AdventAI

A CALL FOR CHARITY.

By W. A. Colcord

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 45., November 12, 1889

BY W. A. COLCORD.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

A few weeks ago a Western newspaper printed the “Questions for Sunday-keepers” which appeared in the REVIEW of Aug. 13. These, it seems, had a tendency to irritate some of the Sunday-keepers in that locality, a Methodist minister signing himself Rev. J. C. Caughlan, coming out in the next issue of the same newspaper, with the pitiful plea of a lack of charity on the part of seventh-day observers in asking Sunday-keepers such questions. In the course of the article he says:—

Worshiping on the first day as we do, we will not be so unkind and uncharitable as to ask a seventh-day brother to break the commandment, as he views it, and work on his Sunday. We would like to see the same display of charity. Give us fresh questions that have not been answered until we are tired.

There are several anomalies here. From this we are left to conclude that it is uncharitable to call for Scripture proof for first-day observance, for that is the substance of the questions. We had never before regarded charity in that light. We had never supposed the mantle of charity to be so broad that upon points of difference in religious belief and practice, it would not allow an appeal “to the law and to the testimony.” We wonder if it would be uncharitable to call for Scripture proof on other points of doctrine! When Luther was brought before the Diet of Worms, and asked if he would retract what he had written in his books, he said, “I implore you by the mercies of God to prove to me by the writings of the prophets and apostles that I am in error.” Was this uncharitable in Luther? There is a way, the apostle informs us, by which we may be the means of hiding a multitude of sins. It is not, however, by a charity so broad as to knowingly and willingly allow a brother to go on in sin. The promise is to him who “converteth the sinner from the error of his way.” James 5:20.

The questions called for Scripture proof for Sunday-keeping. To have made a perfect comparison, we would have supposed that in making a claim to superior charity, the writer would say that worshipers on the first day would not be so uncharitable as to ask a seventh-day brother for Bible proof for seventh-day observance. But, no; he knew they could give that, so he puts it, “to break the commandment as he views it.” From this we understand that in calling for Scripture proof for first-day observance, we have virtually asked Sunday-keepers to break the commandment “as they view it.” This puts them in a queer light, we confess. From this we are left to conclude that when they read in the commandment, “The seventh day is the Sabbath,” they understand it to mean the first day! Seventh-day observers never ask Sunday-keepers to break the fourth commandment, but they do ask how they can “view it” as they do.

Mr. Caughlan asserts that Sunday-keepers do not ask seventh-day observers to break the commandment as they view it, and counts them more charitable therefore. This is quite easily accounted for. They could not consistently do so, for they are forced to admit that the seventh-day observer’s view of the commandment is right. He keeps the seventh day, and that is the day the commandment enjoins. If, however, there is Bible evidence showing that he is wrong, and Sunday-keepers know of it, they are very uncharitable not to enlighten him and ask him to change his views and practice.

But let us turn the charity table around once. Seventh-day observers have never been so unkind as to ask Congress to pass a law, contrary to the first article of amendments to the Constitution, compelling everybody, irrespective of religious or conscientious convictions, to keep the seventh day. But the great Methodist Church, together with other Sunday-keeping bodies, through the American Sabbath Union and the Sunday-law petitions, have asked Congress to do this respecting the first day. Now, we should like to know who is the more charitable. Seventh-day observers, upon Bible authority, appeal to Sunday-keepers to change their practice in accordance with the Bible. And they are uncharitable! But Sunday-keepers, without Bible authority, ask for a law to compel seventh-day observers to keep a day which is not only contrary to the commandment “as they view it,” but contrary to the Bible itself. And yet they are charitable!!

Mr. C. asks for “fresh questions.” When questions upon religious matters must be so fresh as not to savor of an appeal to the Scriptures, they are altogether too modern for us. Such might suit those who have ceased to “preach the word,” and are turning the ears of the people away from the truth unto fables. 2 Tim. 4:1–4.

The reverend gentleman wishes questions that have not been answered by Sunday-keepers until they are tired. From this we would understand that our questions have been answered; in other words, that Sunday-keepers have given us a text which commands us to observe the first day of the week as a day of rest and worship, another in which it is called a sacred day, another showing that secular work was ever regularly suspended on that day, another defining the penalty for its desecration or non-observance, etc., etc. If any Sunday-keeper has ever produced these texts, we have failed to hear of him. Our experience in this matter has been that Sunday-keepers have always become tired just before they got around to give the texts.

Mr. C. attempts to blockade further discussion on the subject thus:—

The Pharisees who approached the Lord with the Sabbath question were severely rebuked.

Very truly; but rebuked for what? For keeping the Sabbath?—No. Because they were keeping the wrong day?—No. They were rebuked for forbidding things being done which were lawful to do; for binding upon the people heavy burdens and grievous to be borne; for making void the commandments of God by their traditions; and for teaching for doctrines the commandments of men, as those who are teaching Sunday-keeping are now doing. It is a strange idea, indeed, to suppose that the Saviour’s rebuke was a reflection on the Sabbath.