AdventAI

THE EXPOSURE, NOT SPIRITUALISM, THE FRAUD.

By A. F. Ballenger

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 49., December 10, 1889

One year ago, it will be remembered, occurred the so-called “exposure” of Spiritualism by Mrs. Margaret Fox Kane, one of the famous Fox sisters, who figured so prominently in connection with the Rochester knockings of 1848. Mrs. Kane gave exhibitions to large and enthusiastic audiences in New York and other cities, pretending to explain the rappings by natural causes, as the result of trickery. The papers took it up, and heralded it to the country—“The death blow of Spiritualism;” and others who opposed the position taken by Seventh-day Adventists, that the phenomena were in direct fulfillment of prophecy, were in high glee over the supposed effect upon our doctrines and work which such an exposure would have. Nevertheless, Seventh-day Adventists were not to be dislodged from a position so manifestly scriptural, and there appeared in the REVIEW AND HERALD of Nov. 20, 1888, in the editorial column, an article voicing the sentiments of our people, in which it was clearly shown that modern Spiritualism did not rest on the Fox sisters for a foundation; and further, that the pretended exposure fell far short of explaining spiritual phenomena exhibited by the Fox sisters themselves. In conclusion, the writer made the following remarks, the truthfulness of which has just been verified:—

“So long as the facts alleged remain unrefuted, we shall not be in a hurry to change our opinion on this point, and conclude that we, with so many thousands of others, have been made the victims of a deception in a matter which sustains such a prominent relation to our work; and that a movement so manifestly based on the supernatural, as is modern Spiritualism, had its origin in fraud and humbug.

“Rather would we conclude that the Fox sisters are practicing a fraud at the present time in their alleged exposures.”

In evidence of the correctness of the position then taken, there appears this dispatch to the Cincinnati Inquirer of Nov. 21.

NEW YORK, Nov. 20.—Maggie Fox, one of the two celebrated Fox sisters who originated Spiritualism, and who last year went about the country exposing Spiritualism, saying it was a fraud, and describing how the tricks were accomplished, now recants, and charges churchmen with having bribed her.

A. F. BALLENGER.