AdventAI

THIN, THINNER, THINNEST.

By L. D. Santee

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 38., September 24, 1889

BY ELD. L. D. SANTEE.

IN a late issue of The Christian Standard (Disciple), an article appeared headed, “The Lord’s Day.” I suppose it to be editorial, as it is without signature. It begins by reference to the texts commonly quoted by advocates of the first day. Here is a quotation that furnishes something new under the sun:—

From an expression in the epistle of Barnabas, it would almost seem that the early Christians believed the ascension of the Lord Jesus to have taken place on the first day of the week.

He quotes “Barnabas” (an authority pronounced by all good scholars to be spurious), and says that from him it “almost seems.” I have italicized the “almost” in the quotation, because “almost” signifies a failure. A hunter says, “I almost got a deer,” and every one knows that he didn’t get it. So in regard to this quotation, Barnabas does not say that the early Christians believed it. But if they had, what then?—They would have been mistaken, that is all. From his resurrection (which took place on Sunday morning), any one who can count “forty” will tell you at once that the forty days end on Thursday. In our almanacs a certain day is marked “Ascension Thursday.” So falls an assumption on which they build an inference for Sunday-keeping. I continue the quotation from the article in question:—

Will he come the second time on this sacred day? Why not cherish the thought that such may be the case?

As I read these thoughts, based entirely on the wish to have it so, I thought, What a degeneration from the sturdy sledge-hammer strokes of Alexander Campbell! He came out with his splendid motto, “Where the Scriptures speak, we speak. Where the Scriptures are silent, we are silent.” And then as we considered what Barnabas “almost” made it seem, the contrast was not flattering. Of course he brings in Rev. 1:10, and assumes that it is the first day of the week, though the Bible nowhere tells him so. Again we quote from him:—

At first the disciples of Jesus kept the Sabbath according to the fourth commandment, for by birth and training they were Jews; but their affection for the Christ led them to observe also as a sacred time, without an express divine command, the day on which so many events . . . had taken place.

O writer, if you were a Campbellite, you would be silent after this; but as you are not, we follow you farther. The Bible says: “This is the love of God, that we keep his commandments.” 1 John 5:3. According to this article, the disciples showed their love by just the reverse. After referring to several of the Fathers, he frankly comes out with this admission: “At first there was no abstinence from work on the Lord’s day;” that is, the early Christians worked on Sunday the same as they did on Monday. Then, according to this writer, it is almost a certainty that in the account given in Acts 20:7, the disciples had worked all day Sunday, and then gathered to break bread in the evening. Another quotation from the closing part of his article, is worthy of thought:—

Though being an institution under the law of liberty, [O Alexander Campbell, where is your motto?] work does not appear to have been formally interdicted or rest formally enjoined.

Now let us consider concessions made in this article on the Lord’s day: “Without an express divine command;” “At first there was no abstinence from work on the Lord’s day;” “Work does not appear to have been formally interdicted or rest enjoined.”

Here, then, is what is left: Sunday without divine appointment, and a working-day; and so this institution sits helpless, with no Peter to say to it: “In the name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth rise up and walk;” no Paul to command, “Stand upright on thy feet;” but it waits patiently for the crutches of legislation to give it the power of locomotion.