AdventAI

PROSECUTION OR PERSECUTION—WHICH?

By E. E. Marvin

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 9., March 4, 1890

BY ELD. E. E. MARVIN.

(Cross Plains, Tenn.)

That the recent attacks upon Seventh-day Adventists in Obion and Dyer counties, Tenn., are in no sense civil prosecutions, urged on by a patriotic desire to maintain the “peace and dignity of the State,” but religious persecution in every sense, is obvious from the following considerations:—

1. Men who had no religion were not disturbed by the Sunday work of any class.

2. Those who profess to have religion were not disturbed by the Sunday work of men who had no religion or of those whose religion was like their religion in respect to a sacred day, though both classes and all classes did Sunday work. If men who have no religion, and profess to have none, are not disturbed by the Sunday work of any class, let them have religion, no religion, or a mere profession of religion; and men who profess to have religion are disturbed neither by those who have no religion nor by those whose religion is like theirs in respect to a sacred day; then it is plainly seen that the disturbance arises entirely from the fact that the Sunday work was done by those who had a particular religion which was not like their religion in respect to a sacred day; therefore, it is religious persecution by those who profess to have religion, against those who do have it, because of the difference in their religion.

It is evident, then, that the Tennessee Sunday law is but a legal birch placed in the hands of one class of religionists, to be applied to the backs of other religionists who choose to differ with them in respect to the day of rest, and is, therefore, unconstitutional and un-American,—a stepping-stone to a despotism which was reached in other ages in the same way. It is but to ask and demand that one class shall bow to the religious bigotry and iron-bound prejudice of another class.

Thus far, with one exception, the Tennessee Sunday law has taken effect on Seventh-day Adventists, and the one exception was dismissed by supreme court decision. The operations of law is its proper definition. And in the operations of this Sunday law, all first-day people and all no-day people have been, thus far, exempt from its penalties. It follows, then, that this Sunday law embraces wide and liberal exemptions in its operations, for all except seventh-day-keepers. The logic of opposition to exemptions for seventh-day people, on the grounds that all are not exempt, fades into insignificance before the facts of Sunday-law operations; for in these all others are exempt. The only power the law has, is spent on seventh-day-keepers. On these grounds, then, an exemption for the latter class would leave the law wholly inoperative.