AdventAI

THE TRIALS IN TENNESSEE.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 48., December 3, 1889

We are able to give to our readers this week a brief sketch of the trials of Bro. Callicott and Stem, of the Lane, Tenn., church, for working on Sunday. These two brethren had been summoned to appear before the circuit court at Dyersburg, on Nov. 25th, to answer to the charge of having labored on the first day of the week, “to the great disturbance and common nuisance” of the good citizens of their community. Both indictments being the same, it was moved and allowed that the cases be tried together.

By a statute of the code of Tennessee, it is made unlawful for any person to perform or cause to be performed by any one under his control, any secular labor, works of real necessity and charity excepted, on the first day of the week. The penalty for a violation of this statute is a fine of three dollars, paid upon conviction before the magistrate. It is further provided, however, that in case the violation is of such a character as to amount to a nuisance, it becomes an indictable offense, to be tried before the circuit court, and subject to such a fine as the jury may see fit to impose.

The cases were called on the afternoon of Monday, the 25th, and the trial continued until noon of the following day, Judge Flippin presiding. Three witnesses appeared for the prosecution. Their testimony showed that on Sunday, the 23d day of June, the defendants had been seen plowing in a cornfield owned by Bro. Callicott; that the latter, on one Sunday in February of the same year, had been seen in the woods near his place getting out boards; and that one or both had been observed working in the garden on a certain Sunday in May; also that none of this work was outside of their own premises, that it had disturbed and inconvenienced no one, that the season had been so wet as to render such work necessary for the good of their crops, and that both the defendants were citizens of good standing in their community.

Col. T. E. Richardson, of Dyersburg, had been engaged for the defense, and made an impassioned and able speech before the jury; his partner, Mr. Coover, also making a short plea. His manner showed that he grasped the situation, and saw through the hypocrisy of those who had instigated the prosecution. The following short extract will give the reader an idea of the whole.

What is it about this work that is offensive? Why do they call it a nuisance?—It is because, as they say, it is a desecration of the Sabbath, an evil example to the youth, and tends to break down the morals of the community. Then it is the religious aspect of the thing; it is because of the religious question involved, that such acts become offensive; and therefore it is religious legislation under which these men are indicted, and nothing else! It is religious legislation, I say, and as such is directly contrary to the Constitution of the United States, and also of this State. It is contrary to the bill of rights of this State, which defines those rights that are inalienable rights which belong to all, and cannot, on any pretext whatever, be bartered or taken away. I say it is unreasonable, sir, that an act which meets with the approval of all good citizens on six days of the week, can become a nuisance simply because on Sunday some man who neither fears God nor the Devil, looking out over the dim distance of landscape around him, happens to observe it! It is only the narrow spirit of religious intolerance which tries to make it appear so.

Beyond showing the evil character of Sunday laws, and the proper relation of Church and State, the effort of the defense was to show that the Sunday work done by our brethren did not partake of the character of a nuisance, and was therefore not an indictable offense. To this end several extracts were read from the decisions of the Tennessee Supreme Court, showing that any act, even though bad in itself, does not become a nuisance until it operates publicly and notoriously to the disturbance, inconvenience, and annoyance of others. The judge ruled, however, and so charged the jury, that it was only necessary that the act should be sufficiently open and public as to be capable of general observation, and in this ruling he was sustained by the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Bro. Parker, with which our readers are familiar. This decision is a very unfortunate one for us, and constituted the chief basis of the effort made by the prosecution. The main arguments of the latter were, that the law did not interfere in any way with our religious worship, was merely a civil regulation which the State had a right to make, and that were it not enforced, the Sabbath would be lost, anarchy would ensue, the horrors of the French Revolution would be repeated in our midst, etc.

Early in the afternoon of Wednesday, the jury brought in a verdict of guilty for Bro. Callicott, and reported a disagreement in the case of Bro. Stem, the mulish stubbornness of one man alone preventing a verdict of acquittal. They wrestled with the matter until the assembling of court the following morning, and then, being still unable to agree, the judge ordered a new trial for both, stating that their verdict in the case of Bro. Callicott was not warranted by the evidence presented. This will be held at the succeeding term of court, in the latter part of next March.

Thus the matter rests for the present. The result is one which had not been anticipated, and if not a substantial victory for our brethren, it affords them at least a short period of relief at a time when the outlook was very dark and perplexing. They secure this without the sacrifice of their property or their convictions of right and duty.

We would not conclude this sketch without making mention of the friendly attitude and interest of the citizens of Dyersburg during the entire time of our stay there. While our religious views and the purpose of our visit were well understood, one and all greeted us cordially, and we saw no evidence that any one bore our people the slightest ill-will. The trial was conducted with great fairness, and neither on the part of the judge nor prosecuting attorney was there any desire to do our brethren the slightest injustice. Far different is it in other sections of the State, but of that we do not need to make extended mention here. We feel certain that the efforts made in connection with these trials have not been without good results, both to our brethren there and to many of the people around there.

L. A. S.