The ease with which some people can dispose of difficult problems, and get around perplexing questions, is truly wonderful. The general and increasing disregard for Sunday by the masses of the people, and the laxity with which it is observed by the great majority of even church-members, have begun to alarm the ministers throughout the country for the future of the day. Notwithstanding the agitation that has been going on in the land over the Sabbath question for the past forty years, and the continued and repeated calls for the divine authority for first-day observance, the majority of these “shepherds of the flock” have been content to let the matter rest so long as the people generally continued to observe the day. As I once heard a Presbyterian minister say, in preaching on the proper observance of the Sabbath, after taking his texts in Ex. 20:8–11, and Isa. 58:13, 14. He said:—
It is not my purpose this morning to state why I observe the first day of the week instead of the seventh, as specified in the commandment as the Sabbath. I do not think my congregation are at all uneasy over this question, and so long as they do not agitate it, I shall not.
And this is the way it has generally been disposed of. Only now and then has one ventured to defend the Sunday. The majority have shown a general aversion to agitate the question. But as the result of this quiescent way of dealing with the question, and the light and truth that have been shining on the other hand, the people have been losing their regard for the day as a sacred institution. They have heard no scripture read that supports its claim to divine appointment, and are becoming aware that there is none to read. And now these men have a mighty incubus on their hands. They are beginning to awake to the fact that no matter what may have been the prevailing opinion in the past, or how great may have been the number holding to that opinion, it will not do to meet argument with silence, or defend a religious practice by keeping still. The logical results of such a course are beginning to be manifest. The religious regard for Sunday is dying out. And now these men are alarmed over the future prospects of the day, and in perplexity begin to ask, “What can be done to save the Sunday?”
The Rev. Dr. Greer, in the Trinity Record, writes an article, copied into the New York Observer, of July 18, upon “The Loss of Sunday.” In this he speaks of the manner in which Sunday is being less and less regarded as a religious day. He says:—
The tendency of the change that has taken place, and is still going on, is to dissociate the American Sunday from all religious uses and sanctions, and to convert it into a secular holiday.
And yet men are growing better and better for all such a “tendency,” and we are grandly marching on to the temporal millennium! But this is a serious matter, at least to the Sunday observer, and so Mr. Greer asks:—
How can this tendency, which good citizens deprecate, be arrested and changed?
This is the burning question. How is it to be done? How some of these “good citizens” say it should be arrested,—by compulsory legislation,—should make the purple come to the cheek of every person professing the name of Protestant, for shame. What is the duty of ministers of the gospel on all religious questions, is summed up in Paul’s charge to Timothy, in which he says, “Preach the word.” But there are some difficulties in defendingp. 506 this Sunday sabbath from “the word.” So Mr. Greer says:—
We cannot go back to the old Sabbatarianism, for that is gone, neither is it necessary to question the origin of Sunday, whether it began in the Garden of Eden, or at Sinai, or in connection with the resurrection of Jesus Christ.
Sabbatarianism pertains to the tenets of Sabbatarians. A Sabbatarian, according to Webster, is “one who regards the seventh day of the week holy, agreeably to the letter of the fourth commandment in the decalogue.” By saying, then, that he “cannot go back to the old Sabbatarianism,” Mr. Greer means that he cannot go to observing the seventh-day Sabbath. And why so?—Because, he says, “It is gone.” We should like to know when it “went,” and who commanded it to “go,” and where it went to. The same men who talk about Sabbatarianism being gone, quote the only command there is in all the Bible for observing the Sabbath as a law yet binding, and endeavor to extract from it support for Sunday observance. It appears rather strange that the Sabbath commandment should still be in force, and yet Sabbatarianism be “gone.” If this be so, some surely must be remiss in their duty. But we would inform Mr. Greer that, for all so many are disregarding God’s Sabbath, there are more than “seven thousand men who have not bowed the knee to the image of Baal” by observing the day dedicated to the great sun-god.
But Mr. G. informs us that it is not necessary “to question the origin of Sunday, whether it began in the Garden of Eden, or at Sinai, or in connection with the resurrection of Jesus Christ.” And how did he learn this? Has he been experimenting, and found that in probing this question a bad odor is emitted? Does he mean to say that it is not necessary to know whether an institution is of divine origin or not? If he does not know whether Sunday observance originated in the Garden of Eden, at Sinai, or in connection with the resurrection of Christ, how does he know whether it originated at any of these places or not? The very fact that he seeks to dissuade from any investigation into its origin, creates suspicion of its authenticity. Whether necessary or not, it is well for the Sunday that its origin be not questioned; for he who investigates, will find that it originated neither in Eden, nor at Sinai, nor in connection with the resurrection. In tracing back its ancestry, he will find its pedigree, as another has expressed it, to be as follows: “It had a pagan for a father, a papist for a mother, and has been dandled on the knees of apostate Protestantism.”
The composure and apparent indifference with which Mr. Greer passes over this matter of the origin of the day, reminds us of the manner in which the old Scotchman was accustomed to dispose of hard questions that came up in his Bible class. Whenever a perplexing question arose over some passage of Scripture which he could not well explain, he would say: “Well, brethren, this is a difficult passage, as all commentators are agreed. Let us look the matter boldly in the face, and—pass on.” It is often a great deal easier to “pass on” than it is to stop and explain.
Mr. Greer continues:—
However it began, here it is, and it has been for ages an integral part of our Anglo-Saxon civilization, and the most effectual way to secure its religious observance is by pointing out to the people, with calm and sober statement, what is involved in its secularization, and what they would lose thereby.
Yes, “here it is;” and “however it began,” we are going to do all we can to keep it here! Other things have been here too. The antediluvians were here once, and the tower of Babel, and the city of Babylon. But none of these are here now. Does Mr. G. argue that because a thing is here it is right? Such reasoning is too puerile for children. This would warrant the grossest forms of idolatry that ever cursed the world. Let those who think it matters little what the origin of an institution may be, ponder the words of Christ: “Every plant, which my Heavenly Father hath not planted, shall be rooted up.” Matt. 15:13.
Admitting that Sunday-keeping has been a part of our Anglo-Saxon civilization for ages, is that a good and sufficient reason why it should be a part of our creed? What Adam Clarke has said of opinions, is equally true of religious institutions: “The antiquity of an opinion, if that opinion be not founded on a revelation from God, is no evidence of its truth; for there are many ungodly opinions which are more than a thousand years old.”
With Mr. Greer’s closing statements, it will only be necessary to quote the scripture to show their fallacy. He thus concludes:—
Sunday stands for God, as no other day in the week does. For the great majority of persons therefore, the loss or surrender of Sunday as a religious day would be the loss of God.
With these declarations compare the words of God:—
“The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.” “Verily my Sabbaths ye shall keep: for it is a sign between me and you throughout your generations; that ye may know that I am the Lord that doth sanctify you.” Ex. 20:10; 31:13.
When professed ministers of the church of Christ in this age of light and knowledge will make statements so contrary to Scriptures which they profess to believe, we may well say with the prophet Zephaniah, “Her prophets are light and treacherous persons: her priests have polluted the sanctuary, they have done violence to the law.” Zeph. 3:4. W. A. C.