BY ELD. W. C. GAGE.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
Under the above heading, Bishop Thoburn makes a vigorous, not to say virulent attack on the views of pre-millennial adventists, in the Christian Advocate of New York. Inasmuch as these views are by no means peculiar to the people who bear the distinctive title of “Adventists,” but are dearly cherished by many devoted Christians in all denominations, we might naturally look for a defense of pre-millennialism from some high quarter, in response to the unfair strictures of Bishop Thoburn in the great Methodist journal. Nor are we disappointed, for Rev. Dr. Hiscox, in the Boston Watchman, makes a vigorous reply, from which we make a few extracts. Referring to the fact that the Bishop’s article is copied by the Western Recorder, and pronounced “able and temperate” by that journal, Dr. H. says:—p. 100 I should hesitate to call it either. For within the same space it would be difficult to find more perversions and misrepresentations of the views of any company of Christians by a fellow Christian, doubtless through inattention to or ignorance of the facts. This clergyman may be thoroughly competent to discharge the duties of a Methodist bishop, but no man is qualified to discuss an opposing theory, especially with destructive criticism, unless he possesses a fairly accurate knowledge of the theory he opposes, and also has a strong enough sense of justice not to misrepresent what he condemns.
The Bishop states the views of the pre-adventists thus:—
“The world, we are told, is growing worse, and hastening to its doom. Great victories under the banner of Christ are no more to be expected. The present dispensation, like the one preceding it, is a failure. The Devil, at present and in this world, is mightier for evil than Christ is to defeat him.” There are four distinct statements claiming to represent the views of the pre-millennarians. The first is a half-truth, the three others are old, stale stock objections, bandied about over and over again by the post-adventists, and are misrepresentations without truth, at least, so far as I am acquainted with their published faith. A bishop ought not to be a sophist. The world is growing worse, and it is growing better, too. To me it seems safe to say that in no preceding period of the world’s history was there so much good or so much evil in the world as now. Both are intensified. The moral forces at work among men, both the good and the bad, are more subtle in their nature, more determined in their purpose, act on broader spheres, more comprehensive in their plans, and more inveterate in their spirit; like two hostile armies, they are preparing for one grand and final conflict, a last and decisive battle, and no one who believes in God and truth and the divine promises can doubt where the ultimate victory will be found.
This is but a statement, in other words, of the great fact, soon to be fully realized, that the “harvest of the earth is ripe.” The influences, both of good and evil, are fast doing their work in the world, and the harvest is ripening for the sickle of Him who cometh on the great white cloud.
But who teaches that “great victories under the banner of Christ are no more to be expected”? That statement is well-nigh a libel on the faith and works of many of the most devoted Christians of this age. A large part of the missionaries in foreign fields, whose lives are consecrated to gospel service amidst pagan darkness, cherish this condemned faith, and find it their inspiration in doing hopeful work for Christ, . . . while the carpet-knights of polemic theology are carping at the blessed hope that cheers their hearts. . . . Many of the most devoted and successful Christian workers scattered all over the home field, are of like precious faith.
Who teaches that “the present dispensation, like the preceding one, is a failure”?—No pre-millenarian, to my knowledge. . . . The preceding dispensation had its work assigned, and accomplished it,—a work of preparation and education. The present dispensation is accomplishing its purpose, save the deadness of the hearts and the unfaithfulness of the lives of God’s people. But what was the purpose of the present dispensation? Our post-adventist teachers say its mission is to convert the world, bring in the millennium, and then welcome Christ to his established throne and kingdom. But does the New Testament teach that? Do the prophecies teach that? Where? Cite the statements. But our Lord said, “And this gospel of the kingdom shall be preached in all the world, for a witness unto all nations; and then shall the end come.” Did he say it should convert all the world before he came?—Oh, no. It was to be preached “for a witness unto all nations.” That is being done; and if faithfully done, is the gospel a failure?
Referring to the charge that pre-millennialism ascribes more power to the Devil than to Christ, Dr. H. quotes the numerous scriptures that represent Satan as the “god of this world,” etc., and adds:—
It is evident that the Devil told more truth than he was accustomed to tell when on the mount of observation he declared to Jesus that all the kingdoms of the world and the glory of them were his. His assertion was not disputed, though his offer was rejected. It is made as an accusation against the pre-brethren that they hold the world will never be converted by the present gospel methods and with the present appliances. Well, if this conviction be an error or a crime, will the post-brethren tell us how long, with the present appliances, it will take to convert the world, at the present rate of progress? If while five millions of converts have been won from heathendom during the present century of missionary activity, during the same century twenty-five millions have been added to heathendom by the natural increase of population?
The writer closes by declaring the article of Bishop Thoburn as “only one of the many incidental attacks so common, on a phase of Christian doctrine, which is venerable enough, and valuable enough to demand the respect, if it cannot command the credence, of all good men.”