AdventAI

ENGLISH AND WELSH DISESTABLISHMENT.

By Editor

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 34., August 27, 1889

THE disestablishment problem in Great Britain divides itself into three sections—a fact due to the diverse features of the question presented by England, Scotland, and Wales. Disestablishment in Scotland has, of necessity, nothing to do with disestablishment in England. The state church in Scotland is not Episcopal but Presbyterian, and as all the rest of Scotland is virtually Presbyterian of some shade or other, the religious warfare there is an internecine conflict between Presbyterians. The principle fought for, of course, is the same as in England. Welsh disestablishment, again, is not agitated for on the same grounds as in England. In England, the battle will have to be fought out on the question of sheer principle. The Church is powerful there, and in a majority, and the attachment of a large class of the people to it cannot be denied. But in Wales, it is only the Church of a small minority, and it is a church which, through its alliances with the landlord interest and its persistent opposition to all attempts at reform in Wales in the past, has made itself hateful to the mass of the nation. Besides, it is a standing argument of Welsh Liberationists that the established Church in Wales is an alien church. It never had any pretensions to call itself the Welsh Church, and is in reality only the Church of England in Wales—a designation which in itself stamps the anomaly of its claim to being the national church of the principality. When a church is the church of a minority and a church out of sympathy with the national life of the people, the arguments against the principle of a state church—strong though they be in themselves—become overwhelmingly forcible.

The next step in the great anti-Church warfare will, undoubtedly, be the disestablishment of the Church of England in Wales. This is the aspect of the question upon which all Liberals now lay most stress. It constitutes a demand in favor of which Wales has persistently declared by an overwhelming majority. Even in the present Conservative Parliament . . . a motion in favor of Welsh disestablishment was only lost by a majority of eighteen. This means in the next Parliament—for nobody now doubts that the next Parliament will be Liberal—a substantial majority against the Church. The Church in Wales is doomed; and none know this better than its own advocates, who are now making heroic efforts—and, it must be confessed, with much success—to strengthen their position in the towns, that they may obtain from commerce a voluntary supply of revenues which have hitherto been drawn from the unwilling tillers of the soil. Unwilling, indeed, has the Church, to its cost, recently found some of these tillers of the soil in Wales. The most remarkable phase of the disestablishment agitation has been what has become known as the Welsh Tithe War. Some intrepid farmers in North Wales, tired of listening to vapid talk and of waiting for a relief that never came, took into their heads that they would refuse to pay the tithes which went to support the established church, unless they obtained a very substantial reduction in the amount to be paid. These men very naturally argued that the country rectors ought not to be allowed to draw in a time of agricultural depression the amount of tithe which had been fixed in days of agricultural prosperity. In this way, the farmers took the work of disendowment into their own hands, and brought the uncertainties even of state-appointed incomes very close home to the minds of the rural clergy. As many of the persons proved as obstinate as the farmers, collisions ensued; and in many parishes tithes were collected by means of auctioneers surrounded by imposing body-guards of police and military. Wales has not been so convulsed since the famous Chartist riots; and, like most public commotions, the Tithe War has succeeded in advancing the disestablishment question several stages.

Inevitable as the doom of the establishment in Wales seems to be, it is not quite so certain what its fate in England will be. The introduction of a measure to disestablish the Welsh Church will, of necessity, raise the question with regard to England. The Church, be it remembered, is the Church of England in Wales. The Welsh bishoprics are all under the jurisdiction of the province of Canterbury. Thus, in disestablishing the Church in Wales, Parliament cannot help treading on the toes of the Church in England. At the same time we do not believe that English disestablishment will be brought about in the near future.—Interior.