AdventAI

CONDEMNED BY THEIR OWN TESTIMONY.

By W. A. C.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 38., September 24, 1889

The aims and arguments of the National Reform Association can land, logically, in nothing but a union of Church and State. But when their efforts are arraigned in this light, these Reformers deny the charge most stoutly. Thus the Christian Statesman of Aug. 29, 1889, says:—

We hold as strenuously as do our opponents to the absolute separation and independence of Church and State, but we also hold with Prof. Leiber that the theory of American institutions “requires the total separation of the State from the Church—not from religion.”

And for once they have favored us with a definition of what a union of Church and State is. The same paper, same article, says:—

A union of Church and State exists where the Church usurps control over the State as on the Romish theory, or where the State assumes to establish and control the Church as in England.

Now we will go back but one number of this paper and prove, by this very definition, that National Reformers do advocate a union of Church and State. In the Statesman of Aug. 22, 1889, the following passage of Scripture is quoted with the parenthetical expression thrown in, which unmasks the hideous form of a union of Church and State upon their own testimony:—

“For the nation and kingdom that will not serve thee [the church] shall perish; yea, those nations shall be utterly wasted.”

It is the duty of the nation, then, to “serve the Church,” according to National Reform interpretation. But this is the Romish theory exactly, and that, the Statesman says, is a union of Church and State. And yet it claims to hold as strenuously as any one “to the absolute separation and independence of Church and State”! How much independence is there in servitude? we should like to ask. All the difference between the Catholic theory and the National Reform theory of a union of Church and State is only as to which church should “usurp control over the State,” the Catholic or the Protestant Church. The National Reformers say the Protestant, because that, they claim, is the only true church. The Romanists say the Catholic Church, because that, they likewise urge, alone is right. It is not a question with either whether the nation should serve the Church, but which church should be served. It is true, National Reformers have sometimes been so exceedingly pious and thoughtful as to substitute the word “religion,” for the word “church.” But the wittiness of this is soon lost when it is remembered that Catholicism is a religion also, claiming to be the Christian religion, and that if the matter were put to a vote between the two denominations as to which had the genuine, the Catholics would outnumber the Protestants two to one. The tricky evasion in the use of terms by no means banishes the theory. Catholics favor a union of State and religion, but they want the privilege of defining the religion. National Reformers favor the same, only they want the say as to the religion. The Romish theory is, that the State should be subservient to the Church. The National Reform theory is the same as is manifest in their demanding that the State shall teach religion in the public schools, and compel everybody to keep Sunday. What is bred in the bone will stick in the flesh. There is no use of National Reformers denying that their theory is anything more or less than a union of Church and State.

W. A. C.