest which remains to the people of God, not because the apostle says that is it, but because, from his reasoning, it is the only thing left not mentioned that it could be! His reasoning on this is like the man’s who sold a good-for-nothing dog to a hunter for a chipmunk dog, explaining afterward that he had tried him for everything else and found him to be worthless; and as God had made nothing in vain, he supposed the dog must surely be a chipmunk dog. Mr. F’s conclusions lack the positive testimony.
One error paves the way for another. If Mr. Foster had not taken an erroneous position on the time of the reward of the saints, he would have had plenty of “rest” to meet all the specifications of Hebrews 4, without taking, as a “last resort,” the unscriptural dogma of Sunday-keeping. He says, “Multitudes of Israel, falling in the wilderness, went to heaven.” But the Bible nowhere says so. It does say, however, of as good a man as David, and a thousand years after his death, that he had not yet gone to heaven. Acts 2:34. It informs us that the righteous will be “recompensed at the resurrection of the just.” Luke 14:14. And this event is located at the second coming of Christ. 1 Thess. 4:15, 16. Here, then, is a rest that remaineth to be enjoyed by the people of God in the heavenly Canaan, the land promised to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob,—the earth made new. Rom. 4:13; Heb. 11:13, 39, 40; Matt. 5:5.
Mr. F. summarizes as follows:—
It is evident, therefore, that an institution ordained by the Creator in the beginning, re-enacted at Sinai with added obligations, and re-enacted again by the Son of God on the morning of his resurrection, with added obligations and responsibilities, is the same original and absolute, universal and permanent institution, in spite of the mere change of day. From this it follows that no express command is needed in the New Testament to observe the Lord’s day.
Although the Sabbath when “re-enacted” (to use Mr. F’s term) at Sinai was the same in every respect as when ordained at creation, yet God gave an express command then, stating the day and the reason for its observance. But when we come down to the resurrection, although there is an alleged “change of day” and another “re-enactment,” yet we are gravely told that “it follows that no express command is needed.” That is just what we should expect, under the circumstances, would be needed. There are three good-sized gaps in the above statements for Mr. F. to fill up: 1. To prove there has been such a change as he speaks of; 2. To show that Christ re-enacted the Sabbath institution; and, 3. To show how he could do this without giving an express command.
One of our questions asked for one authentic instance in which any historian or ecclesiastical writer previous to A. D. 194, applies the term “Lord’s day” to the first day of the week. In reply to this, Mr. F. says: “Writers during the first three centuries refer to the Christian Sabbath as the ‘eighth day,’ ‘the day of the sun,’ ‘the first day of the week,’ and ‘the Lord’s day.’” We did not ask for writers during the first three centuries, but those before 194 A. D. He, however, informs us that “Irenæus and Clemens Alexandrinus (178 A. D.) attest the general respect for the Lord’s day.” But this is altogether too general and indefinite. Did they use the term “Lord’s day”? We should like the citation to their writings. Like his other statements, this lacks confirmation.
To recapitulate: According to Mr. Foster, this Christian Sabbath is the first, the seventh, and the eighth day; the permanent, the changed, and the original Sabbath; the Christian Sabbath; the Lord’s day, and the “same original and absolute, universal and permanent institution, in spite of the mere change of day.” This is almost overwhelming. If assumptions, adjectives, and appellations could make something out of nothing, we certainly think Mr. Foster would succeed well at the business.
W. A. C.