BY W. A. BLAKELY.
(Ann Arbor, Mich.)
The sixteenth annual convention of the National Woman’s Christian Temperance Union assembled in Chicago, Nov. 8. The national association was organized at Cleveland, Ohio, in 1874. It has grown to be a very powerful organization, and its influence has been felt in almost every hamlet in the nation. Its power for good can be attested in every State in the Union; and it is with no small degree of pride that the women of America can look upon the work of this organization, and view with pleasure the grand results that they have accomplished in the past score of years.
The writer is heartily in sympathy with the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union in its work, having been connected with the union as an honorary member; and he believes in its good intentions in inserting among its other resolutions, the religio-political declaration, that God’s word should be “made the basis of our laws.” But ofttimes dire results follow good intentions. The Lord himself said, “Yea, the time cometh, that whosoever killeth you will think that he doeth God service.”
So because persons’ intentions are good, it does not necessarily follow that whatever they do is good. We must go to first principles in everything, and see if they will stand on their own merits. I write thus in introduction because I wish it to be understood that it is the principles, and not the union, that I wish to oppose in this article.
The third plank of the platform of the convention reads as follows:—
While discountenancing all union of Church and State, we do affirm our belief that God in Christ is the King of nations, and as such should be acknowledged in our Government, and his word made the basis of our laws.
Now, I should like to ask, What does this resolution mean? What is meant by being opposed to or discountenancing Church and State? Webster’s Unabridged Dictionary defines these two words as follows: “CHURCH—5. The aggregate of religious influences in a community; ecclesiastical influence, authority, etc.; as to array the power of the church against some form of moral evil.” “STATE.—8. A political body, or body politic; the whole body of people united under one government, whatever may be the form of that government.”
If this convention, then, is opposed to “all union,” it must be in favor of a total separation of Church and State. But does it not appear absurd to all that it should be opposed to “all union of Church and State,” and at the same time affirm that “God in Christ is the King of nations, and as such should be acknowledged in our Government, and his word made the basis of our laws”?
To illustrate how extremely absurd this language is, suppose we should substitute other words, and have it read thus: “While discountenancing all union of the papacy and this Government, we do affirm that the pope, through his cardinals, is the ruler of this nation, and as such should be acknowledged in our Government, and his commands and edicts be made the basis of our laws.” Would any one contend that such a move was not a union with the papacy?—Most assuredly not. It would be ridiculous to take such a position. But it is no more ridiculous to take the position that that would not be a union with the papacy, than to take the position that what the resolution wants is not a union with the Church.
On account of the opposition which the American people are known to have to a union of Church and State, every movement asking for a recognition of God or Christ as Ruler in the Government, for his commandments to be enforced by civil law, for the compulsory observance of Sunday, etc., states, “We are opposed to a union of Church and State, but”—
There is one thing that is very evident in the working of the National Reform Association, the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union, the American Sabbath Union, etc., and that is, they all claim to be opposed to a union of Church and State. There is another thing, also, that is evident, and that is, the National Reform Association, the American Sabbath Union, the Roman Catholic Church, the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union, and a large number of the Protestant churches are calling for Sunday laws, and religious recognition which has never been tolerated by our National Government.
Which is right, the American Government, which has stood for a century as the asylum of the oppressed and persecuted, as a home for Jew and Christian, papist and Protestant, white and black, infidel, atheist, and every one of whatever shade of religious and political belief, or these religious associations?
Which is right, the Government that is a synonym throughout the world for liberty, or these various societies that are trying to make this nation legislate upon religious subjects like the countries of the Old World?
Which is right, to preserve the institution that such men as Washington, Jefferson, Madison, and other patriots founded, or to tear them down and supplant them with religious enactments by fallible men in the halls of a nineteenth-century Congress?
Far better it is to preserve the grand old nation as it is, under which the Church has flourished so well for the past hundred years, than to begin legislating upon religious subjects; and it is also far better to be opposed to Church and State in fact than in resolutions.