AdventAI

STRAINING AT A GNAT.

By W. A. Colcord

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 40., October 8, 1889

BY W. A. COLCORD.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

Catholics are ever ready to hurl a stone at Protestants. The Catholic Mirror of Aug. 3, takes occasion to charge the fanaticism caused by two false messiahs in Georgia, as a result of Protestantism. In calling attention to the matter, it says:—

Newspapers relate shocking stories of the insane ravings of two false messiahs who have crazed the ignorant negroes of Georgia by means of blasphemous claims and incendiary harangues. . . . The safety of the whites was threatened. So completely were the poor black wretches under subjection to the craze, that they were induced to offer human sacrifice to appease the wrath of one of the scoundrels claiming to be Christ. The scenes attending this so-called “religious outbreak” are described as shocking in the extreme to civilization and to common decency.

In attempting to give a reason for these occurrences, the Mirror says:—

For two centuries the white population of the South has been almost exclusively Protestant. There never has been any restriction upon religious work among the blacks, even in slavery times. Preachers and laymen were at liberty to preach and teach what they pleased in respect to Christianity, and were free to carry the “open Bible” into every negro hut in the land if they chose.

Then the editor sums the matter up thus:—

What Protestantism really has done for the negro at the South, may be judged from these periodical outbreaks of a “religious fanaticism” that is largely pagan, and wholly superstitious and degrading.

We have no desire to defend either fanaticism or false Christs. But we cannot agree with the conclusion apparently so easily reached by the Mirror, nor see the consistency of Catholics becoming so shocked at the account of such scenes. If the sacrifice of a single human life, or the deliberate leaping of three young men into a furnace, in connection with religious proceedings, is so appalling to them, how is it that they can gulp down the whole bloody history of the Catholic Church, which fairly reeks with carnage, misery, and woe, without a single gag or a wry face? The loss of a few lives in this manner is to them “shocking in the extreme,” and sufficient to condemn all Protestantism; but a St. Bartholomew’s Day, or a Waldensian or Albigensian massacre, in which Catholics deliberately murdered thousands upon thousands of Protestants, is nothing! The Roman Catholic Church is still the “infallible” and “holy” church! Verily, they “strain at a gnat, and swallow a camel.”

If “what Protestantism really has done for the negro at the South may be judged from these periodical outbreaks of ‘religious fanaticism,’” may not what Roman Catholicism has done for the world be judged from the religious persecutions, the inhumanities of the Inquisition, the rack, the thumb-screw, the pillory, the lash, the stake, the gibbet, and the tortures indescribable which disgrace its history? The outbreaks in Georgia are disgraceful, without doubt; but it does not look becoming for Catholicism to set itself up as a critic in condemning them, and ostracizing Protestantism therefor, while it is itself guilty of atrocities a thousand times as heinous. For every life sacrificed in consequence of religious fanaticism in Georgia, Catholicism has sacrificed hundreds of thousands. If a single human sacrifice was here offered to appease the wrath of a false Christ, fifty millions have been offered to appease the wrath of antichrist himself. If preachers and laymen, being “at liberty to preach and teach what they pleased in respect to Christianity,” and “to carry the ‘open Bible’ into every negro hut in the land,” may be charged with the one, the restrictions which the Catholic Church has ever been so eager to place upon such preaching and teaching, and a closed Bible, are equally chargeable with the other. Religious fanaticism is bad enough, we admit; but it does not wear half the frightful mien that grins from the hideous face of persecution.

The stories which newspapers relate concerning the insane ravings of two false messiahs cannotp. 627 be more shocking than the stories which histories relate of the bloodshed under Catholic rule. Under papal authority the safety of the whites has not only been “threatened,” but those murderous threats have been put into execution. The poor black wretches were never more completely under subjection to the craze in the South than have been papal legates and inquisitors to the pope in his wicked design to exterminate those he chose to style “heretics.” The claims of the two false Christ’s cannot be a greater piece of scoundrelism than the blasphemous assumptions of the man of sin, “who opposeth and exalteth himself above all that is called God, or that is worshiped; so that he as God sitteth in the temple of God, showing himself that he is God.” Nor can the periodical outbreaks of religious fanaticism among the negroes be more pagan or superstitious than the continued abominations in the Catholic Church in the form of rosaries, images, mysteries, saint-worship, pagan day of worship, and the numerous senseless mummeries common to that communion.

In criticising the scenes down South, the Catholic Church presents the spectacle of pulling the mote out of a brother’s eye while having a beam in its own. And in condemning them, it sinks itself into the bottomless pit.