IS IT CHURCH AND STATE?
By W. A. C.
Speaking in Washington, D. C., Sunday, Dec. 8, Mrs. Bateham, the Superintendent of the Sabbath Observance Department of the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union, said:— Last Congress we had 10,000,000 names to our petition; now we have many more. There are several strong organizations besides ours, and a popular sentiment in favor of this law is already created. We have passed the midnight line, and morning will soon dawn. We failed to get our bill, but to-morrow morning Mr. Blair will present a new bill. We are not discouraged. I am here to work in the interest of this bill, and it must succeed or our country is lost, and you will all be lost forever. If you do not keep away from saloons and keep the Sabbath, you will never go to heaven. We presume not. But there are several other things which, if people do not do, they will never go to heaven, and for which as yet there has been no bill presented to Congress. To repent, be baptized, and believe on the Lord Jesus Christ are some of the essentials to salvation. In Mark 16: 16, we have the positive declaration that “he that believeth not shall be damned.” Now, why not have Mr. Blair present a bill for some of these things, if the object in presenting the Sunday bill is to get people to “go to heaven”? Of this bill Mrs. Bateham says, “It must succeed or our country is lost, and you will all be lost forever.” We never supposed so much hung upon the passage of a bill by Congress,—the eternal destinies of 60,000,000 people. Surely legislation is a matter that may well be looked after if this be true. But cannot people stay away from the saloon and keep the Sabbath without a Sunday law? We think it has been done. But to present this matter upon the ground that it is to make people religious, and to legislate them into heaven, would look altogether too much like religious legislation. Of this Mrs. Bateham appears to be conscious, so she added:— We don’t want any union of Church and State. We don’t ask any law to enforce the Christian feature of the Sabbath, but the civil rest must be enforced. But this takes the pith out of all she had said before. The Sunday bill must pass or all will be lost forever. But will all be saved if they disregard the “Christian feature” of the day, and observe simply the “civil rest”? If not, but the object of the bill is to save them, then, though it pass, and become a law, it will fail to accomplish its object even for those who strictly obey it. To enforce the Christian feature of the day, by which is meant its religious observance, Mrs. Bateham virtually admits would be a union of Church and State. But this is just what must be enforced, if the law accomplishes the design of its promoters; for Mrs. B. continued:— We want the religious observance, and God wants it. He says so in “Remember the Sabbath to keep it holy.” Now, can any one doubt that the object of these people in this proposed legislation is a religious object, and that the observance of Sunday they are after is its religious observance? Then what is the legislation looking toward these objects but religious legislation? and what is that, according to Mrs. Bateham’s own tacit admission, but a union of Church and State? They do not want a union of Church and State, and yet they want legislation that will accomplish everything that a union of Church and State would accomplish. We would suggest that the only way they can extricate themselves from this dilemma, is to let religious legislation alone. Sunday legislation is religious legislation, and only such, all the denials and sophistical arguments to the contrary notwithstanding. And the inner and ultimate intent of such legislation is religious, however much its promoters may talk of “civil” observance and the “physical” needs of the laboring man. Through the Sunday institution the Church is grasping for power. The pathetic plea for the poor laboring man may be made to create “popular sentiment,” and the claim that it is only the “civil rest” that is intended, set up to allay the fears of others; yet it is power they crave,—an insatiable greed for power. The two horns of Church and State peer up perceptibly through all this clamoring on the part of the Church for a Sunday law. Though the fair hand of Eve present the forbidden fruit, to every thinking man in the country we would say, “Be not deceived.”