A CORRESPONDENCE

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 5, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 44.

Read the full edition

A CORRESPONDENCE.

Fourth Letter and Reply.

1616 Freeman Ave., Cincinnati, O., Oct. 1, ’89.
Bro. Colcord: Yours of the 29th ult. came to-day. I do not agree with you that baptism is a memorial of Christ’s resurrection. It is a sign or seal of our union to Christ, our participation in the benefits of his purchase, and our engagement to be his. You say God’s example is the basis of the seventh-day rest and memorial. So the example of his Son is the basis of the Christian Sabbath. Heb. 4:10. I know that does not meet the case according to your mind. But I am persuaded that the passage furnishes a reason for the change of day. You are mistaken in supposing that the change of day involves “a one-eighth or two-eighths proportion.” No such thing. We still hold to the one-seventh. There were two Sabbaths in two successive days, as is intimated in Matt. 28:1. “When the Sabbath was past”—the seventh-day Sabbath—“on the first of Sabbaths;” i. e., the first New Testament Sabbath which came on the first day of the week. We still keep every seventh day. But that seventh day comes on the first day of the week.
You ask why we have any more right to work for a law guarding the first day than you have for a law guarding the seventh day. This is a free country, and no one will interfere with you in advocating the adoption of a seventh-day Sabbath law. I do not think you would make much headway, however. And I am convinced that you would be working contrary to the will of God. I believe that God will bless us in pleading for this, and I know that our land would be blessed in the adoption of a National Sabbath law. You say that such a law oppresses the consciences of the seventh-day-keepers. I do not so regard it. The public good demands the cessation of labor one day in seven. The law says all must quit work that day. That does not hurt anybody’s conscience. It lessens the income of those who keep the seventh day, because they have only five days for work. But that need not touch their consciences. It ought to be a benefit to them to have two days every week for religious duties.
As to “majorities’ ruling,” I believe in majorities in the right, but not in the wrong. I have been with the minority too long to overlook their rights. But my conviction is, that you are wrong in this matter, and the majority who keep the first day are right. As to Reformed Presbyterians denying themselves political privileges, let me say, I hold that it is a sin to vote or hold office under an immoral constitution. If a law were passed compelling me to vote, I should refuse to obey it, and take the consequences, whether fines or imprisonment. But your case is different. The Sabbath law only says you must abstain from work on the first day. You do not think it is a sin to quit work. There is no harm in taking a holiday. If you do think it is a sin to quit work on the first day, then your case is parallel, and you would have to do as I have said I would do. As to “2,000,000 unwilling toilers on Sabbath,” I do not advocate a law in order to make them religious. Nothing but the grace of God can do that. But experience has proved that man’s physical, intellectual, and spiritual welfare demands one day in seven for rest. The government which is intended for the good of the people should secure for them this rest. Beyond this, the law cannot go. I believe in preaching the gospel. I believe in self-denial, etc. But I also believe in the Government’s doing its duty.
Now, my brother, I see we are as far apart as when we began. I frankly admit that I am not open to conviction on the seventh-day matter. I am fully and finally persuaded that it is God’s will and my duty to keep the first day, and not the seventh day, of the week. The proof to my mind is satisfactory. I could wish you were of the same mind. With kindest regards,
Yours fraternally,
J. M. Foster.

THE REPLY.

Battle Creek, Mich., Oct. 3, 1889.
J. M. Foster,
Cincinnati, O.
Dear Sir: Yours of the 1st inst. at hand. I see that you are quite willing that our correspondence should cease. You admit that your arguments, though satisfactory to yourself, are not sufficient to convince me, and that you are not open to conviction on the seventh-day matter. Unlike yourself, I am open to conviction on the first-day question. When you will produce as good evidence in support of your position as I have of mine, I think I shall think very seriously of keeping the first day. I have shown the command of God and uniform teaching and practice of Christ and the apostles in favor of the seventh day, while you have shown nothing of the kind for the first.
But in accordance with my promise, I shall not weary you with a long letter this time, for you have failed to meet my questions and propositions squarely. I will call attention to a few points, and close:—
1. You have claimed that keeping the first day is a memorial of the resurrection. Twice I have called for the Bible proof of this, and twice you have failed to give it. I cited you Rom. 6:3, 4 and Col. 2:12 in proof that baptism is the scriptural memorial of this event. These you have likewise failed to notice. Of baptism, you say, “It is a sign or seal of our union to Christ, our participation in the benefits of his purchase, and our engagement to be his.” This may all be true, though you cite no proof, and still it be a memorial of the resurrection. The Sabbath is a sign between God and his people (Ex. 31:13, 17), and still is a memorial of creation. I showed that in the change of day you rob creation of its memorial. This you leave unnoticed.
2. Twice I have asked wherein there was any more right and justice in your laboring to secure a law to compel me to keep the day you regard, than there would be in my laboring for a law to compel you to observe the day I regard, and wherein either one would be just. Your first answer was, that in a republic the majority rules; but failed in this, your second answer is, that this is a free country; I can do so, but you do not think that I would make much headway. But this in nowise meets the issue. My questions do not concern what may or may not be done in a republic, but what is right and just in the matter. To test your theory upon this basis, you seem loth to do.
3. I also challenged you to harmonize your compulsory Sunday-law theory with the Golden Rule. This you did not attempt to do. I have observed that that rule is not a common one with National Reformers. But until you can do this, I would advise you to call a halt, and ponder awhile.
4. Of Seventh-day Adventists, you say, “It ought to be a benefit to them to have two days every week for religious duties.” That would be two-sevenths of time for rest. To change from the one-seventh order, you have said would “unhinge nature.” So you are willing to unhinge nature with the Adventists. But if two days’ rest a week would be beneficial to them, it would be also to other people; you ought to advocate it. God did not select the best proportion, and nature ought to suggest it. I call such reasoning a mere trick and evasion.
5. A law compelling seventh-day people to keep the first day, you say, would lessen their income, but “need not touch their consciences.” How do you know this, Mr. Foster? Will you let us be the judges of our own consciences? Let me state the case. When the law of God tells us to keep the seventh day, and the law of the land says keep the first, think you the conscientious and God-fearing will have no conscience in the matter?—Indeed they will. And when that time of oppression comes, you will hear from them the words of the apostles found in Acts 4:19 and 5:29. You say no conscience in the matter, keep both days. Try your reasoning on in the case of the three Hebrew captives. Daniel 3. Nebuchadnezzar could likewise have said no conscience in the matter, bow down to both the image and your own God. Their answer will be ours. See verses 16–18. We have conscience in the matter.
6. But you condemn a law compelling you to vote, and say, “I should refuse to obey it, and take the consequences.” Such a law, then, you admit would be wrong, although in harmony with the ideas and practices of the majority. Then you say, “If you do think it is a sin to quit work on the first day, then your case is parallel.” Very well, then, our cases are parallel. I, with 30,000 other Seventh-day Adventists, believe it would be a sin to do so. Now, I want to know what reason you have for not condemning the proposed National Sunday law? The only way you can refuse to do it, is to deny, in the face of our word to the contrary, that we have conscience in the matter; and this you have no more reason to do than we have to deny that you believe it would be a sin for you to vote. Now let us see how much of a respecter of the rights of conscience you are. I tell you, Mr. Foster, if that National Reform Association had the genuine essence of Christian charity in it, it would respect those who, according to your own theory, are already keeping nature’s one-seventh part of time for rest, and would not require them to keep another seventh. But it is a scheme of the enemy of all righteousness to oppress the consciences of the honest and sincere. We know what the whole scheme is aimed at, and where the final blow is to strike. And when the sheep-skin is torn off of it one of these days, you will find it true. You Sunday-keepers cannot meet us in argument on the Sabbath question. People are losing their regard for Sunday, and you your hold on them. But you are bound to have it your way, Bible or no Bible, and have the people keep Sunday even if you have to resort to a civil law to make them do so. But the hardest blow and bitterest hate will come upon those who teach from the Bible, and can prove it from the Bible, that Sunday-keeping is wrong. Don’t you know right down in the bottom of your heart that this is so? You don’t care so much about the laboring man. You want the Sunday law for “worshipers.” Don’t you know it? You have said so. It is that they may “keep the day undisturbed.” These are your words.
7. One more point. You say, “As to ‘majorities’ ruling,’ I believe in majorities in the right, but not in the wrong.” As I have said before, yours is a papal argument, through and through. Compare it with the following: In A. D. 556, Pelagius called Narses to compel certain parties to obey the pope’s command. Narses refused, on the ground that it would be persecution. The pope answered Narses’s objection with this argument:—
Be not alarmed at the idle talk of some crying out against persecution, and reproaching the church, as if she delighted in cruelty, when she punishes evil with wholesome severities, or procures the salvation of souls. He alone persecutes who forces to evil. But to restrain men from doing evil, or to punish those who have done it, is not persecution, or cruelty, but love of mankind.—
Bower’s History of the Popes, Pelagius, A. D. 556.
Everybody that ever persecuted, claimed to be in “the right.” But why have you any more right to say what is right than I have? Right here is where your theory breaks down every time. It is a wicked scheme from beginning to end, and you will wake up to the fact, perhaps, some day.
You say, “I am fully and finally persuaded that it is God’s will and my duty to keep the first and not the seventh day of the week.” Very well, keep it. But why, in the name of Christianity and all that is honorable and fair, do you want to compel others to keep it who are not thus persuaded? My dear sir, such a course is without reason or excuse. And here I leave you.
As ever,
W. A. Colcord.