It is not just to judge a man’s life by its exceptions. A single brick, if it be an exceptional brick, is not “a fair test of the whole structure.” This is true, whether the brick is far above or far below the average. Because a man has once in his life sunk down below his true character, if he has risen again nevermore to sink, it is not fair to sneeringly single out that blemish as a specimen of his manhood; and because a man has risen once in his life to extraordinary lofty achievement, if he has fallen back to his own level nevermore to rise, it is not fair to refer with pride to that achievement as a specimen of his strength. While it is true that a man is no stronger than his weakest point, when that point is involved in the testing, yet that weakest point may be now entirely eliminated from his character, leaving behind nothing but the ugly surface-blemish on his record; and while it is true that what we have done once we can generally do again, yet if, as a matter of fact, we have never succeeded in doing it again, it is not fair to credit ourselves with a present ability which does not in reality appear to exist. To ferret out past mistakes, and fasten them on another’s character as its label, or to herald an isolated past achievement as a sample of our present power, is to reverse the first principle of truth, and make the exception the rule. How much harm and injustice are done by such unsound judgment! To be fair, and to make legitimate deductions, one must judge a character, a principle, a tendency, at its normal best, not from the highly forced single success,—still less from its poorest illustrations.—S. S. Times.
Judging Character by Exceptions Is Unjust
From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 38., September 24, 1889