BY CHAS. P. WHITFORD.
Esteemed Friend: Your kind letter of July 5 is before me, and its contents carefully noted. Your question has been considered, and I shall try to answer it. You ask:—
“Now tell me, if you can, why did, and how could, I enjoy this day’s Christian duties as I did, if I was displeasing my heavenly Father in this [keeping Sunday]? Of course if I was not doing right, I was doing wrong; and ‘God is angry with the wicked every day.’”
In reply I will say, that God does not bless people as an evidence that they are correct in religious theory. If that were true, what class of people could not prove they were right in faith and practice. When God’s Spirit fills our hearts, it comes as a result of the faithful performance of that which we sincerely believe God requires; but we should never for a moment conclude that because we do enjoy the blessing and favor of Heaven, we are therefore in harmony with all God’s requirements. If the early reformers had acted on this principle, where would the Reformation have been? In searching after Bible truth our feelings are no safe criterion to guide us to correct conclusions.
The Bible is the revealed will of God, and was given us that we might know how to properly relate ourselves to its Author. And you certainly cannot consider it unchristian or unkind when we say that any influence, feeling, or spirit that leads contrary to that word is not of God. It is not safe, indeed, it is extremely dangerous, to build a religious faith on a Christian experience. Without an open Bible, we should be in a similar condition to the mariner at sea without sails, chart, compass, or crew, drifting, drifting, we know not where. There is a spirit of error in the world as well as a Spirit of truth. The one emanates from Satan, the other from God, the Author of truth.
Now go with me to John 16:13, where we learn that the “Spirit of truth . . . will guide you into all truth.” You and I both profess to be led by this “Spirit of truth;” but we are led in opposite directions. You have been led to keep for the Sabbath the first day of the week, called Sunday, and I have been led to keep the seventh day, or Saturday. Can it be possible that the “Spirit of truth” would lead you to the observance of one day and me of another? It is plain that both days are not the Sabbath of the Bible. It is equally evident that one of us is in error respecting which day is the Sabbath. And now the question comes home to us with force, How shall we decide which is right and which is wrong? Do you think it would be safe to conclude that because we both profess to enjoy the blessing of God, to feel well, therefore we are both right? Would it not be safer to conclude with the prophet, that “the heart is deceitful above all things,” and that by the spirit of error working through it, it is possible we are being led away from God and Christ and heaven?
Men say, Give us Bible proof and we will believe. But when clear and forcible Bible truth is presented, and the error exposed in open daylight, the stubborn will usurps the place of reason, and says, No, I will not have it so; for it is not as I want it to be. We need not go to the insane asylum to see that the mind deceives itself. We may go to our friend who reasons correctly on mathematics and all ordinary affairs of life, and present proof on proof that “the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord,” and find that on that subject our friend will violate every rule by which he acts in all other things. He allows his Christian experience, his feelings, or his will, and not his reason and the word of God, to decide. Oh! let us remember that we can say no more against the Bible than it can say against us. When we find that our practice is not in harmony with the Bible, let us acknowledge that the Bible speaks the truth against us, however humbling it may be to our pride. No, my friend, it will never do to fall back on our Christian experience or our feelings to justify a course that is in direct and flagrant violation of the plain commands of God. Let us acknowledge the truth and obey it, however humbling it may be; and remember that the Spirit of God and his word are in perfect agreement, and that that word says, with no uncertain sound, to every man in the wide world, “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God; in it thou shalt not do any work.”
There is no disguising the fact that this Sabbath question is fast gaining the lead of all public questions. The great multitudes, constituting governments and nations, are rapidly wheeling into line in support of the claim that Sunday is the Sabbath, and must be so kept under a penalty of law. There are a few, a little company, who, in opposition to this, maintain that “the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord,” and must be so observed. And this question as to which day is the Sabbath, is not left for our decision any more than the question as to who is the true God was left to the decision of the people in the days of Elijah. The Lord himself has decided this question as well as that. What matters it though four hundred and fifty prophets, with the second Jezebel (Rev. 2:20) at their head, should all say that Sunday, the first day, is the Sabbath; until they point to a verse in the word of God that says plainly, The first day is the Sabbath of the Lord,—until then, their word on that subject is no more to be taken as the truth than was the word of the four hundred and fifty prophets of Baal that Baal was the true God. And after the manner of Elijah we say to all, Write these two questions: (1) Is the seventh day the Sabbath? and (2) Is the first day the Sabbath? Then whichever one the word of God in the Bible says is the Sabbath, Let that day be the Sabbath. And if the Bible says that “the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord,” keep it; but if the Bible says the first day is the Sabbath of the Lord, then keep that.
Now, my friend, I have in weakness tried to answer your question, and what I have written I shall have to meet in the Judgment; and you will also have to meet a knowledge of these truths at the same tribunal. “Let us hear the conclusion of the whole matter: Fear God, and keep his commandments; for this is the whole duty of man. For God shall bring every work into judgment, with every secret thing, whether it be good, or whether it be evil.”