Citizens’ Meeting in Washington, D. C.
By J. O. Corliss
From the first mention of a meeting of the citizens of Washington to discuss the Breckinridge Sunday Bill, the idea was met unfavorably. Leading men who were approached on the subject, said that such an attempt would be a failure. The reasons given were, that the people in the District, having no vote on political measures, had no particular interest in public affairs, consequently could not be prevailed upon to attend a meeting of the kind proposed. But when a gentleman generously offered a hall free for the purpose, as related in a former report, we took it as a signal to go ahead in working up such a meeting. Accordingly, after a number of citizens had signed the call for a meeting, our workers in the city took pains to notify all with whom they came in contact, of the time and place of the gathering. Standing notices were then inserted in three dailies; 8,000 handbills, announcing a fair and impartial discussion of the Sunday bill, were distributed; 800 postal cards were sent out with personal invitations to all the lawyers, representatives of the press, the leading clergymen of the city, and the prominent members of the W. C. T. U., besides many other representative citizens. One thing was a little unfortunate—the hall had not been heated before the meeting, and was quite cold. But notwithstanding this, between 500 and 600 people were present. A very popular lawyer, General A. A. Birney, was approached beforehand, and was secured as chairman. When he was nominated at the meeting, and came forward to take the chair, he was greeted with considerable applause, which showed his high standing in the city. He opened the meeting by announcing its object, and a candid examination of the Breckinridge bill, from a legal stand-point. Following are his remarks:— On an analysis of this bill, I find the following to be its prominent features. I find in Section three, two exceptions,—“works of necessity or mercy,” and “any person or persons who shall conscientiously believe in and observe any other day of the week than Sunday, as a day of rest.” A plain interpretation of this law would render unlawful the running of street-cars, railroad cars, and steamboats on Sunday; also the delivery of letters or telegrams, or even driving carriages to church on Sunday. But these, and similar questions, would needs be referred to a police judge to decide. The services of a paid janitor or salaried organist of a church, or a third party (Prohibitionist) meeting, would need to be passed upon, as to whether secular or religious, as such meetings are frequently held, and such labor performed, upon Sunday. The intervention of policemen might also be called in. In the second place, could a professional surgeon receive pay for his Sunday labor? Would a professional physician and surgeon attend upon a patient with very great alacrity on Sunday, if he had no expectation of being paid for it? Where do you draw the line between what is necessary and what is not necessary? If I get my cook to prepare me a warm meal on Sunday, shall my cook and I be fined a hundred dollars for that? Again, who is to decide as to whether a person’s belief is “orthodox” or not? This would be akin to the work of the Inquisition. And thus any one would have the means of gratifying malice, private spite, and personal revenge. What is the necessity for such a law in the District of Columbia? The people of this District have their faults; but why should labor on Sunday be considered one of them? We have some 200 churches in this city, large, and well-filled on Sunday; and there is not a better church-going people in the United States than the people of Washington City. The sound of the trowel is not heard, and building is suspended, on Sunday; and the rights of church-going people are respected here in Washington, equally with those of any city in the Union. This sort of legislation belongs to days which are past. In the early days of Maryland and New England, there was a good deal of it. There is now, on the statute-books of this District, an old Maryland law which has never been repealed, under which a person convicted of denying the Trinity, received the mark “B” in his forehead [reading statute of date Oct. 26, 1723]. I see some here who would stand a bad chance under that law; for instance, my friend Dr. Shippen, pastor of the Unitarian church. I have read this law verbatim, because the present bill of Mr. Breckinridge seems to have been taken from it. Now, are we ready to go back 167 years in our legislation, to revive a law that has been rejected by the common sense of our ancestors? Such a law may be in place in countries where there is a union of Church and State; but it is out of place in this country, where no attempts upon the liberties of the citizen should be tolerated. Now, the only principle upon which a line of this bill could be justified, would be a “sanitary” principle; that is, assuming that it is necessary for health that a man should rest one day out of seven; assuming also that it is the duty of Congress to see that he does not labor more than the six days, and to prescribe a certain day on which he should not work. But that theory has not been sustained by the courts; besides, a great many men do not need that restraint. They have plenty of rest, and a council of physicians would hardly say that it was necessary for them to rest on a certain day out of the seven. But the bill is sought to be justified by the principle that religious congregations should not be disturbed; but such congregations are already amply protected by law. But in order to not make this report too lengthy, and yet get before our readers a good idea of what was said at the meeting, we will here give the condensed statements of one of the Washington dailies, the Washington Critic:— Mr. Alonzo T. Jones, one of the editors of the American Sentinel, a clear-voiced, scholarly-looking man, opposed the bill. His address was eloquent and analytical. He claimed that those who observed Sunday ought to be most vigorous in opposition to the bill, for it threatened religious as well as civil liberty. The bill prohibited secular labor on Sunday. What was meant by the word “secular”? Webster defined it as “pertaining to the present world.” What other world did a United States Congressman know about? Webster also defined “secular” as pertaining to “things not spiritual or holy.” Were not Congressmen, then, carrying their legislation into the realms of religion in violation of the Constitution? The speaker denied the right of any body of men to decide what is the truth in religious matters, and said that the Breckinridge bill for the District was but a forerunner of the Blair bill for the nation. Mr. Louis Abraham said the title of the bill had not been read correctly. “A bill to make hypocrites” was the real title. He charged that the gentlemen who were endeavoring to have the bill passed, generally kept their stenographers at work on Sunday. “If this bill passes,” said he, “it will be as serious a blow to this country as when the first gun was fired on Sumter. It is a blow at the Constitution; for it is the entering wedge in the effort looking to a union of Church and State. It is probably not dangerous per se, but it is one of the branches of a convention to bind you in chains of priesthood and upset the Constitution.” By consenting to the passage of such a bill the people would be simply saying, notwithstanding all their churches: “We are an utter failure. Give us a policeman’s club.” It would be a policeman’s club to-day, but it would be a park of artillery to-morrow. The solitary advocate of the friends of the bill was Police Officer Charles Proctor, who significantly remarked, as he clasped his prayer-book with both hands, that he was not used to addressing audiences of that kind. Grant, he said, had never laughed or cried; but he would cry were he present at that meeting. “God bless the man,” said Officer Proctor, “that framed that bill. God bless him! God bless him! God preserve our Christian Sabbath! Oh, may God and Congress give us one day of rest.” Twenty-three years ago, he said, he was a street-car conductor and had to work on Sunday, but he would not run a car now for a million dollars if it took in the Sabbath. Mr. J. O. Corliss made a vigorous and telling speech in opposition to the bill, his arguments being in the line of those of preceding speakers. Such legislation as the bill proposed to enact, he said, would mean a union of Church and State, and with such a union the civil and religious liberty of American citizens was gone forever. If the laws of God and the laws of the land were synonymous, only a Romish Inquisition could inquire into infractions of them. But they were not synonymous. Every man must have a conscience, religion, and faith for himself. There was a way to maintain the Sabbath, and that was by persons who were interested in it; but such laws as the Breckinridge bill could do nothing more or less than make hypocrites. In such legislation the Government would say: “God isn’t able to take care of his Sabbath day, and so we will make ourselves God’s guardian.” But if the Government would take care of the civil interests, God would look after religious matters. Mr. H. Enoch mildly and briefly opposed the bill, and Mr. A. T. Jones offered a series of resolutions protesting against its passage or the passage of any bill of similar import, because, among other reasons, such a bill would be a departure from the fundamental principle of the institutions of this country, which recognizes the right of a citizen to do as he pleases, provided he does not encroach upon the rights of others. It would tend to subvert the character of the Government in derogation of the Constitution, and was a long step backward instead of forward in human progress. Just as the resolutions were being put to the audience, Mr. Steele impressively endeavored to read a section of the Constitution, but his voice was drowned in the volume of “Ayes,” by which the resolutions were carried. The “Noes,” were very feeble, with one exception, that of a lady whose negative was loud, defiant, and emphatic. After the resolutions were adopted, Mr. G. E. Fifield delivered a lengthy address in opposition to the bill, going over the whole ground covered by the resolutions. He dealt largely with the argument that the passage of the bill was a sanitary necessity, and denied the right of the State to say on what day he should rest or whether he should rest at all. Some men needed more rest than others, and some, including many of the friends of the bill, got more rest than was good for them. It was ridiculous to assert that it was a sanitary necessity to have one’s milk delivered before five o’clock in the morning. But if any sanitary laws were to be enacted for him, he preferred to have them framed by the doctors, not by the churchmen. The resolutions referred to in the foregoing were these:— Resolved, That the bill (H. R. 3854), entitled: “An act to prevent persons from being forced to labor on Sunday,” does not meet our approbation, but that we do earnestly protest against its passage, or the passage of any bill of similar import, for the following reasons, to wit:— 1st. There is no call or occasion for the passage of such a law. No person in the District of Columbia is, or has been, forced to labor on Sunday against his will, at any time since the abolition of slavery therein. 2d. Works of necessity or mercy are not defined in the bill, and their meaning and application are left to the arbitrary prejudice or caprice of police magistrates. Under such a law street-cars, railroad trains, steamboats, and private carriages might be stopped, and a citizen might be fined for preaching, for shaving himself, or having his dinner cooked on Sunday. 3d. Such a law would be a departure from the fundamental principle of the institutions of this country, which recognizes the right of a citizen to do as he pleases, provided he does not encroach upon the rights of others; and it empowers a police judge to inquire into and decide upon the conscientious belief of any citizen charged with doing, or causing to be done, secular work on Sunday. 4th. The passage of such a law is designed as, and in effect would be, an entering wedge for a system of aggressive laws tending to subvert the secular character of our Government in derogation of the Constitution, and the religious freedom of the citizen guaranteed thereby. 5th. The proposed law partakes of the most offensive features of the early laws of New England, Maryland, and other colonies of the olden time, known as “Blue laws,” and is therefore a long step backward, instead of forward in human progress. This meeting has given our work in the city more prominence than anything else we could have done. We now await the action of the American Sabbath Union Convention, to commence to-night, which will determine the further course we shall pursue in our efforts against religious legislation. J. O. C.