Miss Alcott’s book, “The Old-Fashioned Girl,” is an attractive picture of a rich, sweet nature unspoiled by flattery, kept innocent by careful home protection, and growing toward the full development of womanhood without loss of that modesty and delicate feeling which are maidenhood’s greatest charms. The title indicates, however, that there is a “new-fashioned girl” who is other and different from sweet “Polly.” And the story hints that there is more than one young girl whose bloom of maiden modesty is brushed off long before the self-poise of dignity and mature womanhood can be healthfully acquired.
How many of us have seen “new-fashioned” youths of both sexes who make the cheek tingle with shame, and the heart ache with sorrow; youths who had no reverence for age, no respect for conventional proprieties, no deference in manner, no dignity or reserve in speech, no regard for the comfort of elders, and no grace of shy, budding tenderness of feeling such as belongs to protected youth!
The hotel piazzas and parlors are often thronged by such young people as those first described. We see them on the cars, in the public streets, and at all points of contact with life. And they are not only the children of families upon whom poverty has laid the hard necessity of sending out both boys and girls to work in shop and mill. They are quite as often the petted darlings of well-to-do parents who seek to give their children the best “advantages.”
The fact is, the reaction from the old over-repression of youth and individuality has swung many too far, and to the bad and repulsive extreme of over-licensed and aggressive self-assertion. The parent who is conscious that in his or her youth a conformity, a deference, and a self-effacement were required which dwarfed the whole future life, says in his or her loving heart, “My children shall develop freely; they shall not feel stifled in their inmost nature.” And the result is, in many cases, the children do just as they please before they know enough to please themselves wisely or righteously. What has added to the difficulty in the case of many young girls, has been the rapid increase of educational opportunities for women, which has made in many circles of society the daughters better educated in book-learning than the mothers. This, in cases where education has not reached true culture, and the freedom of the family life has been unchecked by generations of fine social restraint, has resulted in making the mothers timid just at the point where, for the daughters’ good, they should be able to command entire respect and allegiance. And the mothers’ timidity, growing out of ignorance of much that the more learned girl recites glibly, “feeds fat” that arrogance of many new-fashioned girls which is the ruin of their true maidenhood.
When a young girl, for instance, assumes to herself the air of hostess in her home when her mother is present; when she tells her mother sharply, as the writer has heard a well-educated girl of sixteen do, that she “wishes to receive her gentlemen callers alone;” she doesn’t “want her young company in the same room with the family,” then if the mother weakly or timidly yields, the social training of the young girl is all on the wrong side.
The only thing which preserves that sweetness of manner which really makes youth attractive, is the constant, loving, elevating influence of older persons. We want all the new-fashioned power and capabilities which freer growth and wider range of training are giving our young women. But we want all the old-fashioned modesty, deference, regard for elders’ comfort, and reverence for superiors, which in past time beautified youth, and protected the delicate feelings until the time of real maturity made a dignified self-assertion proper and safe.
Why do not parents see that going to elaborate “parties,” and to all sorts of public entertainments, often unaccompanied by older persons, spoils childhood, and does not make maturity? Why do not mothers see that velvets and satins and jewels for girls in early teens, means the “orange” of social rivalry “sucked dry” before thirty? Why do not mothers see that all those deep and terrible problems involved in the “social purity” reform are touched by whatever exposes girlhood’s innocence and modest retirement, before self-conscious, mature virtue can be naturally reached? Parents were ordained in the Divine providence, to surround their children with an atmosphere of protection from all which can defile or make impure. Parents were ordained in the Divine providence, not only to keep their children from poison, but to feed them with fruit healthful and sweet, and of their own choosing. And to leave a boy or girl to manage his or her own social affiliations, his or her own companionships, amusements, reading, or manners, is to neglect as plain a duty of guidance as ever was shown to conscience. . . .
The fashion of this changing world altereth for the better in those great movements toward individual freedom and social development which are fast turning women from toys, wards, and drudges into equals of men—self-owners and independent workers. But there is a fashion of courtesy, of gentleness, of mannerly deference, of delicate reserve, of dainty taste, of considerate feeling, which will never become obsolete.
And this fashion is never set—save in a protected, well-bred youth, held true to some fine standard of life inherited from the past. We want, in this sense, the old-fashioned girl always; out of which to make the best and strongest of new-fashioned women.—Anna Garlin Spencer.