It is not in America only that opponents of the doctrine that the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord, are in utter discord and confusion among themselves; the same state of things exists in England also, as some items herewith presented clearly show.
This diversity of sentiment shows one of two things,—either that the Bible has given no definite instruction on the subject, or that men have sadly departed from its teaching. But when we look at the testimony of the Bible on this question, we find it just as simple, plain, and direct as language can express it: “The seventh day is the Sabbath.” And all who take this as it reads, and act upon it, have no trouble with the question; they are united; all others are in confusion. This should be sufficient evidence to all that the trouble arises from the efforts of men to evade the commandments of God.
In October last, it seems, there was a meeting held in England with reference to the question of Sunday-keeping, reported in the papers as “The Cardiff Church Congress on the Question of Sunday Observance.” At this Conference there were about as many differing opinions expressed as there were different speakers. Thus the “Right Hon. Earl Beauchamp” expressed the opinion that the old “Judaical observance of the Sabbath has passed away, never to return,” and at the same time acknowledged that it was impossible to frame laws which would secure “the due observance of Sunday.”
He was followed by Mr. George Frederick Chambers, F. R. A. S., Barrister-at-law, Northfield Grange, who repudiated the idea that the Sabbath had anything Jewish about it; it dates, he said, from the origin of the human race; when instituted, it was binding on the whole human race; having never been abrogated, it is binding still; but the Church has substituted the first day for the seventh, and this may therefore be “reasonably regarded as in accordance with our Lord’s will.” The desecration of Sunday, he asserted, came principally from the upper classes, and betokened future mischief.
This plainly rests the keeping of Sunday on the basis of the original commandment. But this did not seem to suit. So the Rev. Robert Linklater, D. D., Vicar of Holy Trinity, Stroud Green, followed, and said: “The popular idea is that we are to keep Sunday, because of God’s command to his ancient people, the Jews. If this is really the case, and a true reason for our duty, we are frightfully guilty in the matter, and we deserve a Babylonian captivity to punish us for our desecrated Sabbaths, since from the very beginning the Church has deliberately broken this commandment, not only in neglecting the specified duties and religious acts of the Sabbath, but ignoring the very day itself. If the old commandment is still binding, there is nothing more to be said; we must keep it to the very letter.”
Mr. Linklater’s expression in the foregoing extract—“the very day itself”—shows that he has no question as to what day is meant by the “seventh day” of the commandment. And on this point the Church of England generally are agreed, that the week is a fixed and definite period of time, and that it has come down, just as we now have it, from the remotest historic ages.
But looking upon Sunday as a mere Church institution, it is not strange that they should begin to feel that where divine sanction was wanting, a little laxity on their part could easily be tolerated; so the “Rev. C. T. Roberts, Curate of St. Clements, Notting-hill,” said: “Hitherto we have tried to keep Sunday exclusively for religious purposes. I was brought up with the idea that to take a walk on Sunday was on a par to taking my neighbor’s purse, or taking God’s name in vain; and to read any other book but the Bible was ruinous to my soul; and the only thing to do was to go to church as much as one could, and for the rest of the day to ‘yawn.’ The tendency, however, at the present day, is in the direction opposite to this. The upper ten and the lower million are breaking loose very rapidly from the state of intellectual and physical bondage to which they have been hitherto supposed to submit upon the Sunday.”
And then the “Rev. J. T. Jeffcock” took a still wilder plunge, and practically nullified all idea of a Sabbath, by making the Lord’s day something to be observed every day. He said: “There has always been a distinction between the Sabbath and the first day of the week. The way for a Christian to keep the Lord’s day, is to ‘keep the Lord always before him?’ Christ has called Christians to liberty, and they must stand fast in that liberty. (Cheers.) He believed the sin of Sabbath-breaking was extinct. . . . When he was first ordained, he used to have a cold dinner on Sunday, but he did not go in for that now. (Laughter.)”
Rev. E. W. Sergeant wanted those who believed that Sunday rested on the fourth commandment, to show where God had changed the day; for he said, “The same Authority alone that fixed the day can change it.” “And if he has done so,” he asked, “when was it done, and why did the Eastern Christians for nearly three centuries observe both days?”
Lord Norton thought it a strange thing to say that the fourth commandment was secondary and temporary, and had been abolished.
Canon Stowell agreed that people kept the Lord’s day on the authority of the Church, but the Church appealed to the authority of the commandment; and he asked, if the fourth commandment was purely ceremonial, why it was inserted among commandments which were of purely moral obligation.
Canon Lucock thought the primitive Church the safest authority to trust.
Captain Toynbee said he was moved almost to tears to hear clergymen of the Church of England speak as some of them had on this question.
The Dean of Manchester thought Sunday was the day of recreation for the human trinity of body, soul, and spirit.
Canon McCormick said it had been said that the Church gave them the Sabbath. He denied this. God gave it. The moral law existed long before the giving of the law on Mount Sinai. God intended the day to be a holy one, and not a day for carrying out our own pleasures.
Rev. A. G. Goldsmith said, with what strikes us to be a tinge of grim sarcasm, that all the speakers were agreed that “one day in the week should be given to something or other.” That is about as near as any one can come to it, when he departs from the word of God.
Prebendary Grier did not hesitate to declare himself a Sabbatarian, and did not agree that Sabbath-breaking was simply a sin of the past.
And thus the matter went on, till it appeared that in “a single diocesan conference” there were something like “fifty different opinions concerning Sunday observance;” but it was thought that this state of disagreement in regard to the institution “must be kept from the people, lest they lose what little respect they have for the day.”
Is God the author of all this confusion?—Nay verily. What a foundation does the Sunday stand upon, and how long, under these circumstances, can respect for it be maintained, when its self-constituted guardians know in their own hearts that it is entitled to no respect? Like Saul, who sought to the woman of Endor because the Lord had departed from him, so the determined champions of Sunday are seeking the assistance of the sword of Caesar because they get no help from God.
The foregoing facts relative to the meeting referred to, we gather from the Sabbath Memorial of December, 1889, quoted from the Guardian of Oct. 16, and the Sussex Daily News of Oct. 24, 1889.