According to the Cleveland Leader of Feb. 25, 1890, the Baptists of Cleveland have become very much stirred up by the teaching of Seventh-day Adventists that man is unconscious in death. We so judge because at the weekly conference of Baptist ministers, held at the Euclid Avenue Baptist church, a Mr. L. H. Harriman was appointed to read a paper in reply to the assertion of S. D. Adventists named above. His paper was entitled, “Does the Soul Sleep in Life or Death?” The very title of his essay betrays the utter misapprehension under which popular theology is still groping on this question. He will have it that the soul is a separate entity, carrying on an existence independent of the body, and to be treated in every supposable condition apart from the body. Thus our theological teachers make man a dual being instead of a unit as the Bible represents him, and so long as they are handicapped with this misconception, correct conclusions cannot be expected from them. Until they can divest themselves of the old pagan notion of duality, and accept the Bible view that man, as an intelligent morally responsible being, is a unit, their discussions of the subject are vain. Why do they not sometimes consider such a proposition as this: Does a man’s head sleep in death? But Mr. H.’s subject ran him, by its very title, into a dilemma from which he did not attempt to extricate himself. The inquiry was, whether the soul ever sleeps in life or death. This obliged him to consider the condition of the soul in natural sleep. And what did he say?—Simply this: that the Bible was not a book of metaphysics, and did not tell us. Does it need to tell us? Does not every one know that in sound sleep, he is entirely unconscious? What is this separate entity, the popular soul, doing all this time? Again, when a man’s eyes are destroyed, he is blind, and never will see again in this world unless his eyes are restored. Has that man at the same time a soul that can see, but won’t? What kind of a thing is this soul that cannot see without the eyes of the body, nor hear without its ears, nor talk without its vocal organs, nor feel without its nerves, nor taste without its tongue, nor smell without its nose, nor walk without its legs? Can it think without its brain? And if the impairment of these organs of the body in life, restricts or totally arrests the operations of the soul in these directions, is it conceivable that when these organs are all totally destroyed in death, then the soul immediately springs forth to see and hear and feel, and exercise all the faculties now possessed by the body, and a thousand others, in absolute perfection? Shades of philosophy, where have ye fled!
Cleveland Baptists Respond to Adventist Teaching on Death
From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 12., March 25, 1890