A correspondent writes: Please explain 1 Cor. 15:29. The text reads: “Else what shall they do, which are baptized for the dead, if the dead rise not at all? why are they then baptized for the dead?”
The word “else,” which introduces this verse, shows the close connection of the passage with what precedes; and its definition, “for else,” (or, if this is not so,) shows that Paul is asking a question based on a proposition the opposite of that which he has just stated.
In verse 23 he states that those who are Christ’s will be made alive, or be raised from the dead, at his coming. Then down to the 29th verse are thrown in some explanatory verses, showing the great transaction which takes place at the end, and the prophecy upon which that hope is based. So the connection is really between verse 23 and verse 29; and if we read these in connection, it will bring out more clearly the idea of verse 29.
Beginning with verse 22, we read: “For as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive. [23.] But every man in his own order: Christ the first-fruits; afterward they that are Christ’s at his coming. [29.] Else [or, if this is not so] what shall they do which are baptized for the dead, if the dead rise not at all? why are they then baptized for the dead?”
Thus we have the ideas which were in the mind of the apostle, more immediately connected. The dead are to be raised when Christ comes, if this isn’t so, if there is no resurrection of the dead, then what shall they do which are baptized for the dead? or, of what account is it that any one is baptized for the dead? and why is any one baptized for the dead?
Paul here asserts that if any one did not believe in the resurrection of the dead, he would not be baptized for the dead. All hinges, therefore, on the resurrection; but what connection has baptism with the resurrection?—Rom. 6:4, 5: “Therefore we are buried with him [Christ] by baptism into death; that like as Christ was raised up from the dead by the glory of the Father, even so we also [being raised up from the watery grave] should walk in newness of life. For if we have been planted together in the likeness of his death, we shall be also [finally raised up] in the likeness of his resurrection.”
When, therefore, a person is baptized, he shows his faith, first, that Christ was buried and rose again; and, secondly, that all the righteous dead will be raised in him. But if there is to be no resurrection of the dead, why should any one be baptized to show his faith that Christ was raised from the dead, or to express his hope that any others will ever be raised from the dead?
The expression, then, “baptized for the dead,” as used by Paul in 1 Cor. 15:29, we understand to mean, ordinary baptism performed in the belief that Christ was raised from the dead, and in the hope that he (the candidate) will, through Christ’s resurrection, be himself also at last raised from the dead. So we could read the text, “Else what shall they do [what shall it profit them] which are baptized on account of, and in hope of, the resurrection of the dead?”
The Mormon idea that this text teaches that one may be baptized in behalf of one that is dead, his baptism being put to the account of the dead one, so that such dead person is considered just the same as if he had been baptized while living, is shown to be a gross perversion by the fact that Paul’s language, so far as the act of baptism is concerned, applies wholly to the living, not to the dead. He does not say, What shall the dead ones do in whose behalf others are baptized? but, What shall they do who are baptized? The question is what they shall do, or what good it will do them, who undergo baptism with reference to this idea of the resurrection of the dead, if the dead rise not. For by this act they would identify themselves with the followers of Christ, and subject themselves to all the dangers and perils, of which Paul proceeds to speak in the verses immediately following: “And why stand we in jeopardy [danger] every hour?” It would all be in vain, if there is no resurrection; but with the certainty of that glorious event before them, they could joyfully subject themselves to all the dangers of the way, even though it might be, as in the case of Paul, to “die [or be exposed to death] daily.” Verse 31.