AdventAI

THE LATEST ENCYCLICAL.

By Editor

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 9., March 4, 1890

The difficulties surrounding the problem of how to be a good American citizen and a good Catholic at the same time, have not been lessened by the latest encyclical issue from Rome by Leo XIII. This papal letter of instructions was doubtless intended to have its first and most direct application to the subjects of King Humbert, but the obligation of observing its teachings will rest none the less strongly upon Roman Catholic citizens of every country in the world. To the general principle enunciated in the encyclical, that when the laws of a State come into direct conflict with the laws of God, it is the duty of the Christian citizen to obey the latter rather than the former, of course we express no dissent. We can agree also with such generalities as that “when Christian institutions and morals fall away, the principal foundations of human society must crumble,” and that “every offense against religion recoils on the State.” Such excellent thoughts as these are scattered all through the encyclical, and it is only when the context is supplied and the document is considered, as a whole, that its real and large significance appears.

It will be observed in reading the encyclical that the pope does not limit the duty of disobedience, in a case like that just mentioned, to the laws of God as against the laws of the State, but he carries the principle further by making the laws and teachings of the Roman Church of equal authority with the divine laws and teachings. In other words, in case of a conflict between the authority of the Roman Church and that of the State, the citizen is to obey the former rather than the latter. This is made clear in the following passage: “If the laws of the State are in open contradiction of the divine law, if they command anything prejudicial to the Church, or hostile to the duties imposed by religion, or violate in the person of the supreme pontiff the authority of Jesus Christ, then, indeed, it is a duty to resist them and a crime to obey them,—a crime fraught with injury to the State itself.” It is evident that the clause, “if they command anything prejudicial to the [Roman Catholic] church,” places a very large and dangerous discretion in the matter of obedience in the hands of the citizen. So also does that clause regarding the violation “in the person of the supreme pontiff,” of the authority of Jesus Christ. In its literal and strict application this means that when any law is passed or any action taken by any government which may be deemed “prejudicial” to the interests of the Roman Church, it becomes the duty of the Catholic citizen to resist, and a crime to obey. This may seem to be a hard construction upon the language used in the encyclical, but it is a consistent and logical construction.

Apply the doctrine here enunciated to such a familiar and vital issue as that of the taxation of Roman Catholics in this country for the support of common schools, and we are brought face to face at once with a very grave difficulty. The Roman priesthood and their newspaper organs have been engaged for years in a bitter and persistent assault upon our public school system. The statement has been made again and again, with increasing emphasis, that the laws requiring Roman Catholic citizens to contribute to the support of common schools are unjust, tyrannical, and outrageous. It has been understood, of course, that this opposition was sanctioned, if not directly authorized, by the Roman pontiff, but never before has the duty of Romanists in a case like this been set forth in such plain and direct language as now. Under this latest pronunciamiento from the Vatican we fail to see how any good and loyal “son of the church” can longer render even a tacit obedience to the law which requires him to pay a tax for the support of common schools. This law is manifestly “prejudicial” to the interests of the Roman Church, from the Romanist point of view, and therefore it must be resisted at all hazards. It is unnecessary to carry this arraignment further than to say that a strict application of the principle under consideration to existing conditions in this country, could result in nothing else than an open rebellion against the laws of the land. We do not apprehend that matters will come to this issue, but if they do not it will not be because rebellion is not made justifiable by the tenet of this latest papal document.

We have not space to dwell upon other passages in the encyclical which tend to a further complication of the problem as to where the duty of a Romanist to his church ends and his duty to the State begins. We are told that “in politics, which are inseparably bound up with the laws of morality and religious duties, men ought always and in the first place to take care to serve the interest of Catholicism.” And again, “that whenever it is lawful in the eyes of the church to take part in public affairs, men of recognized probity and who promise to merit well of Catholicism ought to be supported.”

We can do no more at this time than call attention to these passages as embodying teachings which, we believe, are fraught with danger to our free and republican institutions. When our Roman Catholic citizens are instructed by the head of their church that in politics “men ought always and in the first place to take care to serve the interests of Catholicism,” (the italics are ours,) what are we to expect as the result of the practical application of such teaching?—Christian at Work.