AdventAI

CANDOR AND DUPLICITY IN CHILDHOOD.

By Dr. Felix L. Oswald

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 12., March 25, 1890

Young children are naturally truthful. Their candor is not founded on any conscious deference to dogmatic precepts, but on an instinctive recognition of the fact that sincerity is the simplest way of dealing with the problems of intellectual communication. Prevarication requires inventiveness, dissimulation, sophistry, subterfuge, caution, effrontery, and impudence. Candor requires only loyalty to facts. In the mind of infancy the very idea of falsehood is associated with the dread of risk and detection. Animals amuse us by the absolute unreservedness of their conduct; every impulse at once betrays itself into action; the working of their mental organism can be read like an open book. Yet cornered animals, even of the less intelligent species, are apt to become tricky, and in stress of circumstances, human weakness, too, resorts to subterfuge and deceit. In young children the habit of prevarication is generally preceded by an habitual disguisement of conduct, suggested by injudicious restraint or excessive severity in the punishment of trifling offenses. The asceticism of the Middle Ages evolved a veritable training-school of dissimulation. Hypocrisy, for ages, remained the only alternative to the risk of open dissent, and similar causes will limit the chances for the development of even a naturally ingenuous disposition. Children, subjected to the discipline of a home where every cheerful impulse of their young souls is suppressed as sinful, naturally come to regard eternal dissimulation as the price of liberty, and prevaricate with the full sanction of their physical conscience, and under the constant impulse of reaction against the irksomeness of unnatural restraint. Conning catechisms while his schoolmates are enjoying their holidays, and the woodlands with a thousand voices invite to mirth and play, awakens rebellious instincts, which, sooner or later, must lead the most honest boy to the expedient of duplicity.

“Tyrannous bigots,” says Condorcet, “forfeit the right to hear the truth, if they punish loyalty to nature and freedom as a capital offense.” Parents should beware of giving their children cause for justifying dissimulation by a similar logic. Inhuman severity alone is apt to pervert the innate candor of the infant soul. If children have been taught by experience that the detection, even of a venial sin, is invariably followed by desperate penalties, it would be absurd to expect the desire of averting such consequences to be scrupulously fastidious in the choice of means. Stoicism is not a virtue of childhood, and the instinct of self-preservation from extremes of cruelty is as pardonable in the evasive pleas of a frightened child as in the evasive leaps of a frightened rabbit. Children will never acquire the habit of duplicity if they are made to realize how much easier it is to stick to the truth, and how decidedly, on the whole, it is also the safer plan.—Dr. Felix L. Oswald, in the Home Magazine.