AdventAI

TOO MUCH ASSUMPTION.

By W. A. C.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 4., January 28, 1890

The attention of the Michigan Catholic, published at Detroit, was called by Bro. Ballenger to an extract from a sermon delivered by Father Enright at Harlan, Ia., not long ago, the greater part of which appeared in the REVIEW of Jan. 14. In doing so, Bro. B. stated that “the move now being made by some Protestant ministers to enforce Sunday observance by law, is calling attention to the foundation of the religious observance of the day.” In commenting upon this, the above paper, under date of Jan. 23, states that what Father Enright says has been said a thousand times, and is true, and then inquires:—

But what good will the knowledge of this fact do Mr. Ballenger? It may enable him to charge Sunday-sabbath Protestants with inconsistency, in protesting against the Catholic Church while adopting one of its institutions and following one of its laws. But Mr. Ballenger might just as properly charge them with inconsistency in using the Scriptures, which they received from the Catholic Church. Indeed, he might as properly charge them with inconsistency in being Christians; for all the Christian truth there is in Protestantism is received from the Catholic Church.

There is altogether too much assumption here. This implies that the Sunday-sabbath, the Scriptures, and the truths of Christianity, all rest upon the same foundation, a statement which we are by no means ready to admit. That professed Protestants are inconsistent in claiming to ignore the authority of the Catholic Church while clinging to one of its institutions, is true; but that there is a like inconsistency in their using the Scriptures or professing the truths of Christianity, we deny. The Catholic Church may lay claim to everything high and holy on earth and in purgatory (?) and out of it, but we have yet to see its patent on truth, or its copyright, with “all rights reserved,” on the Holy Scriptures. It is one thing to institute a claim, and quite another to sustain it.

With the apostle John, we believe that “grace and truth came by Jesus Christ,” and not by the Roman Catholic Church. With Paul, we agree that “all Scripture is given by inspiration of God,” and not by an apostate libel upon a once true church. The Roman Catholic Church is neither the author nor the sole preserver of the Scriptures. No doubt it would gladly have assumed a monopoly of these sacred writings, and shut out their pure light from the world by obliterating at one fell stroke every copy of God’s word except those under its immediate control, as is evident from its well-known efforts in this direction, martyring thousands for reading it or being found in possession of a copy of it, and pursuing to the death those who dared translate it for the common people to read, as the ashes of a Tyndale and others testify. But God had ordained it to be otherwise. Though so dangerous was Wickliffe’s translation thought to be to the interests of the Romish religion, that a bill was brought into the House of Lords for the purpose of suppressing it, and so great was the opposition to its publication by the Roman Catholic clergy as to cause the bishop of London to endeavor to buy up whole editions as fast as they were printed, to burn them, still Tyndale’s translation survived; and well for the world has it been that the preservation and propagation of the Bible and Bible truths have not depended on the Roman Catholic Church.

Indeed, the world would have had the Bible had there never been a Roman Catholic. Surely it is not dependent upon the Catholic Church for the preservation of the Old Testament. The Jews have preserved that with jealous care. Nor is it any the less true of the New Testament. Very early were the Gospels and Epistles copied, manifolded, and scattered throughout the various countries of Syria, Egypt, Greece, and Italy. The Syriac version of the New Testament which was made before the close of the second century, a translation which is still extant, is of too early origin and not in the right language for Roman Catholicism to lay claim to. Other ancient manuscripts of the Bible with which the Latin Church has had little or nothing to do either in their transcription or preservation, are still extant, such as the Codex Alexandrinus, or Ethiopic version, written in Greek fifteen hundred years ago, and now in the British Museum, having been brought from Alexandria by Cyril Lucar, who was patriarch of that city, and later of Constantinople, and presented in 1628 to Charles I. of England. The Waldenses, who date back as far as the third century, and whose devotion to truth was characterized by their secretly copying and circulating the Scriptures at the peril of their lives, have been another means, independent of the Catholic Church, of preserving in the world a knowledge of God’s word.

It is therefore evident that the statements of the Michigan Catholic are altogether overdrawn, and that its conclusion based upon them is by no means a true one. Of the fact that seventh-day observers can charge Sunday-keeping Protestants with inconsistency, it says:—

But this kind of attack will result as disastrously for Mr. Ballenger’s people as for the Sunday-sabbath Protestants. If these accept the Scriptures from the Catholic Church, so do Mr. Ballenger and the other Seventh-day Adventists. If the Sunday-sabbath Protestants accept their Christian truths from the Catholic Church, so do the Saturday-Sabbath Protestants.

The facts are that Protestants of no kind are dependent upon the Catholic Church for Christian truths. They have learned them from the Bible, which has been preserved independent of that church. But the same is not true of Protestants and the Sunday institution. For the authority to keep this, they are wholly dependent upon the Catholic Church, because, as a supplanter of the true Sabbath in the Christian dispensation, it originated with that church, and not with the Scriptures. The Bible says nothing about keeping the first day of the week. Herein lies the inconsistency of Sunday-keeping Protestants.

But should it be admitted that all are indebted to the Catholic Church for the preservation of the Scriptures, there is one fact that should not be overlooked, and that is, that inconsistency is to be charged upon all Sunday-keepers, whether Protestant or Catholic; for these very Scriptures which have been preserved, by whomsoever it may be, say the seventh day, and not the first, is the Sabbath. Had Catholics desired to appear consistent, they should have changed the Scriptures so as to agree with their change of the Sabbath; but for some reason they failed to do this, perhaps because there were in existence too many copies over which they did not have control, to expose so impious a fraud. By that, therefore, which they claim to be particularly their own, are they condemned.

W. A. C.