As a representative of the National Religious Liberty Association, the writer attended the March term of the circuit court at Troy, Tennessee, to witness the trial of Bro. R. M. King, indicted for working on Sunday. The indictment against Bro. King read as follows:—
INDICTMENT vs. R. M. KING.
State of Tennessee. Obion County. July term A. D. 1889.
The Grand Jurors of the State of Tennessee, elected, empaneled, sworn and charged to inquire in and for the body of the County of Obion in the State aforesaid, upon their oath present that R. M. King, late of said county, laborer, heretofore, to wit: on the 23d day of June, A. D. 1889, and on divers other Sundays before and after that date, and up to the taking of this requisition in the County of Obion aforesaid, then and there did unlawfully and unnecessarily engage in his secular business, and performed his common avocation of life, to wit: plowing on Sunday, and did various other kinds of work on that day and on Sundays before that day, without regard to said Sabbath days. Said work was not necessary, nor done as a matter of charity; and the doing of said work on said day was and is a disturbance to the community in which done, was offensive to the moral sense of the public, and was and is a common nuisance. So the Grand Jurors aforesaid present and say that said R. M. King was in manner and form aforesaid guilty of a public nuisance, by such work on Sunday in a public place, prejudicial to public morals, contrary to the statute, and against the peace and dignity of the State.
J. R. BOND, Att’y-Gen’l.
Five witnesses were called for the State, and one for the defense. The first witness examined was J. L. Cole, who was also the prosecutor in the case. He testified that he had seen Mr. King plowing in his field on Sunday on one occasion. There was a public neighborhood road on two sides of the field in which the plowing was done, but the field was not in sight of any place of public worship. He did not see the defendant plowing for more than five minutes. On cross-examination the following questions were put to the witness by Col. Richardson, the defendant’s counsel, and drew from the witness the answers as given:—
Col. Richardson.—Did you see the defendant, Mr. King, working on Sunday?
Mr. Cole.—Yes, sir, I saw him plowing in his field on Sunday, the 23d day of June last.
Col. R.—Did it disturb you in any way?
Mr. C.—Yes, sir, of course it did; it was very annoying to my feelings.
Col. R.—On what grounds?
Mr. C.—On the ground that it was a violation of laws both sacred and civil.
Col. R.—Then it was an excitement of your religious feelings, and repulsive to your views of Christianity?
Mr. C.—Yes, sir.
Col. R.—How long have you known Mr. King?
Mr. C.—For about twenty or twenty-five years.
Col. R.—What was the general character of the defendant as a peaceable, quiet, law-abiding citizen, up to the time of this indictment?
Mr. C.—It was good.
Col. R.—Is he a pious, Christian gentleman?
To this question the Prosecuting Attorney, J. R. Bond, objected, and his objection was sustained by Judge Swiggart on the ground that it was irrelevant. Whereupon Col. Richardson made the following plea:—
Your Honor, I think it is relevant, and I submit to your Honor that I propose to prove that he is a member of a church which holds that Saturday, the seventh day, is the Sabbath, and that he observes it. I think I have a right to do this for two purposes: First, I think I have a right to do it to show that he did not intentionally violate the law; Second, I think I have a right to do it, to show the intent and purpose for which he did it, as a matter of mitigation. If this action can be sustained at all, and if this jury can find any verdict at all, it is within the discretion and power of the jury to impose any fine above fifty dollars that they may see proper. And I think that as a matter of mitigation I have a right to show to the jury that this man belongs to a church that professes certain tenets of religious faith, among which is that the seventh day is the Sabbath; and that he observed that day as the Sabbath. I think I have a right to prove this:—not, I grant you, as a defense to the action or as a decision of it, but in mitigation of any fine.
The Court.—I do not think his religious belief or religious connection with any church or sect, has anything to do with this lawsuit, and sustain all objections tending to prove anything of that sort.
Col. R.—And your Honor declines to allow me to prove it even as a matter of mitigation?
The Court.—Yes, sir.
Col. R. (To the witness)—Are you prejudiced against the defendant because of his religious views?
Mr. C.—I can say this, that I do not favor his religious views.
Here the Court objected to any further questions on this point from the defense.
Further examination drew from this witness and the one who followed, the fact that the witnesses and certain others had bound themselves by a written pledge, or agreement, to prosecute every violation of the Sunday law. The defendant offered to prove that others who made no pretensions to observe any other day than Sunday, cut wheat with a self-binder, rafted logs, and did other work on Sunday, and that no attempt had been made to prosecute them; but the Court would not allow him to do so.
The cross-examination showed that the third witness, Alexander Wright, was going down to his field to examine his crops the first time he saw Mr. King at work; and on another occasion he and the fourth witness, Wm. Oaks, were on their way to another part of the neighborhood after a cow. The fifth witness was looking up harvest hands when he saw the defendant at work on Sunday.
The defendant also offered to prove that he had been tried before a justice of the peace, and fined for the identical work which was made the principal offense in the indictment, viz., plowing corn on Sunday, the 23d day of June last, and that he had paid his fine and the costs, and introduced for the purpose, the Justice before whom he was tried; but the Court would not permit him to prove these facts.
The speech of the Prosecuting Attorney was a tirade against the religious sect of which the defendant was a member, and a reflection upon Northern men, all of which was well calculated to arouse the prejudices of the jury. It was so saturated with blackguardism that it cannot be repeated. The main effort of the speaker was to confound the defendant and those of his religious faith, with the Mormons, and he even charged them with offering human sacrifices. I will give a few extracts from the speech, which are very much modified; for no respectable pen could write the words as spoken, and no respectable ear would want to hear them.
There were a lot of fellows in the olden time,—some Adventists, or Seventh-day Advents, or Mormons, or May-flower fellows, I do not care which you call them,—who believed in human sacrifices, carrying them to the altar, and burning them up as an incense. Suppose they should come from the same section of that country, Col. Richardson would say, You have no right to interfere with the rights of conscience of this people. And you can’t interfere with them, because the Bill of Rights says that every man in this country has a right to worship God according to the dictates of his conscience. Burn children, practice polygamy, and everything else of that sort? No, sir; away with all such foolishness and everything of that sort! I do not care anything about the Adventists, or Mormons, whether they are right or not. But when they come here, they must walk up to the rack, and eat the same fodder that our folks eat. Not satisfied with worshiping God; oh, no; but with your short-hand reporters, your Mormons, and your Adventists, you want to corrupt not only the whole morals of the country, but you want to control the courts of the country. I wish to God we had more Methodist churches, and more Baptist churches, and more Presbyterian churches, and more Episcopal churches, and more Catholic churches, until every man was brought under the benign influences of these churches; but, in the name of God, I do not want any of these Adventistp. 173 churches, or Mormon churches. Guiteau, when he had a revelation from God (and I expect he had a Seventh-day Adventist lawyer to defend him), took a pistol and shot down the ruler of this nation, and they hung him; and that is what they ought to do with all these fellows. I have no respect for men like that. These fellows never heard from God, and I think never will. They are not satisfied with working on Sunday and practicing polygamy themselves, but they come down here and want to save us, and have us practice polygamy.
The obscene and filthy utterances of the attorney, which we have not quoted, evoked considerable merriment among the visitors of the court room, the jury, and especially among the leading witnesses for the prosecution, who were devout church members.
The jury were out only about half an hour, when they returned a verdict of guilty, and assessed the fine at seventy-five dollars. The counsel for the defendant took exception to the charge given to the jury, and moved a new trial. In refusing to grant a new trial, the judge said:—
The law is clear. I charged it properly. The fine is a reasonable one, and one well warranted. The laws are made to be obeyed, and Mr. King and all other men should and must obey them, or leave the country. I make these remarks that they may know that I intend to have the laws strictly enforced in the future. Mr. King and his brethren have a right to keep another day if they choose, but as Christian men, it is their duty to obey the laws of the State, and they must do it.
An appeal was taken to the Supreme Court of the State, and will probably be heard at the April term. The results of this case prove more clearly than ever the danger of removing a single provision that our fathers wisely put in the Constitution to protect the rights of conscience, and to secure to all perfect Religious Liberty. And it is not enough to have these safeguards in the Constitution. The statute-books, also, must be kept clear of laws touching matters that are purely religious. The Bill of Rights of Tennessee is clear and strong as to the rights of conscience; but the statutes are enforced regardless of the Bill of Rights. In matters of so much importance we cannot trust to the good will and indulgence of our fellow-citizens. The rights of every citizen in matters of conscience should be recognized fully and distinctly in all constitutions and statute-books, both State and national. Nor can any creed or sect be safe when it is otherwise. It matters not how numerous or well protected they may be at the present time; let the precedent once be established of coercing the conscience under the sanction and protection of law, and none can tell what the end will be. In the case above referred to, the witnesses testified that their moral and religious senses and their sense of propriety were shocked. Another citizen of Tennessee, in talking with the writer, said that it would shock his moral sense and sense of propriety more to see persons led down into the water and immersed than to see a man quietly plowing in his field on Sunday. Who can say, if the laws would permit it, that there would not be men whose religious senses would be shocked by immersion, by communion in both kinds, or by the opposite of these, till their pent-up religious enthusiasm would seek a vent in prosecutions and persecutions? The only tenable ground for a remedy against the evils of religious legislation, is to keep the State and the Church forever separate. DAN. T. JONES.