AdventAI

HARD PRESSED.

By W. A. C.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 44., November 5, 1889

IN a recent correspondence the National Reformer J. M. Foster has been repeatedly urged to give a valid reason why a Sunday-keeper has any more right to ask for a law compelling seventh-day observers to keep Sunday than a seventh-day observer has to petition for a law compelling first-day observers to keep Saturday, and wherein such a law in either case would be just. Under five different dates he gives five different answers, as follows:—

1. In a republic the majority rules. The majority believe in keeping the first day. They have a right to keep that day undisturbed.—Letter dated Sept. 25, ’89.

2. This is a free country, and no one will interfere with you in advocating the adoption of a seventh-day Sabbath law. I do not think you will make much headway, however.—Letter dated Oct. 10, ’89.

3. I see you mean not civil right or right between man and man, but inherent right, or right in God’s sight. I do not believe you have.—Letter dated Oct. 8, ’89.

4. This Government began with a first-day Sabbath law. The Adventists came here understanding that. And there is no ground of complaint because the law continues in force.—Letter dated Oct. 16, ’89.

5. Individually, neither of us has a right to compel the other to keep any day. But it is the will of God that all enjoy rest on the first day. Civil government is his agent to carry out his will in things civil, and as such it must prohibit all common labor on that day.—Letter dated Oct. 31, ’89.

Now, we submit that a man who gives so many different answers to one question must be hard pressed. His first answer implies that the sentiment of the majority in religious things determines what is right and what is wrong, which is certainly a very unscriptural way of deciding such questions. It also implies that minorities have no rights. His second admits that in a free country a seventh-day observer has the privilege of asking for as wicked and oppressive laws as National Reformers ask for, but sneers at the idea of success. In his third, he denies their right “in God’s sight.” In the fourth, he asserts that this Government has always had just what he and his party are clamoring for,—a Sunday law. In his fifth, he finally admits that he has no more rights than the seventh-day observer, but immediately denies it by assuming to dictate what the will of God is. Now will Mr. Foster try again, and state what more right he has to say what the will of God is than have other people? W. A. C.