AUTHORSHIP, like every other vocation, has its share of difficulties and disappointments. In this, as in other lines of work, every success is accompanied by a large body-guard of failures. The kernels of wheat, as compared with the stalks and leaves and chaff, are sometimes in discouragingly small proportions. But none should be disheartened over occasional failures. They work to a good purpose. They subserve a valuable end. They give the faculties of mind needed exercise, which helps in its general development. They are a part of the discipline necessary to future efficiency. And any one who imagines he can strike twelve the first time, and that his every effort will be perfection, and who is not prepared for occasional criticisms, rebuffs, rejections, and disappointments, and who cannot take these experiences with equanimity, with entire composure and good feeling, would do better not to attempt to enter very largely into literary labor.
The correspondents of the REVIEW, we are happy to say, are generally the consistent and understanding kind, who accord all liberty to reject, condense, amend, or dispose of their communications in any other way which may seem best to those to whose lot it falls to pass judgment on them. But there is occasionally one who, if any change is made in his communication, suffers not many mails to run to waste before sending back some such instruction as this: “I would thank you to print my articles exactly as I write them. If you cannot publish them just as I prepare them, you need not print them at all. I send them in just such shape as I want them.” Every one of course has a right to stamp his article “immaculate,” and to send it on with an air of infallibility. But seeing it is to go forth to a world of differing tastes and differing judgments, it would seem like presuming a little too much to suppose that every one would regard it in the same light. No paper can be run in the interest of any one writer, but in the interest of all, according to the best judgment of those who have it in charge. It is not the province of any publisher to change the sentiment of any communication without the author’s consent, but the articles are few which do not demand, here and there, a touch of improvement in their constructional make-up. But when an article is received which demands considerable editing to make it readable, if the restrictions named above are laid upon us in regard to it, but one result follows; and that is, that the article is started on its way to the waste-basket, by the air-line route, on a limited ticket, with no stop-overs.
In the Journalist of Feb. 1, 1890, we find some remarks on this subject which set forth so clearly the established custom touching the relation between correspondents and publishers,—a custom to which no reasonable correspondent will object, and which no conscientious editor will abuse,—that we lay it before our readers. All will be interested in it; for who is there who has not written, or who does not expect sometime to write, for the paper? We quote as follows:—
BLUE PENCIL RULES.
There is no man in a newspaper office whose work is more irksome or less appreciated than the “Blue Pencil Fiend” or “Copy Chopper,” as he is variously and not affectionately called. It is his unpleasant duty to go through the work of his fellows with a judicious yet merciless hand, to prune, amend, and alter it so that it may exactly fit the requirement and space of the paper. In doing this, many a carefully written sentence must be sacrificed, many an elaborately worded statement boiled down, and many an inch of space chopped from the string of the writer.
It is hardly within the possibilities for the “Copy Chopper” to be a popular man and at the same time do his duty. Every correction or emendation he may make is a silent, but none the less effective suggestion that the writer has not performed his work satisfactorily; every line that he cuts out is a direct reduction of the earnings of the space worker. He may be one of the most genial and lovable fellows alive, but the reporter whose story has been slaughtered from half a column to a stickful can hardly be expected to regard him with entire approval. It is a direct blow to a man’s vanity to have his flowery flights of fancy shorn from an article, and the whole reduced to bald facts. The sufferer is very apt to conclude that the “Copy Chopper” does not know a good thing when he sees it, or that he is actuated by a fiendish desire to injure him. From a writer’s standpoint, it is almost invariably the case that the “Copy Chopper” spoils a story when he alters it.
On the other hand, it becomes perfectly apparent to the “Copy Chopper,” after some experience in his work, that not one newspaper worker in ten knows how to write. In his leisure moments he composes little peans in praise of the men who know how to state facts plainly, intelligently, and intelligibly, and in the midst of his work he breathes a sigh of relief when the work of a practiced and practical writer comes to his desk, and a silent but fervent blessing upon the man whose copy needs no revision floats through the midnight air.