THE COUNCILS

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 24, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 38.

Read the full edition

THE COUNCILS.

BY ELD. R. S. WEBBER.
(Pittsfield, Me.)
Speaking of the councils of the Christian Church, Chambers, in his Encyclopedia, vol. 3, pp. 278, 279, says:—
Council, or synod, is an assembly of ecclesiastical dignitaries held for the purpose of regulating the doctrine or discipline of the church. As early as the second century, church councils were convened in which only one or two provinces took part, the bishops and presbyters binding themselves to carry out the decisions arrived at in their own communities. These assemblies were commonly held in the chief town or metropolis of the province, and the bishop of such capitals—who, after the third century, bore the title of Metropolitan—was wont to preside over the meetings, which possessed no other legislative power than flowed from the mutual agreement of the members. Over these provincial councils were established, at a later period, the diocesan synods, exercising authority over several united provinces, and finally the national councils. After the fourth century, when the Christian religion was established in the Roman Empire, we read of ecumenical, i. e., universal, councils, so called because all the bishops of Christendom were invited or summoned by the emperor. In earlier times, all Christian teachers, presbyters, and others were invited to take part in the councils; but after the opening of the fourth century, only the bishops were convened. According to the doctrine of the Roman Catholic Church, the pope alone, or, by way of exception, in some cases the college of cardinals, had the power of convening ecumenical councils, which were supposed to represent the universal Church under the guidance of the Holy Ghost. Questions were determined by the majority of votes, and the pope or his proxy presided, and confirmed the resolutions carried in the synod. In matters of faith, councils professed to be guided by the Holy Scriptures and the traditions of the church, while in lighter matters human reason and expediency were consulted. In the former, ecumenical councils are held to be infallible; and hence it is maintained that all such synods have agreed together; but in other matters of discipline, etc., the latest synod decides questions. The question of the pope’s subordination to the decrees of the ecumenical councils, was long and warmly debated. Twenty ecumenical councils are recognized in the Roman Catholic Church—nine Eastern and eleven Western:—
  1. The synod of apostles at Jerusalem. Acts 15.
  2. The first Council of Nicaea (325 A. D.).
  3. First Council of Constantinople, convoked under the emperor Theodosius the Great (381 A. D.), to determine the Catholic doctrine regarding the Holy Ghost.
  4. The first Council of Ephesus, convened under Theodosius the Younger (431 A. D.).
  5. The Council of Chalcedon, under the emperor Marcian (451 A. D.).
  6. The second Council of Constantinople, under Justinian (553 A. D.), which condemned the doctrine of Origen and others.
  7. The third Council of Constantinople convoked under the emperor Constantine (Pogonatus V.) (681 A. D.).
  8. The second Council of Nicaea held in the reign of the empress Irene and her son Constantine (787 A. D.), to establish the worship of images. Against this council Charlemagne convened a counter-synod at Frankfort (794 A. D.).
  9. The fourth Council of Constantinople, under Basilius and Adrian (869 A. D.).
  10. The first Lateran Council held in Rome, under the emperor Henry V., and convoked by the pope Calixtus II. (1123 A. D.).
  11. The second Lateran Council, under the emperor Conrad III., and Pope Innocent II. (1139 A. D.).
  12. The third Lateran Council, convened by Pope Alexander III. (1179 A. D.) in the reign of Frederick I. of Germany, condemned the errors and impieties of the Waldenses and Albigenses.
  13. The fourth Lateran Council (1215 A. D.).
  14. The first ecumenical Synod of Lyon (1245 A. D.).
  15. The second ecumenical Synod of Lyon (1274 A. D.).
  16. The Synod of Vienne in Gaul (1311 A. D.).
  17. 1414 A. D.
  18. 1430 A. D.
  19. The celebrated Council of Trent (1545–1563 A. D.).
  20. The Council of the Vatican 1869–70. The Vatican Council decreed the infallibility of the pope.
While the number of the general councils is given as found in Chambers’s Encyclopedia already referred to, for lack of space his remarks concerning the councils are but partially quoted.
It will be seen from the foregoing list of councils, that the first nine were held in the East; and as Protestants reckon the Council of Nicaea the first of the general councils, the first eight of these were Oriental. They were convoked by the emperors for the following reason, as given by the American Encyclopedia, vol. 5, p. 423:—
This was because the church did not then extend beyond the limits of the Roman Empire, and because the first Christian emperors naturally assumed to protect and promote the interests of the church which their predecessors had persecuted.
It will also be seen that the first Lateran Council held in Rome (1123 A. D.), was convoked by Pope Calixtus. And as this was the first general council held in the West, it is supposed by some to be the first over which the pope had much influence. But this is far from the truth; for over all the councils convened in the East, from the Council of Nicaea to the first council held at Rome, A. D. 1123, the power of the pope of Rome was mighty. In the second general council, the first held at Constantinople, A. D. 381, it was decreed that “the bishop of Constantinople should hold the first rank after the bishop of Rome.” (See Can. 3. Hefele’s History of the Church. Councils, vol. 2, p. 357.)
Again Hefele says (vol. 1, p. 44):—
The signatures of the pope’s legates, Hasius, Vitus, and Vincentius, subscribed to the acts of the council before the other bishops, must be regarded as a sanction from the See of Rome to the decrees of Nicaea. Five documents dating from the fifth century, mention, besides, a solemn approval of the acts of the Council of Nicaea, given by Pope Sylvester and a Roman synod of 275 bishops. It is granted that these documents are not authentic, as we shall show in the history of the Council of Nicaea; but we nevertheless consider it very probable that the Council of Nicaea was recognized and approved by a special act of Pope Sylvester, and not merely by the signature of his legates, for the following reasons:—
a. The fourth ecumenical council looked upon the papal confirmation as absolutely necessary for insuring the validity of the decrees of the council, and there is no good ground for maintaining that this was a new principle, and one which was not known and recognized at the time of the Nicene Council.
β. Again, in 485, a synod composed of above forty bishops from different parts of Italy, was quite unanimous in asserting in opposition to the Greeks, that the 318 bishops of Nicaea had their decisions confirmed by the authority of the Holy Roman Church (confirmationem rerum atque auctoritatem sanctae Romanae ecclesiae detulerunt. —Hard. II., 856).
γ. Pope Julius I. in the same way declared, a few years after the close of the Council of Nicaea, that ecclesiastical decrees (the decisions of synods) ought not to be published without the consent of the bishop of Rome, and that this is a rule and a law of the church.—Socrat. Hist. Eccl. II., 17.
δ. Dionysius the Less also maintained that the decisions of the Council of Nicaea were sent to Rome to be approved.
(Concluded next week.)