AdventAI

THE HEARING ON THE SUNDAY-REST BILL.

By J. O. Corliss

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 8., February 25, 1890

SINCE our last report we have had a very interesting time in Washington. In view of the fact that the Breckinridge bill would soon come up for consideration in the House, we sent to New York, and had an article on the Breckinridge bill which had previously appeared in the Sentinel, struck off in leaflet form, and mailed one of these to each member of Congress. We then went to Senator Stockbridge, and asked him to present a resolution to the Senate, re-referring the petitions which were presented last winter to the Senate, so that they would count in the present Congress. This he promised to do. We next saw Mr. O’Donnell of the House, who promised to do the same for the old petitions presented to that body.

Having secured this much, we then visited the committee who have in charge the Breckinridge bill, to learn when we could be granted a hearing before them, in opposition to that measure. After some consideration, Tuesday, February 18, at 10 o’clock A. M., was the time set for the hearing, and one hour was accorded to the consideration of each side of the question.

At the time appointed the room was completely filled with people who were anxious to hear what could be said for and against the measure. Rev. Geo. Elliott, of “Abiding Sabbath” fame, led out in favor of the bill. With such a famous champion, we did expect to hear a tolerably good speech, but were doomed to disappointment. He made a few assertions, such as, Sunday laws are constitutional, and, The Constitution already has a Sunday law in it; referring to the two words in parenthesis in the Constitution, “Sundays excepted,” in the time allowed the President to keep a bill in his possession without his signature. From this he argued that everybody in the United States, especially the people of the District of Columbia, were entitled to a Sunday law for their protection.

He was followed by a Mr. Shulteis, who represented a local assembly of the Knights of Labor. In a very few words he stated that the Knights of Labor were all in favor of the bill. Mrs. Catlin, who has charge of the Sunday department of the W. C. T. U. for the District, then read a short paper, the gist of which was that the President and the Commissioners of the District desired that the bill should pass. She then created quite a sensation by saying that the night before she had taken 27,000 signatures in favor of this bill from her safe, to have them in readiness to bring to the hearing that morning, but that when she went for them, she found they had been stolen during the night. A peculiar impression seemed to prevail at this statement, and various pairs of eyes were turned intently toward the faces of those who were designated as “the opposition.” The chairman of the committee, seeing the situation, and apparently not willing that it should remain as it was, cross-questioned the lady until she stated that she did not think the thief was one who was opposed to the measure, but that some one had taken the bundles, expecting thereby to get some booty. This, of course, changed the complexion of matters very much, for which we silently thanked the Lord.

The next speaker in order was Mr. Crafts, of “American Sabbath Union” reputation. We were somewhat prepared for his performance before the committee, from the speeches he had made the Sunday previous in different pulpits in the city. In these, fully one-half of his time was taken in a tirade upon Seventh-day Adventists and their methods of labor, more especially upon those who had led out in the work of opposition here in Washington. His words appeared steeped in gall, while denouncing them as a deceptive and dangerous people. His speech before the committee was little else than a re-hash of his Sunday tirade, but it seemed to have an opposite effect to that which he intended.

Being obliged to follow Mr. Crafts, I told the committee that I had no time to waste in personalities, further than to express my appreciation of the last speaker’s confession that he had no argument in favor of the bill, which I deemed his only excuse for his bitter personal attack. Recriminations we thought out of place under such circumstances, and that, further, we had arguments to present, with which we wished to fill the time allotted to us. But before entering upon the line of thought chosen, a petition opposing the bill was exhibited, with the signatures of 7,649 citizens of the District appended. So far as the charge was concerned, that we wished to have Saturday incorporated into law as the Sabbath, we told them that it made no difference what day was demanded by the bill, we should oppose it just as strongly as the present one. It was the principle underlying the measure which we opposed, more than the day. We then proceeded to show that the bill was nothing but a religious measure, and therefore was unconstitutional.

We took the position that it is not the day on which an act is performed that makes it uncivil, but it is the act itself which is uncivil, if it is thus adjudged. Then if the act of laboring is uncivil, honest toil becomes a crime. In that case, if the law permits that labor on all days but Sunday, then it legalizes crime on all days but that one. If it is said that labor is no crime only as done on Sunday, and to the disturbance of other people’s rest, then simple mental disturbance is made a crime, and on this ground the law may prohibit the preaching of religious opinions which are not in harmony with the majority, simply because their minds are disturbed thereby. A third count made was, that if the bill was entirely civil, why should it exempt persons from its penalty simply on the ground of religious belief? It is just as wrong for a religious person to be uncivil toward his neighbors as for one who makes no profession of religion. Laws against polygamy are enforced just as strongly upon those whose religious belief allows them to have a plurality of wives, as upon those who have no religious belief in the matter. This shows that a purely civil law cannot make exemptions for those who violate it, because of certain religious beliefs they may hold.

As my time for speaking closed, the chairmanp. 125 of the committee handed a note across the table to me, which was a request from a Knight of Labor to have three minutes of time. Of course the time was given him. He proved to be Millard F. Hobbs, master-workman of the District assembly, and said that, being in a position to know, he affirmed that no one had been authorized to speak before that committee in favor of a Sunday law. Further, he said that the Knights of Labor, while desirous of Sunday rest from toil, were not in favor of such a bill, on account of its religious features. When they made a move in the direction of Sunday rest, the body which he represented would get what they desired through their organization, and not by asking Congress to give it to them.

This little speech made another short sensation, and Mr. Crafts came forward to the rescue of his patron Knight, who had spoken in favor of the bill, by saying he was duly authorized to speak in behalf of the measure. The master-workman replied that everybody knew his (the master’s) position and authority, and that he always had authority to speak for his order, and was responsible directly to them, and was, moreover, in a position to know that Mr. Shulteis had no authority whatever from that body to speak in favor of a measure which his order had voted against after listening to Mr. Crafts’s appeal for a half hour in its behalf. This seemed to effectually settle the question, and the vanquished party appeared quite crestfallen.

It seemed providential that this man came in and asked the privilege to speak as he did; for he completely refuted the oft-repeated statement of Mr. Crafts, that the Knights of Labor were almost unanimous in favor of the bill. It was quite an eye-opener, too, to those present, as to who were practicing duplicity in the matter of representing the number of their adherents.

Eld. A. T. Jones followed, as the next speaker, and in an argument against the bill read from Mr. Crafts’s book, “The Sabbath for Man,” citing instances of many who had been promoted for refusing to labor on Sunday, even though they were urged to the opposite course, and that not a single instance had ever been reported where a person had lost anything financially by refusing to work on Sunday. This was good evidence that no one was now being forced to labor on Sunday, as would be inferred from the title of the bill under consideration. He showed the inconsistency of the promoters of this bill, in exempting from the penalties it provides only those people who they affirm are the strongest opponents of the measure in the country. This showed that the exemption was not to specially favor that people, but was simply a sop thrown to them to induce them to stop their opposition, which meant that they should no longer, by the circulation of publications or by public preaching, hold up that Saturday was the Sabbath, and that Sunday was not. The balance of his time was consumed in presenting a constitutional argument against Sunday laws in general, which seemed to give much satisfaction to the members of the committee present. Bro. McKee then presented a brief, setting forth legal points utterly condemnatory of Sunday laws.

When the hearing was closed, there were not many gleams of satisfaction to be seen on the faces of those who had spoken in favor of the bill, or upon the faces of their friends. The last one of them soon moved out of the room. We, however, were detained considerable time, receiving the congratulations of members of the committee and others, upon the strength of our position. One member, especially, said he had examined this subject quite thoroughly, and he was satisfied that the promoters of the bill had no ground upon which to stand. The daily papers had representatives present, who gave very fair reports of the speeches made. On the whole, we feel to thank God for the measure of success which attended the effort to enlighten men in high places on this subject. We believe that this hearing will have a good effect upon even those who were not present, as we hear of much favorable comment upon the subject.

Of course, we cannot tell what influence or pressure may yet be brought to bear upon the committee before they report the bill to the House; but we now have good reason to hope that the bill will be reported adversely. If this is done, we look for its promoters to bring greater force to bear in order to carry the Blair bill through, which has been permitted to lie quiet to await the fate of this one in the House. They have gone too far now to retreat, and if they are foiled in their present efforts, it is quite evident that they will hold the Seventh-day Adventists responsible for their failure, and will, consequently, heap upon them more vile epithets than ever. We hope that our people everywhere will so seek God that in the thickening conflict they may find needed grace to stand in the place where God would have them. J. O. CORLISS.