Can the Papacy's Lost Temporal Power Be Restored?
The dominion of the papacy having, according to the prophecy, been taken away to be consumed and destroyed unto the end (Dan. 7: 26), can it ever be restored? It is the conviction of discerning and thoughtful men that the fretting of Leo XIII. over the loss of temporal power does not voice the feeling of the Catholic world at large, but that there is a growing tendency on the part of Catholics to abandon all claims for a temporal sovereignty on behalf of the pope. For instance, according to the Independent of Feb. 27, 1890, there has just appeared an “important” book, entitled “Theological Criteria,” by Canon di Bartolo, which bears the imprimatur of the Cardinal Archbishop of Turin, and the translation of which into French has the sanction of the Vicar-General of Rennes, and which is approved by Archbishop Manning and Bishop Hefele. This book openly denies the right of the church to a physical coercion, and claims that all it can rightfully exercise is a “moral coercion.” On the subject of infallibility the Canon says that the rule must be that of minimum, to reduce the application of it as far as may be; and he states one point to which he would have it apply, as follows: “The Roman pontiffs are not infallible in the assertion of their right to temporal dominion in the pontifical states.” This position he is said to support “by quotations from Catholic writers to the effect that the temporal power is not of divine right nor essential to the papacy, nor the object of a dogmatic definition.” The Independent adds: “Such utterances published with high ecclesiastical permission or approval, confirm what we have more than once said as to the drift in the Catholic Church.”